ISIS advances puncture Kurdistan self-confidence
The gunmen launched their surprise attack in the dark, approaching with a stealth and discipline honed by years of fighting in Syria. Within hours, the fighters of the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, known as Isis, had routed the Kurdish peshmerga warriors guarding the northwest Iraqi towns, killing dozens and menacing the rest of Kurdistan.
"The Mujahideen conquered several areas controlled by secular Kurdish gangs and militias, said a statement issued by Isis. May God Almighty allow his Mujahideen to liberate the whole region.
Iraqs Kurds can point to tremendous accomplishments in the autonomous region they have carved out since the imposition of the western no-fly zone over northern Iraq 23 years ago. They have built up the long-neglected regions economy and infrastructure, transformed what was long a guerrilla force into a regular standing army and won international praise as they edge closer toward the full independence they crave. But in addition to puncturing the Kurds brash self-confidence, the fall of the towns of Sinjar, Zumar and Wana exposed the weaknesses and vulnerabilities of Iraqi Kurds go-it-alone strategy since Isis cataclysmic June 10 advance into northwestern Iraq. It should serve as a wake-up call: the Kurdistan experiment may not survive the Isis challenge without help from Baghdad and western or regional allies.
Immediately after the collapse of Baghdads rule in parts of Iraqs Nineveh, Salahadin, Kirkuk and Diyala provinces, Kurds surged into areas they had long coveted and held tight, engaging in occasional skirmishes with Isis, but mostly staying out of the groups way in what many considered a de facto truce. Under the leadership of longtime Kurdish politician Masoud Barzani, they were comforted by the goodwill of the west and neighbouring Turkey and lulled into a false sense of security by the plaudits bestowed on their peshmerga in comparison with the performance of Iraqi troops.
But a different portrait of the Kurdish fighters emerged in the past few days, what analyst Emile Hokayem described on Twitter as a collection of old fighters, few [in number], badly trained young ones equipped with old weaponry and contending with new territory to defend.
Any hope of a truce or arrangement with Isis was quickly dashed as it became clear the group never intended to give Kurds a pass. The Islamic State wanted to postpone the Kurdish battle, but geographically speaking and because of the escalation of events the Islamic state had to enter this battle now, a Syria-based spokesman for the group told the Financial Times. The Islamic State wants all its territory without borders from Iraq to the Levant.
Kurds have downplayed their losses in the northwest of Iraq, even as Isis threatened to take control of a crucial dam that controls much of the water heading toward southern Iraq. What has happened is the fighting there continues, said Dindar Zebari, a Kurdistan Regional Government official. I believe the peshmerga forces are reorganising themselves and they have the support of the public. If they have made a tactical withdrawal or even were defeated that doesnt mean it was a huge failure."
But by many accounts, the Kurds only managed to rally against Isis in the latest battle after the intervention of Syrian Kurdish fighters of the Kurdistan Workers Party who crossed the non-existent border to come to the help of Iraqi brethren who had largely shunned them. The Syrian Kurds have been fighting Isis for years, and have far more battle experience against them than Iraqis.
Mr Zebari dismissed the role of the Syrian Kurds, arguing that Iraqi Kurds have been battling Islamist militants, including Isiss Iraqi predecessors, since the 1990s. But as numerous commentators, including retired US General Robert H. Scales and Douglas Ollivant, a former US National Security Council member, have pointed out, Isis belongs to a new breed of Islamist militants that are far more intelligent, disciplined, well-trained and battle-hardened than their forebears.
For the sake of Kurdistan if not for the Iraq they appear poised to abandon, Kurdish leaders in Erbil desperately need to cultivate outside help to fend off this challenge.
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/2022c9ca-1bd7-11e4-adc7-00144feabdc0.html