This article lacks proper comparison between islamic and nonislamic taxation system and has the wrong ideas about both sides.
Zakaah is not essentially for everything just for looking after the people told about in the quran ie poor and needy etc etc. Moreover zakaah is on whole of property and wealth one owns over and above what one needs over a period of one year ie it is not like income tax at all. For example, income tax is not paid on wealth one has already paid in come tax once. Zakaah will need to be paid even on the very same wealth every year so long as it remains above ones need. Only essential things are exempt from zakaah.
For example if one earn 100,000 Rs and tax rate is 10% and exemption is also 10% of the income. Then one needs to pay 10% tax on 90,000 Rs = 9000 Rs.
One never needs to pay tax again on this money.
On the other hand zakaay is 2.5% but it is on whole of one's wealth and property. So if one has 11 houses but only needs one then one needs to pay zakaah on the rest of the houses so long as they have been owned by one for a year ie one needs to get them valued and thereby calculate how much zakaah one will need to pay on that extra property.
Suppose the value comes to one million Rs then 1,000,000X0.025 = 25,000 Rs. This amount needs to be paid each year on the same properties if their value does not appreciate.
Zakaah does not stop a government from taking more money from people if the money coming in is found to be insufficient to meet the esential services that public needs from government to provide.
So it is important for people to understand how islamic system works and how nonislamic system works so that they could a proper comparison between the two.
Also it is not only raising funds is a problem for a government but stoping people from cheating regarding these funds ie people may try and hide their wealth and try not to pay tax or zakaah and any who pay may be lost in form of lack of acccountability and monitoring of funds thereby leaving doors open for officials stealing funds from treasury in various ways.
This whole thing is a very complex issue so people need to become aware of these things and have proper mechanism in place if they want to get the benefits they want.