Advertisement

حکومت و اسٹبلشمنٹ کا کڑا امتحان

اگر کوئی پوچھے کہ تحریک انصاف کی حکومت کامیاب ہے یا ناکام تو میں ایک نقطے پر ہی اسے فیل قرار دے دیتا ہوں وہ ہے وزیر اعلیٰ پنجاب . کسی بھی معاشی و سماجی ترقی کے مقابل یہ ایک ایسا بلنڈر ہے جس کی وجہ سے پنجاب خاص طور پر وسطی اور اپر پنجاب تحریک انصاف کا قبرستان بن جاۓ گا . اگر کے پی کے میں کسی ہزارہ یا گجر برادری کا وزیر اعلیٰ لگا دیا جاۓ

اور بلوچستان میں کسی پشتون کو تو اس کا سیاسی نقصان کیا ہے اس بات کا اندازہ ہر کوئی لگا سکتا ہے . جو اپنا کھوتا دماغ عمران خان نے پنجاب پر مسلط کرنے کی کوشش کی ہے اس کے نتائج بھی سنگین ہی نکلیں گے اب تحریک انصاف کی حکومت تو کاردکردگی کے بغیر ہی فیل ہو گئی اب مزید اس کو کیا چیلنجز درپیش ہوں گے اس بات کا اندازہ لگاتے ہیں

ملک ایک سنگین معاشی بحران کی طرف گامزن ہے زرداری دور میں انفلیشن ہوا اس کے مقابلے لوگوں کی آمدن بھی دوگنی کر دی گئی ، نواز دور میں انفلیشن کنٹرول کیا گیا بھاری قرضے لیے گۓ . اب ایک ایسا ڈیڈ اینڈ آ گیا ہے جس دونوں باتیں ہی نا ممکن نظر آ رہی ہیں . موجودہ حکومت مصنوعی طور پر کچھ نہیں کرے گی اور قدرتی طور پر ڈالر بھی بڑھے گا جب قرضے کی قسط ادا ہو گی اور ٹیکس بھی لگانا پڑیں گے تا کہ بجٹ خسارہ ختم کیا جا سکے . اس میں عوام کے لیے ایک مہنگائی کا مزید سونامی نظر آ رہا ہے .

اس کے ساتھ ساتھ تحریک انصاف کی پیدا کردہ افرا تفری اور غیر یقینی صورتحال کی وجہ سے کاروباری طبقہ بھی پریشان ہے اگر ایک سال میں کرنسی کی قیمت میں اتنا گراو ہو تو کون اعتماد سے یہاں کاروبار کرے گا . اس کے ساتھ ساتھ عوام بھی اب آوسٹیریتی کی پالیسی کی طرف گامزن ہو چکی ہے اور اس نے بھی اپنے خرچے کم کر دئیے ہیں . ان تمام باتوں کے نتیجے میں سنگین معاشی بحران نظر آ رہا ہے

معاشی بحران کے ساتھ ساتھ تحریک انصاف کے لیے سیاسی بحران بھی ہو گا کیا اس کے اتحادی عوام مخالف پالیسیوں میں اس کا ساتھ دے گے یا نہیں دیں گے . کیا ماضی کے برعکس ایم کیو ایم عوام پر ٹیکسز پر ایوان میں بیٹھی رہے گی یا بائیکاٹ کرے گی .

تحریک انصاف سے زیادہ بدنامی اسٹبلشمنٹ کی ہے جس نے اسے قوم پر مسلط کیا ہے حالت خراب ہونے کی صورت میں اسٹبلشمنٹ بھی متاثر ہوے بغیر نہیں رہ سکے گی اور عوامی اعتاب کا شکار بنے گی . جنرل باجوہ تاجروں کی منت سماجت کر رہے تھے اس سے بہتر تھا اپنی بدمعاش انٹیلی جنس ایجنسی کو نکیل ڈالتے جس نے ملک میں افرا تفری پھیلا کر اسے برباد کیا ہے آج بھی جعلی اکاونٹس کے تماشے کے پیچھے پیپلز پارٹی کو ختم کرنے کا جو کھیل ہے اس کی بھینٹ لاکھوں لوگوں کا روزگار چڑھ چکا ہے

کاروباری طبقہ ایسے ذلیل ہو گا تو کون اس ملک میں کاروبار کرے گا اس لیے سیاست کا مکروح ایجنڈہ چلانے والی انٹیلی جنس ایجنسی کی باز پرس ہونی چاہئیے نہیں تو بحران میں عوام خود ہی مجرموں کے گریبان میں ہاتھ ڈالے گی . اب ہم بھی دیکھتے ہیں عوامی نمائندوں سے کتنا بہتر یہ ایجنسیوں کے مہرے اس ملک کو چلاتے ہیں . جو افرا تفری اور طوفان پچھلی حکومتوں میں ان ایجنسیوں کی جانب سے جاری رہا ہے اس سے جو ملکی معیشت برباد ہوئی ہے اس کا کتنا مداوا ہوتا ہے ​
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
Buzdar ka nakami se koi taluk nae. Imran khan hi scale hai kamyabi ya nakami ka. agr kisi ne kuch krna hoga to buzdar kya ap b kr lo gy CM bn ke. nae krna hoga to beshak einstein le ao wo b hath pe hath dhar ke betha rhe ga.
 
Buzdar ka nakami se koi taluk nae. Imran khan hi scale hai kamyabi ya nakami ka. agr kisi ne kuch krna hoga to buzdar kya ap b kr lo gy CM bn ke. nae krna hoga to beshak einstein le ao wo b hath pe hath dhar ke betha rhe ga.
سیاست صرف معیشت پر نہیں ہوتی اور بھی بہت کچھ ہوتا ہے کراچی سے ایم کیو ایم کیوں جیتتی ہے اندروں سندھ پیپلز پڑتی یا کے پی کے سے اے این پی
اگر فیصلہ ہی عوامی امنگوں کے خلاف ہو تو کیسے کامیاب ہوں گے
​
 
Advertisement
سیاست صرف معیشت پر نہیں ہوتی اور بھی بہت کچھ ہوتا ہے کراچی سے ایم کیو ایم کیوں جیتتی ہے اندروں سندھ پیپلز پڑتی یا کے پی کے سے اے این پی
اگر فیصلہ ہی عوامی امنگوں کے خلاف ہو تو کیسے کامیاب ہوں گے
​
main samjha nae apka point. can you explain
 
main samjha nae apka point. can you explain
کراچی کے مہاجر کراچی میں اکثریت میں ہے اگر ایم کیو ایم کسی سندھی کو کراچی کا میر لگا دیں تو ان کی سپورٹ کہاں جاۓ گی اگر کسی مہاجر کو پیپلز پارٹی سندھ کا وزیر اعلیٰ لگا دے تو سندھی ووٹ بینک ناراض . اسی طرح اگر ایک غیر پنجابی اور کٹھ پتلی قسم کے بندے کو پنجاب پر مسلط کر دیا جاۓ تو تحریک انصاف کی پنجابی سپورٹ تو ختم ​
 
کراچی کے مہاجر کراچی میں اکثریت میں ہے اگر ایم کیو ایم کسی سندھی کو کراچی کا میر لگا دیں تو ان کی سپورٹ کہاں جاۓ گی اگر کسی مہاجر کو پیپلز پارٹی سندھ کا وزیر اعلیٰ لگا دے تو سندھی ووٹ بینک ناراض . اسی طرح اگر ایک غیر پنجابی اور کٹھ پتلی قسم کے بندے کو پنجاب پر مسلط کر دیا جاۓ تو تحریک انصاف کی پنجابی سپورٹ تو ختم ​
tehreek e insaf koi ilqai party nae hai. sab munday khunday unke sath hain jinko ilaqe ki politics ka pta hi nae. so unki siasat b aisi hi hai. mera nae khyal koi fark parega is qadam se un supporters ko.
 
tehreek e insaf koi ilqai party nae hai. sab munday khunday unke sath hain jinko ilaqe ki politics ka pta hi nae. so unki siasat b aisi hi hai. mera nae khyal koi fark parega is qadam se un supporters ko.

جیسے پہلے الکٹبل کی سیاست سے کوئی فرق نہیں پڑنا تھا بعد میں پڑ گیا ​
 
Advertisement
جیسے پہلے الکٹبل کی سیاست سے کوئی فرق نہیں پڑنا تھا بعد میں پڑ گیا ​
It is a good point. Racial/ethnic fault lines tu hai pakistan Mei as per ISPR ya in other words cultural/ethnic diversity hai as per liberal media commentators. It makes sense to please the prevalent majority and appease them by appointing to powerful position like CM one of their power symbols.
But honestly who could replace Shahbaz sharif in this context from across the spectrum? Best bet would be Hamza shahbaz. Nobody else from any party would even come close to have the same impact.

So why play a game if it is rigged for you to lose. Why take chances? Why experiment with choices like Buzdaar?

It did not make any sense for IMRAN khan to break through with such entrenched political parties and people already in power. IMRAN should not even have tried going by the conventional wisdom. But he did. He experimented. He made a lot of mistakes. Took some drastic decisions. And here he is today still battling it out. There is no guarantee for him to succeed or he might become a morphed version of status quo. But it is fun to play the game. IMRAN is in it for the ride and for the high. He might flip-flop or his decisions might fail but he certainly won’t give up. And his experimentation spree might continue.
He will not be shy that is for sure. Buzdaar might be a masterstroke or failure but it could have only played out with IMRAN at the helm. The guy has the courage for gambling.
 
Globally rightist ya conservatives ya populists power Mei aa rahay hain. The shift is indicative of a more deeper issue. Social media dynamics apni jaga hain but traditional sober political manipulations are gradually fading. Multiple reasons ho saktay hai iss shift ke but hypocrisy of the ruling elite might be a contributor. Populist are not likely to perform going by the traditional wisdom and the nature of change taking shape to be slow. So this global shift might be temporary and trumps, modis, and IMRAN might not last longer.
Domestically I don’t see pmln or ppp having solutions for the economic issues. Rampant joblessness & state being ignorant of the issue is not imran’s doing. Even if they are to mess up they have to be given a chance.
 
Advertisement
It is a good point. Racial/ethnic fault lines tu hai pakistan Mei as per ISPR ya in other words cultural/ethnic diversity hai as per liberal media commentators. It makes sense to please the prevalent majority and appease them by appointing to powerful position like CM one of their power symbols.
But honestly who could replace Shahbaz sharif in this context from across the spectrum? Best bet would be Hamza shahbaz. Nobody else from any party would even come close to have the same impact.

So why play a game if it is rigged for you to lose. Why take chances? Why experiment with choices like Buzdaar?

It did not make any sense for IMRAN khan to break through with such entrenched political parties and people already in power. IMRAN should not even have tried going by the conventional wisdom. But he did. He experimented. He made a lot of mistakes. Took some drastic decisions. And here he is today still battling it out. There is no guarantee for him to succeed or he might become a morphed version of status quo. But it is fun to play the game. IMRAN is in it for the ride and for the high. He might flip-flop or his decisions might fail but he certainly won’t give up. And his experimentation spree might continue.
He will not be shy that is for sure. Buzdaar might be a masterstroke or failure but it could have only played out with IMRAN at the helm. The guy has the courage for gambling.
The fate of a nation is not decided in gambling sitting in casino. Once he was saying he would end corruption in 100 days , he would do miracles in 100 days like he was master of everything but the reality is he is overestimated and overconfident illiterate person who can't do the basic math. Things will get worst if same attitude continue and at some point economy can lose balance.
I could never imagine such idiocy that you bring unknown person at top position undermining all sacrifices of your workers and politics. That is result of his unreal imaginary might created by useless people around him those who depend on him have put him at the rank of Lord who can do any miracle. Leadership is to follow public opinion not to impose your wish on people. Now he has gone against public wish so he will have a cold response in future . He had many persons even from south Punjab more eligible but who can think a Lords merit.
He has started his journey to be the most hated person from most liked person. This gamble will cost everything in his life even his trust future will be in danger due his political failure. More people will get hurt because of his wrong policies and more hate he'll earn. That is end of story his ugly face under make up will be unveiled
 
The fate of a nation is not decided in gambling sitting in casino. Once he was saying he would end corruption in 100 days , he would do miracles in 100 days like he was master of everything but the reality is he is overestimated and overconfident illiterate person who can't do the basic math. Things will get worst if same attitude continue and at some point economy can lose balance.
I could never imagine such idiocy that you bring unknown person at top position undermining all sacrifices of your workers and politics. That is result of his unreal imaginary might created by useless people around him those who depend on him have put him at the rank of Lord who can do any miracle. Leadership is to follow public opinion not to impose your wish on people. Now he has gone against public wish so he will have a cold response in future . He had many persons even from south Punjab more eligible but who can think a Lords merit.
He has started his journey to be the most hated person from most liked person. This gamble will cost everything in his life even his trust future will be in danger due his political failure. More people will get hurt because of his wrong policies and more hate he'll earn. That is end of story his ugly face under make up will be unveiled
There was no balance in economy to begin with. Because the mask on our crumbling economy is uncovered now does not mean IK is resposible for all the mess. His merits and demerits are debate-able and you can chose to focus on his demerits just like Rehan Khan chose to do in her book. It won’t change the reality that we as a nation have degraded to a point that it is not easy to reverse things. IMRAN may fail but again he cannot be made scapegoat for 70 years of failed policies. At worst he overestimated himself and won’t succeed in delivering. But who is to guarantee same old faces which have devoured pakistan for 70 years are going to deliver. IMRAN cannot singlehandedly bring a country down in 1 or 5 years just like Trump cannot bring US down in his tenure. But again those who follow trump or IMRAN are not likely to deliver but can be better projected by media at best.
 
There was no balance in economy to begin with. Because the mask on our crumbling economy is uncovered now does not mean IK is resposible for all the mess. His merits and demerits are debate-able and you can chose to focus on his demerits just like Rehan Khan chose to do in her book. It won’t change the reality that we as a nation have degraded to a point that it is not easy to reverse things. IMRAN may fail but again he cannot be made scapegoat for 70 years of failed policies. At worst he overestimated himself and won’t succeed in delivering. But who is to guarantee same old faces which have devoured pakistan for 70 years are going to deliver. IMRAN cannot singlehandedly bring a country down in 1 or 5 years just like Trump cannot bring US down in his tenure. But again those who follow trump or IMRAN are not likely to deliver but can be better projected by media at best.
I know that it will take time to understand the economic engineering done by Dar and I know that everywhere in world economic engineering works . It will be impossible for minister of economy to run economy on policy basis. Definitely previous govts transferred the faulty system with greater burden to PTI but now they will not be blamed for Inflation or bankruptcy of Pakistan present govt will have to face the rage
But other side can't do better economy no problem what about governance issues the political transfers and postings the nepotism and everything traditional what is the change
 
I know that it will take time to understand the economic engineering done by Dar and I know that everywhere in world economic engineering works . It will be impossible for minister of economy to run economy on policy basis. Definitely previous govts transferred the faulty system with greater burden to PTI but now they will not be blamed for Inflation or bankruptcy of Pakistan present govt will have to face the rage
But other side can't do better economy no problem what about governance issues the political transfers and postings the nepotism and everything traditional what is the change
Governance issues are a clear failure on many fronts. Part of it is the inherited beurocracy. There are serious capacity issues apart from nepotism, corruption, non-seriousness, apathy,incompetence, lack of professional ethos, integrity issues, laziness etc. Structural problems , file system and redundancy also pose serious challenges. When you have myriad of issues and lack of competent human resource whether it is political, public sector or private sector it obviously becomes a problem. Follow up is not there on a lot of initiatives. There were few good choices in a few positions but whatever culminated out of political considerations might not yield desired results. It is not the failure that will be a concern but how quickly they can resolve failures and how quickly they can build a team which is reliable is a challenge. From the looks of it, it might take them a long time or they might not be able to do it. Like in kpk they are stuck between status quo and reforms, it might be the same in federal. Punjab as opposed to popular opinion I consider Buzdaar as a good choice and he might yield results which others cannot do.