- Joined
- Dec 1, 2010
- Posts
- 10,198
- Reaction score
- 2,220
- Points
- 173
kia is inqilaab ki ibtadaa pakistan se ho gi?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Yeh banda kon ha.
Yeh banda kon ha.
Yeh banda kon ha.
I think this guy is trying to stretch this thing too far. Here is a translation of Quranic aayat. They talk about fraud and short changing, not some capitalist system:
. Woe to those that deal in fraud,-
2. Those who, when they have to receive by measure from men, exact full measure,
3. But when they have to give by measure or weight to men, give less than due.
4. Do they not think that they will be called to account?-
Ghulam Ahamd Pervaiz.. Is ke nam se kuch loog pervaizi bi kehlatey hein
Dear siasti sb, in ke naam se koi bhi parwezi nahin kehlaata haan mullah log logoon ko parwezi ka label lagaate hen jaise aik doosre per yeh log label chipkaate rehte hen ummat main fitne fasaad peda karne ke liye.
regards and all the best.
Dear Talwar Gujjar sb, why do you think the quran is not talking about the capitalist economic system? Are you aware it is based upon a way of life founded upon the idea of personal gains at the expense of each other?
Deen of islam is basically about bringing forth a proper human community or an ummah. Can a people become an ummah on basis of capitalist system when they try to profit from each other by inflicting losses on each other? Even a family ends up broken when people adopt the idea of personal gains at the expense of each other in a family.
If you have not yet read my explanation of the quran and deen of islam please do, you will find a lot of very useful information about everything that really matters in this world HERE and HERE.
regards and all the best.
I am not arguing for or against Capitalism. All I am saying is your so called scholar is talking irrelevant things. The verses he refers to don't say what he is lecturing about. He should be honest to say he is talking his own ideas, not what Quran says.
Dear Talwar Gujjar ab, if I may ask, have you studied the quran in depth as I have? If not my work on the quran can be found in the provided links. Please find some time and go through it. It was a huge undertaking of its kind by me. Anyone who goes through it will come to know how easy or hard it is to understnd the text of the quran and why that is the case. It is well detailed explanation of things about which a huge majority of people are totally unaware. It is result of my several decades study of things in depth and I am sharing it for the benefit of people as my contribution to humanity.
regards and all the best.
Just try to learn from Quran,
don't try to fit it to your convenience,
Obey Allah and his Messenger, don't try to dictate them your terms.
Pervez was a known heretic,
nothing to learn from him.
[FONT=&]
Dear Talwar Gujjar sb, that is exactly what I did over many years of my life and am still continuing.
In order to understand anything at all one has to first of all learn sense to make proper sense of things. Unless one has learned sense of making proper sense of things one cannot understand anything at all because before one could understand anything at all one has to know how to figure out things for oneself. This is a very long process based upon trial and error right from the day one is born till the day one dies. This ability of figuring out things is one's best interpretation of facts and if this interpretation of facts makes sense then is it correct as well otherwise incorrect. We all try to explain things the best we can on basis of our own life experiences but the question is, how do we know whether an explanation we have come up with makes proper sense or not? What do we need to make proper sense of something? A proper context. How can we come to know the proper context of something? Simply by trial and error method. By taking different contexts in turn and seeing if any of them works we can come to know the proper context of something. What is context? A context is always based on purpose of something. Nothing can make sense unless it is purposeful or has a purpose. Letters, words sentences are all meaningless without their proper contexts. For example, in general letters make sense in context of being words. Words make sense in context of being sentences and sentences make sense in context of their objectivity.
Trial and error method of learning is tested by each and every human being right from the day one is born. If we look at how we came to know how to look at things or hear sounds of things or feel things etc etc it was all a process called trial and error. We learned how to sit or stand or walk or run or jump or talk by way of trial and error by constantly correcting ourselves and improving ourselves. We were not born knowing everything but not knowing anything at all. This is why we cannot be sure about things till we find out about them. The same is true about the message iof the quran. None of us can know it till we work at it. To know the message of the quran properly one has to know the way to learn the quran properly otherwise one cannot learn the quran properly at all. To know a message properly knowing something about the human language itself is absolutely necessary. Someone just saying I know the quran is not enough.
You cannot obey anyone wilfully properly or purposefully unless first you come to know what the purpose of obedience is supposed to be and whether that purpose makes sense or not in its said or supposed context. It is because obeying someone or something is about accomplishing some task or objective or mission or goal. So it all comes down to knowing properly the message of God or his messenger before acting upon it. It is because a message is given for a set purpose so acting upon it has to be for fulfilling that purpose.
All of us human beings are individuals and have our own life experiences to guide us as to how to judge things for what they actually are. However only that judgement proves correct that is firmly based upon a solid foundation. To claim parwez was a known heretic is not right on your part because you cannot prove him so and if you are simply basing your claim on nonsense of ignorant and foolish mullahs then that is a serious mistake on your part. However like everyone else you too have the right to differ with anyone provided you have the justification for doing so otherwise if people decide to differ with each other just for sake of it then humanity cannot save itself from serious consequences.
A very wrong statement by you indeed because regretfully it says a lot about you as a person rather than the issue we are supposed to be discussing. I do not like to be pedantic but please do think before you state anything because talking about others exposes oneself as well.
I do not enter in debates with people instead I try to explain things the best I can so that those who may be interested in understanding things could benefit from my explanations. I am hoping for the same in your case as well. After all we all learn from each other and ideas breed ideas and exchanging ideas increases our knowledge through help of each other. This is why people who claim to be muslims study under supervision of nonmuslims and vice versa. We all have something to contribute to ensure well being of humanity and that is the way we should carry on if we want a better future for humanity. This is why we should not stop learning from anyone but we must first learn sense of making proper sense of things so that none could mislead us by ones tricks and mechanisms.
regards and all the best.
[/FONT]islam deen hai mazhab nahin hai
http://archive.org/details/Al-Quran_123
[FONT=&]
Dear Talwar Gujjar sb, that is exactly what I did over many years of my life and am still continuing.
In order to understand anything at all one has to first of all learn sense to make proper sense of things. Unless one has learned sense of making proper sense of things one cannot understand anything at all because before one could understand anything at all one has to know how to figure out things for oneself. This is a very long process based upon trial and error right from the day one is born till the day one dies. This ability of figuring out things is one's best interpretation of facts and if this interpretation of facts makes sense then is it correct as well otherwise incorrect. We all try to explain things the best we can on basis of our own life experiences but the question is, how do we know whether an explanation we have come up with makes proper sense or not? What do we need to make proper sense of something? A proper context. How can we come to know the proper context of something? Simply by trial and error method. By taking different contexts in turn and seeing if any of them works we can come to know the proper context of something. What is context? A context is always based on purpose of something. Nothing can make sense unless it is purposeful or has a purpose. Letters, words sentences are all meaningless without their proper contexts. For example, in general letters make sense in context of being words. Words make sense in context of being sentences and sentences make sense in context of their objectivity.
Trial and error method of learning is tested by each and every human being right from the day one is born. If we look at how we came to know how to look at things or hear sounds of things or feel things etc etc it was all a process called trial and error. We learned how to sit or stand or walk or run or jump or talk by way of trial and error by constantly correcting ourselves and improving ourselves. We were not born knowing everything but not knowing anything at all. This is why we cannot be sure about things till we find out about them. The same is true about the message iof the quran. None of us can know it till we work at it. To know the message of the quran properly one has to know the way to learn the quran properly otherwise one cannot learn the quran properly at all. To know a message properly knowing something about the human language itself is absolutely necessary. Someone just saying I know the quran is not enough.
You cannot obey anyone wilfully properly or purposefully unless first you come to know what the purpose of obedience is supposed to be and whether that purpose makes sense or not in its said or supposed context. It is because obeying someone or something is about accomplishing some task or objective or mission or goal. So it all comes down to knowing properly the message of God or his messenger before acting upon it. It is because a message is given for a set purpose so acting upon it has to be for fulfilling that purpose.
All of us human beings are individuals and have our own life experiences to guide us as to how to judge things for what they actually are. However only that judgement proves correct that is firmly based upon a solid foundation. To claim parwez was a known heretic is not right on your part because you cannot prove him so and if you are simply basing your claim on nonsense of ignorant and foolish mullahs then that is a serious mistake on your part. However like everyone else you too have the right to differ with anyone provided you have the justification for doing so otherwise if people decide to differ with each other just for sake of it then humanity cannot save itself from serious consequences.
A very wrong statement by you indeed because regretfully it says a lot about you as a person rather than the issue we are supposed to be discussing. I do not like to be pedantic but please do think before you state anything because talking about others exposes oneself as well.
I do not enter in debates with people instead I try to explain things the best I can so that those who may be interested in understanding things could benefit from my explanations. I am hoping for the same in your case as well. After all we all learn from each other and ideas breed ideas and exchanging ideas increases our knowledge through help of each other. This is why people who claim to be muslims study under supervision of nonmuslims and vice versa. We all have something to contribute to ensure well being of humanity and that is the way we should carry on if we want a better future for humanity. This is why we should not stop learning from anyone but we must first learn sense of making proper sense of things so that none could mislead us by ones tricks and mechanisms.
regards and all the best.
[/FONT]islam deen hai mazhab nahin hai
http://archive.org/details/Al-Quran_123
What is your connection to Gulam Ahmad Pervez. I thought he died in 1985.
Make it short and to the point:
Why should I follow you and not the traditional tafasir like Ibne Kathir, or the Fuqaha like Abu Hanifa and others. Be straight and specific, don't keep on going round and around.
Dear Talwar Gujjar sb, there are no short cuts to learning sense rather it is a lifelong process. Moreover only those people learn sense who put a lot of effort into learning and learn things carefully. There is no benefit in learning greater than being knowledgeable rather than being confused or puzzled about life and living. Without knowledge one cannot be a proper human being. Not only that one cannot do anything or have anything or use anything properly. This is why even our creator taught us knowledge so that we could learn how to live in this world properly. Basically this is what the quran is about ie a book of guidance which is a program for humanity from God wherein are set goals by God for mankind to accomplish but according to his provided guidelines.
My connection to parwez sb marhoom is same as my connection with you. We are human beings so we are all blood related. However the main connection between human beings has to be ideological because only a proper ideological connection can help people become a proper human community based upon guidance of Allah.
Not all people can be at the same stage of learning at the same time because when one person dies of old age another is being born as a baby. However those who have managed to learn more they help others rise in their level of knowledge as well as go beyond their level of knowledge. This is why people can learn things from each other generation after generation and keep growing in their knowledge of things in the real world realities as well as in the knowledge of God given message. This is why we human beings can agree with each other on things about which we have found out for sure and continue learning and discovering what is yet to be learned or known. So long as we keep doing that we are on the right track. We should never stop learning because that becomes death of a human being. It is because God has created human beings for learning and doing things so that his plan and purpose for creating this world and giving his message to people could becomes fulfilled.
This is why we must be open for learning from each and every thing or person but we should only try to be proper human beings and do or have or use what is right properly. This is how mankind could end up as one people or an ummah. By sticking to wrong ideas and practices we can only and only inflict harms and destructions upon each other. This is why we must do our level best to find out right ideas and practices so that we end up with a world that is fit for human beings to live in. It is because Allah has made it responsibility of human beings to make this world a paradise for themselves with help of his guidance. If people will not learn sense and do things which turn this world into a paradise for them then they will always end up turning it into a living hell hole for themselves by hands of each other.
regards and all the best.
You have not quoted a single Quranic ayah or a hadith to support your contention. Quran is, "----a guidance and glad tidings to believers." Baqara:97. I don't find anything against following Islam to my capability and understanding as I learn from mainstream scholars. I found Pervez making up things and saying it was in Quran, in the video you posted. Quran is not fond or oblivious to such vandalism:
"Then woe to those who write the Book with their own hands, and then say:"This is from Allah," to traffic with it for miserable price!- Woe to them for what their hands do write, and for the gain they make thereby." Baqara: 79
© Copyrights 2008 - 2026 Siasat.pk - All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Disclaimer|