Bari science nikaali hai. Mere haklay paindoo bachay we already know this. Salaried class always suffered whenever there are taxes. But what to do, N league govt has literally bankrupted the country. If we will not pay then how this country will survive. There is no other way to rum the country. May be after 2 years we will get some releif from PTI govt.
اس پینڈو کو کوئی سمجھا دے اپنا چائینیز کم کر اور گھر میں کھانا کھا جیسے تیرے باپ دادا کھاتے تھے اگر خرچہ کم کرنا ہے تو عیاشی کم کر باہر کا کھانا کھائے گا بے وقوف
Bhai jo 17hazar gas ka bill daita ha, uss ki salary bhi lakhon mein ha, no big deal. Hum loug Europe mein 40% tax daity hein, jis k baad hath aaye salary Pakistan mein 17hazar bill dainy walay sy kumm reh jati ha. Aur phir Baqi salary k 1/3 ghar k kiraye aur bills mein chala jata ha, yani Gross salary ka 60% pehly hafty mein he ghayeb magar Allah ka shukr ha. Klasra Sahab rona bund krain.
Pichli aur iss hakoomat mein ye farq ha k ye haqoomat ye paisay apni jaib mein nahi dalay gi inshaAllah.
sahi lnde ka danishwr hai pakistan is worst country in collecting tax. IK has to come up with strict taxation and non subside useless projects like metro, is jese pendyo ka dil hai IMF se lete rho inki maujen lge rhen
There are hundreds of Khan sahib speeches where he is opposing indirect taxes. because indirect is charged at the same rate to poor and rich. Now a labourer will pay same increase as shopkeeper and factory owner. I dont like Klasara but here he is right. Instead of defending increase we should also criticise our govt. This increase should be temporary and whenevey govt have the chance to organise FBR and increase direct taxation, this should be reversed.
There are hundreds of Khan sahib speeches where he is opposing indirect taxes. because indirect is charged at the same rate to poor and rich. Now a labourer will pay same increase as shopkeeper and factory owner. I dont like Klasara but here he is right. Instead of defending increase we should also criticise our govt. This increase should be temporary and whenevey govt have the chance to organise FBR and increase direct taxation, this should be reversed.
Will a poor man buy an iphone? Will a poor man buy 1800 cc car? The income tax is minimal on people who fall in average and below average salary catagory. The luxury items on which duty is increased isnt really in grasp of a poor man. All over the world there is a lot of tax on cigarette industry (mainly to discourage smoking) and the same has been implied in pakistan. So how will a poor man be affected adversly ?
I pay upto 48% as tax on a portion of my salary. The people in the lower income bracket instead pay only 22%. This thing is very normal all around the world. People who are rich are supposed to pay more in taxes.
The media would ofcourse create an havoc over this issue as they are the highest paid people in our country.
بھا ئی ان کی بھی یہ روزی روٹی ہے نہیں بولیں گے یا لکھیں گے تو کھائیں گے کہاں سے اب یہ الگ بات ہے کہ کسی کو اچھا لگے یا نہ، اسی طرح حکومت نے بھی اپنا کام چلانا ہے کسی کو اچھا لگے یا نہ۔ ہاں اگر خزانہ بھرا تھا تو اب حکومت نے اپنی عیاشیوں کیلئے نئے ٹیکس لگائے تو یہ غلط بات ہے۔ جو کہ ایسا نہیں ہے ۔
In anchors ki salary lakho mein hai and they play a role of ghareeb awam.. mujay koi ghareeb dikha do jo roz chinese aur sabz chae afford karta ho:/
Inko takleef yeh hai k in sub pay tax laga hai aur inki luxury items oay tax laga hai:)
Kounsa ghareeb hai jo 17k ki gas use karta hai mujay b bata do bhai
Will a poor man buy an iphone? Will a poor man buy 1800 cc car? The income tax is minimal on people who fall in average and below average salary catagory. The luxury items on which duty is increased isnt really in grasp of a poor man. All over the world there is a lot of tax on cigarette industry (mainly to discourage smoking) and the same has been implied in pakistan. So how will a poor man be affected adversly ?
Oh god....we should handover the affairs of the state to this chuchunder.
He is against progressive taxation as well. In fact, his musing is against taxation altogether.
The sad thing is, to put weight to his stupid argument, he talks about some (fictional?) professor in US, so that he may give impression that he is learned.
However the fact of the matter is that he doesn't know even an iota of any subject except for political jugatbazi .
اپنی ہی دہرا رہا ہے ۔۔ شہباز نے جو جواب دیے اس کا ذکر تک نہیں۔ اور یہی ان صحافیوں کا مسئلہ ہے کے جو منفی بات ہوگئی اس کا ذکر کرو اور جو مثبت باتیں ہونگی اس کو گول کردو۔۔۔۔ خود پسند پینڈو۔
There are hundreds of Khan sahib speeches where he is opposing indirect taxes. because indirect is charged at the same rate to poor and rich. Now a labourer will pay same increase as shopkeeper and factory owner. I dont like Klasara but here he is right. Instead of defending increase we should also criticise our govt. This increase should be temporary and whenevey govt have the chance to organise FBR and increase direct taxation, this should be reversed.
What. The Proposed scheme is progressive, more for the rich and relief for the less fortunate. Progressive taxation on service sector and utilities are good in itself for a policy. Though the burden of tax on the poor should be much less as we have in the current flawed scheme.
The question of direct and indirect taxation is another issue as presently state collects bulk of the tax from indirect taxation which favors the rich. This has to change but that requires FBR reform and much much more.
We'll hold the government accountable for how it alters the mix of taxation and increases the direct taxation in the coming years. But progressive taxation on services will not go away. The government has to compensate/payback if a taxation scheme on services/sales is not progressive (due to several technical reason) as is the practice in many states.
But Klasra's wisdom is saying that even the tax on the large consumers is not good and bla bla bla ... it is not even understandable what he is actually saying in terms of a meaningful economics. His statement is valid against all taxes yet the economy does not work as he is assuming.
He is wrong on all accounts--- except for some theories of extreme conservatives who argue that rich shouldn't be taxed because they are the only investors and job creators (and if taxed the poor will suffer the more) and the poor should be taxed because they do not save and are lazy.
What. The Proposed scheme is progressive, more for the rich and relief for the less fortunate. Progressive taxation on service sector and utilities are good in itself for a policy. Though the burden of tax on the poor should be much less as we have in the current flawed scheme.
The question of direct and indirect taxation is another issue as presently state collects bulk of the tax from indirect taxation which favors the rich. This has to change but that requires FBR reform and much much more.
We'll hold the government accountable for how it alters the mix of taxation and increases the direct taxation in the coming years. But progressive taxation on services will not go away. The government has to compensate/payback if a taxation scheme on services/sales is not progressive (due to several technical reason) as is the practice in many states.
But Klasra's wisdom is saying that even the tax on the large consumers is not good and bla bla bla ... it is not even understandable what he is actually saying in terms of a meaningful economics. His statement is valid against all taxes yet the economy does not work as he is assuming.
He is wrong on all accounts--- except for some theories of extreme conservatives who argue that rich shouldn't be taxed because they are the only investors and job creators (and if taxed the poor will suffer the more) and the poor should be taxed because they do not save and are lazy.
YOU HAVE FAILED TO COMPREHEND. Gas price hike is charged on tier bases, without consideration to income level. This is what Klasar is talking of 94 billion plus GST. You are mixing direct taxation with gas price hike. Please be rationale in criticism and consider things on merit. We are not Patwaris but educated people. We own this govt and will criticise on bad decision.