- Joined
- Jan 27, 2015
- Posts
- 49
- Reaction score
- 55
- Points
- 0
Last edited by a moderator:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
His ignorance never ceases to amaze me!
God or Prophet have NEVER said that jannat lies under Mothers feet. This is a total lie. It's mentioned in a Za'if Hadith of Tirmidhi. It not Tirmidi its Sunsn Nasi
It was narrated from Mu’awiyah bin Jahimah As-Sulami, that Jahimah came to the Prophet (PBUH) and said, “O Messenger of Allah! I want to go out and fight (in Jihad) and I have come to ask your advice.” He said, “Do you have a mother?” He said, “Yes.” He said, “Then stay with her, for Paradise is beneath her feet.” (Hadith No. 3106, Book of Jihad, Sunan An-Nasa’i, Vol. 4).
Quran has NEVER said that disobedience of Parents is the second biggest sin. He's lying. And lying openly without any shame.
It is narrated on the authority of Hadhrat Anas bin Malik (May Allah be well pleased with him), he says: The Holy Prophet (Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam) was asked about major sins. He said: Ascribing partners to Allah, disobeying one’s parents, murdering someone and giving false testimony are major sins. (Sahih Bukhari, Hadith No. 2653)
When he quotes Quran, he gives reference. Please read carefully, he did not say its in Quran.
It seems that your only motive is to prove that Islam does not give any importance to women. That's why you did not discuss the reference he gave from Quran in support of women right and respect.
It seems that your only motive is to prove that Islam does not give any importance to women. That's why you did not discuss the reference he gave from Quran in support of women right and respect.
Why are you lying openly? Islam or Quran does not give Women any rights, period! If Islam allows men to beat their wives, why don't women get the same rights? If men can marry upto 4 women, why should'nt women get the same rights? Its easy to come here and brag about women rights, where in reality there are none.
He hasn't read Islam yet. He spesks his perception, not facts. He dinf even know that Nisai carried no importance thus he referred to Nisai's hadith. Let's hope he read actual Islam instead of relying in perception and propaganda.
Well that is the real problem, isn't?
People's actual religion is not what it seems rather just what they have heard from their parents, its really amazing the lack of knowledge about religion here.
Why are you lying openly? Islam or Quran does not give Women any rights, period! If Islam allows men to beat their wives, why don't women get the same rights? If men can marry upto 4 women, why should'nt women get the same rights? Its easy to come here and brag about women rights, where in reality there are none.
I hope you get women rights for your WOMEN, especially marry as many time as they want.
"Yes..Islam does not give any respect to women. I've written threads on it."
Your one sentence says it all..
FYI.
Your Lord has decreed that you worship none but Him and that you be kind to parents. Whether one or both of them attain old age in your life, say not to them a word of contempt, nor repel them, but address them in terms of honor. And out of kindness, lower to them the wing of humility and say, "My Lord! Bestow on them Your Mercy even as they cherished me in childhood." [Noble Quran 17:23-24]
A man came to the Prophet and said: O Messenger of Allah! Who from amongst mankind warrants the best companionship from me? He replied: "Your mother." The man asked: Then who? So he replied: "Your mother." The man then asked: Then who? So the Prophet replied again: "Your mother." The man then asked: Then who? So he replied: "Then your father." (Sahh Bukhr 5971 and Sahh Muslim 7/2)
I know of no other deed that brings people closer to Allah than kind treatment and respect towards one's mother.”[Al-Adab al-Mufrad Bukhr 1/45 nm
Sorry no more discussion,
Thanks for two important references.
1. As I had mentioned in Quran you cannot come up with a single verse where God has asked to respect Mother, exclusively.
I knew this aya therefore I had used the word "Exclusively" as it is claimed by Muslims that Mother is given special treatment or respect in Islam.
2. In the second Hadith, word " Haq bahsan sahabti" is used. But Islam negates it when it denies Mother's equal right to inheritance.
That means, you should spend time with your mother, if possible but when it comes to Practical Rights, Mother stands nowhere. She can be beaten by Father. She cannot divorce. She cannot inherit as much as Father. So on and so forth
Let's come to the last argument. Islam heavily relies on Orders. Everything important ( according to Islam) has been issued as an Order. In this hadith it's NOT an order. It's not generalised either.
What if that Sahabi had not asked that question?
So, of course there would be no mention of Mothers at all.
If Islam wanted, it could issue a directive for Mothers. It did not. This hadith is a conversation between Prophet SAW and His companion, which was probably never supposed to go public or known and remembered by others.
Cheers
Its rightly said that little or incomplete knowledge is a dangerous thing. You are an excellent example of the same.
First you dont have basic understanding of Hadith and especially of Dai'f Hadith. For what purpose Dai'f Ahadith were still kept even after knowing that they are Daif and for what it may be used or not, your comments show that you dont even have a basic knowledge of this except for saying that the Hadith is Dai'f and then discarding it. I will not explain it for you and you should either continue wandering in your ignorance or find the right way out. May Allah help you with the latter.
Secondly Allah's Prophet has at many instances talked about different sins and narrated them in different orders which we believe is the order of there severity as well. Killthecorrupts provided you with a Hadith from Sahih Bukhari wherein disobeying parents has been kept on 2nd number in the order. You straight away discarded it as well. Now I say that if you are not a liar of highest order then you produce a Sahi Hadith which would explicitly say that disobeying parents is not a second greatest sin rather its 4th, 5th or 6th. Else I will consider you the biggest liar of this forum.
Coming to your demand of Quran asking respect for mothers explicitly, this is another absurd proposition. Whats wrong with talking about mothers and fathers collectively? Quran talks about the Principles which it has set rightly. Its not talking about your personal family matters which you might be facing from your childhood.
"Practical Rights" is also a new english word which i have learnt today from you. Dear, you need to once again learn and understand why Islam allowed a man for punishing a women and in what conditions. Please dont consider what might be happening in your family is Islam's teaching. Divorce also is a right which a female can demand at the time of marriage. If a female surrenders it at his own will, then its not Islams wrong.
The last thing addressing your comment about orders. So this is the Epic of your intellect.
You need to understand difference between a crime and a sin. There are crimes which are sins as well. So we have orders and punishments for those in Islam. However, there are sins which are not categorized as crimes in this world since they are more related to moral behaviour of a person leading to emotional disturbance for others. Such sins will be punished in the life hereafter.
BTW your hypocricy and double standards are very clear from here. On one side, you want Islam to pass a a directive on mothers, and on the other hand when you are given with a Hadith describing it as a major sin, you discard that Hadith only because it talks about both the parents and not just mother. Epic..
It is your absolute idiocy that Hadith was never supposed to go public and remembered.
If its true, bring 5 Sala's from Quran with their names, Raka's, possible way of praying Sala, and the prayers to be recited in Sala. Sala is the basic thing and if you remained unable to prove it then it will be another claim against you. Once you will provide this info from Quran, then I will ask one by one about all other things which are crucial in ISlam and be ready to prove them from Quran alone.
Peace
Brother you didnt answer any of my questions. Not a single one you answered. And now you have stamped your ignorance by saying that every Imam has advocated that no ruling to be made on Dai'f ahadith. Honestly deep in my heart I have pity and sympathy with you on your ignorance and your blatant way of trying to describe things with your own logic. (in Islam ruling is something else and Fazeelat is something else. Your obviously mixing both).Dear brother
It’ll limit my reply to the points raised by you.
1. In the said Hadith, Prophet SAW has not used the word “Second”. Neither did he say that it was a list of Sins by precedence, order, or importance. Orya added it by himself.
2. He narrated Quran, and Quranic aya and then suddenly he writes two Ahadith; one was Za'if and the other was Manipulated as he added what was not said. This was grave mistake. He has a habit of exaggerating things to suit his purpose. He may not add a single word from his own, no matter how good his intentions are.
3. Now you know that Prophet SAW has NEVER said it’s “Second” biggest sin. However that was not the only concern. They say he wrote those two Ahadith was also objectionable. He said “God has declared it biggest sin after Shirk”. But God has never said that. It was a big lie too as it was not Hadith-e-Qudsi. It was a Hadith-e-Nabvi.
We can say God has said this only about that Hadith which is categorised by Imams as Hadith-e-Qudsi. I'm sure you know the difference.
4. Orya lied again when he quoted the Second Hadith. He said God has said that.
It was neither Hadith-e-Qudsi, nor Hadith-e-Nabvi. It was just a Zai'f Hadith which was not to be believed. He mentioned it as if it’s in Quran. Read his paragraph again and you'd get the impression I'm talking about.
5. By Practical Rights, I meant to refer to the Laws of Islam. For example inheritance laws, laws for being a Witness, laws related to Divorce etc. Orders of Islam that have a “practical impact” on women in general.
6. About Za’if Ahadith, every Imam has advocated that no recommendation rulings be made on Za’if Ahadith.
Imam Muslim called it an obligation to discard Za’if Ahadith. Za’if Ahadith are merely “conjectures” and a conjecture should not be ascribed to a Prophet who is followed by Billions. There’s a reason Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim dint accept Za’if Ahadith.
But in this article this man is attributing Za’if Ahadith directly to God.
7. Why I underscored the point that Quran in specific and Hadith in general Do Not state that a Mother deserve special treatment, is becaise its claimed or perceived by majority of Muslims.
8. Regarding your point that Ahadith were meant to go public which is why Method of Prayer was not mentioned in Quran, there’s two answers:
First: Quran is incomplete in many ways.
Second: A practice performed many times, by thousands, right from the start, did not need Ahadith to be remembered. It had become a part of history. Even if there were no Ahadith about method of Prayer, still we'd know how to pray.
Moreover, if you follow the course of history, you'd know that Umar had put a ban on stating Ahadith. That tells how Early Muslims used fabricated Ahadith to fulfil their personal or group interests and how Umar and his companions thought that remembering and mentioning Ahadith was not important. Rather it was declared a crime.
Had you followed the sequence of discussion, you wouldn’t be confused about my posts.
8
© Copyrights 2008 - 2026 Siasat.pk - All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Disclaimer|