Advertisement

فاٹا : نقصان کا سبب فوج کی حکمتِ عملی

http://www.bbc.co.uk/urdu/pakistan/2014/01/140128_fata_idps_seminar_zs.shtml

پاکستان کے قبائلی علاقوں میں جاری جنگ سے بچنے کی خاطر نقل مکانی کرنے والے افراد کے بارے میں ایک تازہ رپورٹ میں کہا گیا ہے کہ قبائلیوں کی اکثریت اپنے نقصانات کا بڑا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی دہشت گردی کے خاتمے کی حکمتِ عملی کو مانتی ہے۔
قبائلی علاقوں سے نقل مکانی کرنے والے ڈیڑھ لاکھ خاندان اب بھی علاقے کی غیر یقینی صورتِ حال میں بہتری اور امداد کے منتظر ہیں۔
قبائلی علاقہ جات

اسلام آباد میں واقع ایک نجی تھنک ٹینک ’فاٹا ریسرچ سینٹر‘ کی اس رپورٹ میں کہا گیا ہے کہ قبائلی علاقوں میں فوج کی حکمتِ عملی سے متعلق لوگوں کے ذہنوں میں بہت ابہام ہے۔
سروے کے مطابق 93 فیصد قبائلی اپنے مکانات اور دیگر املاک کی تباہی کے لیے فوجی کارروائیوں کو موردِ الزام ٹھہراتے ہیں
.
سروے کے مطابق تقریباً 70 فیصد متاثرین اپنے علاقوں میں امن قائم ہونے کی صورت میں گھروں کو واپس جانا چاہتے ہیں۔

"صوبائی حکومت ایک جانب تو دھرنوں کے ذریعے ڈرون حملوں کے خلاف احتجاج کر رہی ہے لیکن اس سردی میں متاثرین کو دوسری جگہ منتقل کر کے ان پر ڈرون حملے کر رہی ہے۔"
​

گلاب خان


صوبہ خیبر پختونخوا میں واقع جلوزئی کیمپ کے متاثرین کے ایک رہنما گلاب خان نے اس موقعے پر اپنے خطاب میں عمران خان کی تحریکِ انصاف کی حکومت کے رویے سے متعلق بھی شکایت کی۔
ان کا کہنا تھا کہ سرد موسم کی وجہ سے انہوں نے صوبائی حکومت سے مارچ تک کی مہلت مانگی تھی لیکن وہ دینے کو تیار نہیں لہذا انھیں عدالت سے رجوع کرنا پڑا۔
گلاب خان کا کہنا تھا کہ صوبائی حکومت ایک جانب تو دھرنوں کے ذریعے ڈرون حملوں کے خلاف احتجاج کر رہی ہے لیکن اس سردی میں ان متاثرین کو دوسری جگہ منتقل کر کے ان پر ڈرون حملے کر رہی ہے۔ ان کا کہنا تھا کہ انھیں عالمی قوانین کے تحت ان کا حق دیا جائے۔
فاٹا ڈیزاسٹر مینیجمنٹ اتھارٹی کے ایک اہل کار حسیب نے بتایا کہ ڈیڑھ لاکھ خاندان اب بھی کیمپوں یا اپنے رشتہ داروں کے پاس پناہ لیے ہوئے ہیں۔ انھوں نے بتایا کہ باجوڑ اور مہمند ایجنسیوں سے تمام متاثرین واپس لوٹ چکے ہیں لیکن باقی ایجنسیوں سے تعلق رکھنے والے ہزاروں افراد آج بھی خراب حالات کی وجہ سے غیر یقینی صورتِ حال کا شکار ہیں اور پناہ گزین ہیں۔
فوج پر الزام

111106133105_south_waziistan_304x171__nocredit.jpg

93 فیصد قبائلی اپنے مکانات اور دیگر املاک کی تباہی کے لیے فوجی کارروائیوں کو موردِ الزام ٹھہراتے ہیں۔

ان کا کہنا تھا کہ ان متاثرین کی دیکھ بھال کی کسی قومی پالیسی کی عدم موجودگی میں آگے چل کر ان کے مسائل میں اضافہ ہو سکتا ہے۔

قبائلی علاقے شمالی وزیرستان سے حکمران جماعت مسلم لیگ ن کے رکن قومی اسمبلی محمد نذیر نے حکومت کی جانب سے عملی اقدامات کی یقین دہانی کرائی۔ ان کا کہنا تھا کہ ان متاثرین کی واپسی پر ان کی اقتصادی بحالی پر بھی توجہ دینی ہوگی۔
فاٹا سینٹر کے ڈاکٹر اشرف علی کا اس موقعے پر کہنا تھا کہ اس وقت قبائلی علاقوں سے متعلق حکومتی پالیسی میں مکمل ابہام پایا جاتا ہے اور ’ہمیں نہیں معلوم ہم کس سمت میں جا رہے ہیں۔
‘
شمالی وزیرستان میں گذشتہ دنوں فوجی کارروائی کی وجہ سے نقل مکانی کرنے والوں کی تازہ لہر آئی تھی اور خدشہ ہے کہ اگر اس قسم کی مزید کارروائیاں اگر ہوئیں تو متاثرین کا مسئلہ مزید شدت اختیار کر سکتا ہے۔

​
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#1578

Sab say pahlay koee in nakal-makani kernay waloon say yay poochay kay app dehshat-gerdoon ko panah hi kyoon daytay hain.

yay jo Guns rakhi huee hain yay kia Pakana (Gubbara = Balloon) pharnay lay leay rakhi huee hain. kyoon aanay daytay hain apnay area may.

Gayhoon kay sath ghun to pista hi hay.. (thumbsdown)
 
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#

Sab say pahlay koee in nakal-makani kernay waloon say yay poochay kay app dehshat-gerdoon ko panah hi kyoon daytay hain.

yay jo Guns rakhi huee hain yay kia Pakana (Gubbara = Balloon) pharnay lay leay rakhi huee hain. kyoon aanay daytay hain apnay area may.

Gayhoon kay sath ghun to pista hi hay.. (thumbsdown)
Dhehshat gard aayai nahi un ko banaya gaya hai.... farak hai aur is tarah to dhehshat gard poorai pakistan mai hain karachi, lahore, south punjab aur balochistan bhara para hai, Phir order karoo PAF Ko kai karai bambari har jagah, aanai do drones poorai pakistan mai aur army bhi shelling karain jaha us ka dil karain... yee dohri policy kabails par hee kyoon lagoo hoti hai ...
 
Advertisement
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#

Sab say pahlay koee in nakal-makani kernay waloon say yay poochay kay app dehshat-gerdoon ko panah hi kyoon daytay hain.

yay jo Guns rakhi huee hain yay kia Pakana (Gubbara = Balloon) pharnay lay leay rakhi huee hain. kyoon aanay daytay hain apnay area may.

Gayhoon kay sath ghun to pista hi hay.. (thumbsdown)
and what about the terrorists in punjab and sindh ? who provide them refuge? any answer please !
 
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#

Sab say pahlay koee in nakal-makani kernay waloon say yay poochay kay app dehshat-gerdoon ko panah hi kyoon daytay hain.

yay jo Guns rakhi huee hain yay kia Pakana (Gubbara = Balloon) pharnay lay leay rakhi huee hain. kyoon aanay daytay hain apnay area may.

Gayhoon kay sath ghun to pista hi hay.. (thumbsdown)

Tumhara kasoor nahi is umer main bollywood dakhny say asey hi nojawan ho saktey hain.dehshatgardo ki is waqt sab say ziyada tadad karachi main aur to aur ab to TV waley punjabi taliban ki bhi headlines chalatey hain unnk barey mqin kia karna hqy ?
 
Advertisement
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#

Sab say pahlay koee in nakal-makani kernay waloon say yay poochay kay app dehshat-gerdoon ko panah hi kyoon daytay hain.

yay jo Guns rakhi huee hain yay kia Pakana (Gubbara = Balloon) pharnay lay leay rakhi huee hain. kyoon aanay daytay hain apnay area may.

Gayhoon kay sath ghun to pista hi hay.. (thumbsdown)

Karachi mein 108 bandon ko mar kar jab zaireen apni bus mein bitha kar chopa kar lay kar ja rahey hotay hain oss wakt sirf 30 bandon ke marnay par matam kiyon shoro kar daitay ho oss wakt kiyon nahe kehtay esay deshat gardon ko chopa kar bus mein lai kar kiyon ja rahey hotay ho ... or zarain ke sath jo bus mein deshatgard jatay hain who koi hakomtay Pakistan nahe baijti jo on ko lazmi apnay sath bus mein beithanay par majbor hon . magar yahan 1 lakh ke eik lakh loag deshtgardon ko panah dainay waley hain ? or in logon ke pass deshat gard basanay on ko training denay or Russia say laranay walay kon hain paksitan or pak army kash ke yeh oss wakt iss dollar zadar liberal army ko inkar kar daitay tu aap oss wakt in ko easa na karney par bhi ghadar kehtay .. idiot who hota hai jo baghir sochay samjhay bus loch tal laita hai
 
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#

Tumhara kasoor nahi is umer main bollywood dakhny say asey hi nojawan ho saktey hain.dehshatgardo ki is waqt sab say ziyada tadad karachi main aur to aur ab to TV waley punjabi taliban ki bhi headlines chalatey hain unnk barey mqin kia karna hqy ?


First of all i do not watch bollywood channels. i did not subscribe indian channels at my home. Do not judge anyone by your own assumptions.



Tiger "Hath Sut" , i never been to Karachi and i'm not a Shia Zaireen.
I'm against all those groups which Army had created in past, They all should be eliminated now.


Karachi mein 108 bandon ko mar kar jab zaireen apni bus mein bitha kar chopa kar lay kar ja rahey hotay hain oss wakt sirf 30 bandon ke marnay par matam kiyon shoro kar daitay ho oss wakt kiyon nahe kehtay esay deshat gardon ko chopa kar bus mein lai kar kiyon ja rahey hotay ho ... or zarain ke sath jo bus mein deshatgard jatay hain who koi hakomtay Pakistan nahe baijti jo on ko lazmi apnay sath bus mein beithanay par majbor hon . magar yahan 1 lakh ke eik lakh loag deshtgardon ko panah dainay waley hain ? or in logon ke pass deshat gard basanay on ko training denay or Russia say laranay walay kon hain paksitan or pak army kash ke yeh oss wakt iss dollar zadar liberal army ko inkar kar daitay tu aap oss wakt in ko easa na karney par bhi ghadar kehtay .. idiot who hota hai jo baghir sochay samjhay bus loch tal laita hai



What about the terrorist whithin the army ?

App uss chin-naal aurat ki terha hain jo laraee kernay ka koee na koee bahana dhoondh hi layti hay..
 
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#1578

[h=1]شمالی وزیرستان میں پناہ گزینوں کے بڑھتے مسائل[/h]http://www.bbc.co.uk/urdu/multimedia/2014/01/140128_south_waziristan_idps_rwa.shtml
 
Advertisement
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#

Dhehshat gard aayai nahi un ko banaya gaya hai.... farak hai aur is tarah to dhehshat gard poorai pakistan mai hain karachi, lahore, south punjab aur balochistan bhara para hai, Phir order karoo PAF Ko kai karai bambari har jagah, aanai do drones poorai pakistan mai aur army bhi shelling karain jaha us ka dil karain... yee dohri policy kabails par hee kyoon lagoo hoti hai ...

Lawangeenn bhai, mein maanta hoon kay military nay ziyadti ki hai innocent logoon kay saath. Magar aapko maan'naa parray ga kay mas'alaa wahan say shuroo howa jab uzbeks, chechens, somalis, saudis, tunisians, libyans, egyptians, syrians, palestinians and their mother-in-laws all found refuge in the FATA. They were not the afghan talibans - these were the same people who brought upon misery on the afghans and when the going got tough in afghanistan they ran away to FATA.

In this game no one is innocent - americans are guilty of committing excesses and so is the Pak military during the musharraf era but the al-qaeda types are mainly responsible and the people of FATA who were on the payroll of these arabs and other foreign elements who were al-qaeda and provided them refuge and decided to protect them at all costs. (I know that you may have the same refrain that there is no al-qaeda and there is no osama bin laden or that there is no al zawahiri).

Now coming back to your point of terrorist in other areas. Yes, there are terrorists in other areas as well. For example in Karachi and that includes MQM terrorists, ANP terrorists, LeJ terrorists, TTP terrorists, Sipah Mohammad terrorists, PPP terrorists. Security agencies always try to, even if half-heartedly, act against these groups from time to time. In the past military has or was involved in uprooting pockets of these terrorists as in the case of MQM back in the 90s. And, when military moves against insurgents they almost always commit excesses as they did in Karachi too. Lot of innocent people along with terrorists were killed. I am not sure how do you feel about that operation? I have no love lost for MQM but its a fact that military and security agencies did inflict pain for the innocent people who were caught in the middle.

Now you ask why do they not bomb Karachi. Well, you know very well that the tactics employed by the terrorists is a lot different than what they do in the FATA. In karachi or Lahore they don't move around in convoys of double cabin pickups or have full fledged training facilities on the lines of a military academy.

Also, the terrrorists in the urban areas hardly ever use heavy weaponry as employed by the militants in the FATA and most of the time they target the civilians.

Just in the past few months we have seen Pak military men killed enmasse in insurgent attacks that you see in war zones around the world. Then you have instances where military men were killed and their bodies mutilated. I am sure that when that happens then the military has a pretext to go after the militants and as reprehensible as civilian causalities are they are bound to happen if the militants hide around in civilian populations.

The bottom line is that as it is incumbent upon the military to be careful of civilian casualties and collateral damage the terrorists or TTP or militants (who claim to be protecting the tribal area population) should not indulge or take refuge in areas when they know that it would cause civilian casualties. You can't kill and then run to hid among civilian population. This is not manly.
The military should also show restraint as much as they can and I believe that this nuisance to drag on as long as it has shows that the military has shown some restraint. Otherwise based on sheer firepower the military can blow them out any day.


By the way do you feel the pain of the people of karachi in the 90s and people of baluchistan in 70s and 2000s and people of sindh in the 80s when they faced similar excesses at the hands of the military as you feel about the people of FATA?
 
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#


Yeh kis alliance ki tasveerain share kar rahy ho ? Its say All Pakistan Kafir alliance
 
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#

Lawangeenn bhai, mein maanta hoon kay military nay ziyadti ki hai innocent logoon kay saath. Magar aapko maan'naa parray ga kay mas'alaa wahan say shuroo howa jab uzbeks, chechens, somalis, saudis, tunisians, libyans, egyptians, syrians, palestinians and their mother-in-laws all found refuge in the FATA. They were not the afghan talibans - these were the same people who brought upon misery on the afghans and when the going got tough in afghanistan they ran away to FATA.

In this game no one is innocent - americans are guilty of committing excesses and so is the Pak military during the musharraf era but the al-qaeda types are mainly responsible and the people of FATA who were on the payroll of these arabs and other foreign elements who were al-qaeda and provided them refuge and decided to protect them at all costs. (I know that you may have the same refrain that there is no al-qaeda and there is no osama bin laden or that there is no al zawahiri).

Now coming back to your point of terrorist in other areas. Yes, there are terrorists in other areas as well. For example in Karachi and that includes MQM terrorists, ANP terrorists, LeJ terrorists, TTP terrorists, Sipah Mohammad terrorists, PPP terrorists. Security agencies always try to, even if half-heartedly, act against these groups from time to time. In the past military has or was involved in uprooting pockets of these terrorists as in the case of MQM back in the 90s. And, when military moves against insurgents they almost always commit excesses as they did in Karachi too. Lot of innocent people along with terrorists were killed. I am not sure how do you feel about that operation? I have no love lost for MQM but its a fact that military and security agencies did inflict pain for the innocent people who were caught in the middle.

Now you ask why do they not bomb Karachi. Well, you know very well that the tactics employed by the terrorists is a lot different than what they do in the FATA. In karachi or Lahore they don't move around in convoys of double cabin pickups or have full fledged training facilities on the lines of a military academy.

Also, the terrrorists in the urban areas hardly ever use heavy weaponry as employed by the militants in the FATA and most of the time they target the civilians.

Just in the past few months we have seen Pak military men killed enmasse in insurgent attacks that you see in war zones around the world. Then you have instances where military men were killed and their bodies mutilated. I am sure that when that happens then the military has a pretext to go after the militants and as reprehensible as civilian causalities are they are bound to happen if the militants hide around in civilian populations.

The bottom line is that as it is incumbent upon the military to be careful of civilian casualties and collateral damage the terrorists or TTP or militants (who claim to be protecting the tribal area population) should not indulge or take refuge in areas when they know that it would cause civilian casualties. You can't kill and then run to hid among civilian population. This is not manly.
The military should also show restraint as much as they can and I believe that this nuisance to drag on as long as it has shows that the military has shown some restraint. Otherwise based on sheer firepower the military can blow them out any day.


By the way do you feel the pain of the people of karachi in the 90s and people of baluchistan in 70s and 2000s and people of sindh in the 80s when they faced similar excesses at the hands of the military as you feel about the people of FATA?

Answer to your Question Did i feel bad for people of other places when military moved against them, Yes because i think as a Human not as Muslim, Pushtoon or someone else. For me human life is precious and when someone dies they leave some dependents behind them and indirectly i also feel bad for them. Everything you said about FATA and Military operation is right to some extent but we know people of FATA have been living like this for ages and they have been supporting afghans against every invaders so i personally believe pakistan army should keep these things in mind. There is no doubt FATA is totally different place from the rest of the Pakistan but their life is as precious as others.
Last year we planned to go to afghanistan from pakistan and i was shocked that how easily you can cross the border without any documents and checking. Do you really think this is going to help us fight against terrorism. Govt. failure on every level is the main reason for all this mess that now are armed forces have to deal with and unfortunately both side will suffer looses. Mrk brother you might know that too, that army can't wipe them out, they might move somewhere else temporarily but will be back again and who will suffer the most normal FATA people.

People of FATA have no choice, they can't go against any one neither TTP nor Army.
 
Re: فاٹا میں نقصان کا سبب پاکستانی فوج کی حکم&#

Answer to your Question Did i feel bad for people of other places when military moved against them, Yes because i think as a Human not as Muslim, Pushtoon or someone else. For me human life is precious and when someone dies they leave some dependents behind them and indirectly i also feel bad for them. Everything you said about FATA and Military operation is right to some extent but we know people of FATA have been living like this for ages and they have been supporting afghans against every invaders so i personally believe pakistan army should keep these things in mind. There is no doubt FATA is totally different place from the rest of the Pakistan but their life is as precious as others.
Last year we planned to go to afghanistan from pakistan and i was shocked that how easily you can cross the border without any documents and checking. Do you really think this is going to help us fight against terrorism. Govt. failure on every level is the main reason for all this mess that now are armed forces have to deal with and unfortunately both side will suffer looses. Mrk brother you might know that too, that army can't wipe them out, they might move somewhere else temporarily but will be back again and who will suffer the most normal FATA people.

People of FATA have no choice, they can't go against any one neither TTP nor Army.

Brother, I admit that when it comes to FATA I am an armchair analyst. You probably know more about the intricacies involved than I ever would.

The question I asked in the end was more of a rhetorical one and was directed more towards others than to you. I completely agree with you that to us as human beings or muslims or Pakistanis even a single innocent life lost should be one too many!

You made an acute yet common sense observation about the border crossings. I always wonder about that. And, its not just from Afghanistan border - we even allow anyone to come to Pakistan from anywhere in the world and indulge in all sorts of activities. Just a quick story that there were 5 or 6 young men who disappeared from our area and it wasn't until their families reported them missing and through our local area muslim organization contacted the FBI that they were traced in Pakistan and were eventually caught in Sargodha on their way to the tribal areas. This happened just 3-4 years ago. Shows that even after all the problems we had faced we couldn't stop those arab or african young men who had no connection to Pakistan at Karachi airport and ask them why are they there. The only answer that I can come up with is incompetence.

The last line that you wrote probably sums up the dilemma for us. We are stuck in the war of two or three or four evils.

I
 
Advertisement
Re: ???? ??? ????? ?? ??? ???????? ??? ?? ???&#1578

When there is dialogue result is this (And you know what happened to Nek Mohammad, consider as the first Amir of TTP, after this speech)



When there is operation result is this.

 
pehle 4 operation kar chukay aqal phir bhi inko nahi ati phir wohi kuty ki dum terhi ki tehri....
na bijli hai na pani hai na gas hai or chalen hain operation karnay ...kisi liberal fascist ko pata bhi hai kay operation per kitna kharcha ata hai? jab kamyabi ki umeed hi na hoo tu itna pesa lutanay ki kia zaroorat? is pese se ap bijli gas ka masla hal nahi kar saktay?