No comparison between Bhutto and Nawaz Scharif. Those who compare them should hear Bhutto talking. He never used a Parchi to talk. NS cannot even utter a few words without parchi.
I admit that ZAB did not get a fair trial, but Kasuri was assassinated, and Bhutto was complicit to a high degree. Bhutto had turned into a hardcore fascist by the mid 70s. This was the aftermath of him having been the only civilian martial law administrator in Pakistan's history. He just couldnt let go of the control that came with it.
Regardless of the (political) question why he was tried or hanged in 1977-79, what is source and basis of your this very assertion, except, of course, for the denial/words of Bhutto during the trial.
As far as the assertion that Qasuri was not assassinated (by orders of whomsoever) was ludicrous on any account. Bhutto's defense A B Awan tried to put this theory in the court but without any evidence, support or basis and was duly rejected. Of course, the purpose of this claim was public consumption rather than for the court. It would be apt to mentioned that the Bhutto's PM office had tried/suggested to Justice Shafi Ur-rahman Inquiry to divert the case towards the lines of domestic conflict. I hope you are well aware of the verdict of LHC and the accounts of the witnesses and beyond the usual political rhetoric of the times.
Regardless of the question we do agree/disagree with the verdict, what are the reasons/material to this very assertion. As far as the defense of Bhutto/PP was concerned, that was to turn the criminal trial into a political trial and theater: Hence we witnessed all sort of vilification of the court in and outside the room, mud-slinging of the judges, accusations of political affiliations and bribery for the witnesses and the judges. That was their crux and the content of the defense in this criminal trial. (Perhaps, we are witnessing the same in Shareef's trial as well today). There was nothing unusual as this is an old and quite effective strategy in all sort of trials. However, in Bhutto's case that was, IMHO, turned out to be a fatal mistake limiting the options for the arguments of the legal team - as each word was reported and scrutinized on the political ground that what was helpful to the accused. Perhaps, that was the reason, right after the verdict from LHC, Attorney Hafeez Lakho directly blamed Yehya Bukhtiar for the unanimous verdict and demands were made to remove Bhuktiar from the case (especially from the co-accused Awan in this case. In any event, it was Bhutto's own and well calculated strategy to fight the case on the political (rather than on judicial) grounds as he had rather put his bet on external intervention from different sources (belonging to inside or from outside of the country- Bhutto had been very popular and favorite among several general even in those days, which is another side story of this saga. However, the main story of this case regards to attempts/strategies for invoking external intervention and reasons for its failure - only some future historian would do justice to this topic. In any case my initial question stands about the basis of 'not a fair trial'.
Now let me explore two comments that I expect from you would make in this regard. First why the case was not tried in the session court, that resulted in loss of one chance of appeal. The case was put in the session court, initially, however it was shifted to the full bench of LHC on the demands/request of Bhutto. Of course, while Bhutto/PPP wished to fight the case on political grounds, it was a correct decision. The sinister Zia readily agreed to the Bhutto's demands. In any case, since all this happened in view of the wishes of the accused, one may not put the blame on the judicial system or account it as 'unfair trial'.
Second, the question of presidential pardon: Usefully when a court decision is split, the sentence is reduced. In this case there were very strong not just ample grounds (because the minority of SC had acquitted him) to convert death sentence to life imprisonment. I agree that, if the trial had not turned into a political battlefield, that would have been the certain result. On the other hand, Bhutto, in person, did not files the appeal (rather that was his wife Ameer begum), so when he had not sought the pardon (accepting the court verdict) why he should have avail the constitutional (not legal) remedy? In any case, IMO, Zia would not have let him go whether the appeal was properly made or not.
One important point to note about this trial, was, regardless of various political slogans and claims, Bhutto right up to about couple of months before the hanging, was sure that the junta would not dare to hang him. This is also a tragic long saga of political failure in Bhuttos trial. For the time when Bhutto finally lost the hopes regards to his conversation with his nephew at dentist's office and with Begum Nusrat Bhutto. ------ I had been and still am quite much supporter of ZA Bhutto but these damn..fac-..
I agree with your valid point. Perhaps i was erroneously pointing out the defense strategy that Shareef's advisors are trying to copy.
If your point was that Bhutto's trial was was political and in times when the constitutional law was suspended, then I tend to agree with you point of it 'being Inherently Unfair Trial', regardless of the material facts in the court room.
Just for a snippet, throughout the administration of Bhutto, emergency (suspending a few legal rights) was in place, which was lifted by the Zia and replaced with the unconstitutionality martial law. One of demands of Qoumi Itahad was to lift up emergency (especially by the NDP and Baluchis who had suffered immensely by emergency) - Thus, would a political trial under emergency also be accounted as inherently unfair? In my personal opinion ;yes, though our constitution explicitly declares it fair.