Advertisement

اختصار پاکستانی خصوصیت نہیں : ایاز امیر

23162_20846738.jpg


https://dunya.com.pk/index.php/author/ayaz-ameer/2018-05-02/23162/20846738
 
Advertisement
جتنی تقاریر کا ذکر کیا وہ ایک فوکسڈ اور جانے سامعین کے سامنے تھیں- وہ ایک خاص طرح کے خطاب ہیں مگر بڑے اور متنوع سامعین کے سامنے مختلف مقاصد ہوتے ہیں، پبلک سپیچ ( وہی جس پر اعتراض کیا جا رہا ہے) کا پہلا اور بنیادی مقصد نئے یا مخالف سامعین (جن کا تعلق ہر قسم کے طبقات اور عمر سے ہے) کو اس بات پر راضی کرنا ہے کہ تقریر کرنے والا انکے دل بات کر رہا ہے، انکی زبان سمجھ رہا ہے، اور پھر یہ کہ اسکا اپنا خیال بھی در حقیقت کچھ مختلف نہیں- - دوسرا مقصد یہ یقین دلانا ہے کہ وہ سامعین سے مخلص ہے- اگر بات صرف اپنی بات یا معلومات دینے کی ہو تو آپ اپنی پسند کے سامعین کو جمع کر کے واضح اور 'ٹو دی پوائنٹ' بات کرتے ہیں- -ۂ ​
 
Advertisement
اس جوکر اور نواز شریف کے گھٹیا مالشئے بین کی فراری بٹ نے جو کسی کتے والی کی ہے اور اسکو اسکی اوقات میں واپس لے آئی ہے اسکی جگہ کوئی غیرت مند اور حلالی ہوتا تو بڑ ھکیں مارنے کی جگہ کچھ کر کے دکھاتا یہ جاہل کا بچہ اور گنجا جوکر چلا ہوا کارتوس ہے
 
جتنی تقاریر کا ذکر کیا وہ ایک فوکسڈ اور جانے سامعین کے سامنے تھیں- وہ ایک خاص طرح کے خطاب ہیں مگر بڑے اور متنوع سامعین کے سامنے مختلف مقاصد ہوتے ہیں، پبلک سپیچ ( وہی جس پر اعتراض کیا جا رہا ہے) کا پہلا اور بنیادی مقصد نئے یا مخالف سامعین (جن کا تعلق ہر قسم کے طبقات اور عمر سے ہے) کو اس بات پر راضی کرنا ہے کہ تقریر کرنے والا انکے دل بات کر رہا ہے، انکی زبان سمجھ رہا ہے، اور پھر یہ کہ اسکا اپنا خیال بھی در حقیقت کچھ مختلف نہیں- - دوسرا مقصد یہ یقین دلانا ہے کہ وہ سامعین سے مخلص ہے- اگر بات صرف اپنی بات یا معلومات دینے کی ہو تو آپ اپنی پسند کے سامعین کو جمع کر کے واضح اور 'ٹو دی پوائنٹ' بات کرتے ہیں- -ۂ ​
kia baat kee hai aap ne.
Hitler delivered speech to entire awam.

Fact of the matter is, IK is not a genius or an intellectual or even a learned person. He is a sportsman.
His speech and interviews are poor but not any worse than shareefs or zardaris.
 
kia baat kee hai aap ne.
Hitler delivered speech to entire awam.
Fact of the matter is, IK is not a genius or an intellectual or even a learned person. He is a sportsman.
His speech and interviews are poor but not any worse than shareefs or zardaris.

There is nothing much to comment on your second point except for a silence.

But on the literary worth of the speeches of Hitler (or Churchill) you are right. (Though I've not heard him except for reading a few once on the suggestion of a teacher, and oft repeated phrases/passages in the history books.). Hitler was focused; He wrote by himself and edited his key speeches several times. There is peculiar quality of German language to express the abstract (somewhat in Urdu as well due to its poetic background) and the complex. For us readers of the English translations it is real torture to read the German (or Russian) books especially those of the science or philosophy.

In any case, Hitler's were also in a sense 'wartime speeches', but moreover, there was vast political literature of hopes and rise of Germany of pre-war-1 and the later regarding their despair and defeated. Also, also after the political defeat of anarchists, the socialist rhetoric had won in the academic and industrial halls. Those were the times, full of alternate political ideas and conflicts and the vulgarities of the war were vivid; that had pushed the whole European politics towards the edge, towards breakup and regeneration. In any case, the Germans were well educated and their working class was vastly politically learned and organized since, at that times, the labor unions had the most political sway ever in Europe. Let’s read the Hitler’s speeches as a part of the intra-war literature.

And this brings me back to the point I was making in my comment. The political speeches and discourse (and including the leadership) is not independent of their times and the people they serve, but the opposite. Amir, rather than criticizing, had pondered on the question that why a pointed and “flowery” speech was neither needed nor would had not added much. Why the vast majority of the listener deem it successful and were satisfies? Ours are the times, split between globalism and nationalism, religion and internet invasion, public welfare and FDI led development. None is clear except for the vague ideas of imitated goals. Religion/conservatism has utterly failed to sooth down. We are a nation which is still stuck in a fake and futile arguments about political control, albeit on the instigation of a rich political class, than to have courage to opt between diverse ideas and ideals of social and cultural visions. In this environment of confusion, fear and self divide, what could some flowery rhetoric and grand ideals had achieved. Lacking grand ideas and ideals, be content with the bland speeches from one leader or the other. The purpose of the political speeches is partially the solidarity and partially to convince and win over the audience. It is the times (and the audience) that dictate weather a detailed raw language or a flowery and stern abstract rhetoric is needed. With apology to Amir, wish we may not come to the times when the speeches like of Hitler, Lincoln or Churchill become meaningful. – back to work.