Advertisement

The Most Muslim Populated City in US Overwhelmingly Votes for Jewish Sanders over Clinton in MI

Bernie Sanders’s upset in the Michigan primary Tuesday can be attributed in part to a strong showing in Dearborn, Michigan, which has the largest concentration of Arab Americans in the nation. Sanders won almost 60 percent of the vote there, besting rival Hillary Clinton.


“Believing in something unpopular and fighting for those things is true courage and bravery. I feel personally connected to his message of humanism and peace,” Mason Hinawi, a high school student and first-time Dearborn Heights voter, told The Intercept about his support for Sanders. “I know a lot of Muslim people my age also taken by his message of peace and his welcoming tone.”

An analysis by the Dearborn-based Arab American News showed that heavily-populated Arab neighborhoods in the city went overwhelmingly for Sanders — 210 to 101 in Southern Salina, a Yemeni American neighborhood, for example. The paper estimated that “Arab Americans voted 2 to 1 for Sanders in almost every east Dearborn precinct.” East Dearborn is where most Arab Americans live.

The win came following sustained outreach by the Sanders campaign aimed at Arab and Muslim Americans, in Dearborn and elsewhere.

In October, Sanders shared an emotional moment with a Muslim college student who asked him to stand up to Islamophobia. He invited her up to the stage and cited his own background as the grandson of Holocaust victims as informing his views on bigotry, telling her “there is a lot of anger being generated, hatred being generated against Muslims in this country….If we stand for anything we have got to stand together and end all forms of racism”:


Two months later, Sanders attended a roundtable event at the Masjid Muhammad mosque in Washington, D.C. “Do we come together, or do we allow demagogues to divide us up? That is the issue of the moment,” he said, condemning the Islamophobia coming out of the GOP side of the race.

In February, his campaign tweeted out a graphic in Arabic that translates into “Not me, us”:

Screen-Shot-2016-03-09-at-4.06.45-PM-859x1024.png



The tweet included Arabic text that translates into, “America becomes a greater nation when we stand together and say no to racism, hatred, and bigotry.”

“His whole campaign and his whole demeanor and his whole sort of discourse fits much more into the Arab American community and our discourse,” said Amer Zahr, who lives in Dearborn and teaches at the University of Detroit. Zahr met with Sanders at a private event last week.

“Our community is no stranger to Hillary Clinton and to her kind of ultra-right wing policies when it comes to Israel, her relationship to [donor] Haim Saban,” Zahr said. “Bernie doesn’t talk like that at all. We asked him about Palestine and Israel…he said that he would look at both sides equally, which no politician says.” (Howard Dean flirted with the conceptof evenhandedness during his 2004 run for the presidency, but backtracked after coming under attack from Democratic politicians.)

Zahr credited Sanders’s showing to “the combination of our community being very familiar, and not in a good way, with Hillary Clinton and her hawkishness…and the progressive message of Sanders’s campaign hits home for a lot of us.”


The editorial board of the Arab American News endorsed Sanders, citing his words against Islamophobia and his more dovish foreign policy. As the Michigan primary neared, his campaign began airing Arabic-language radio ads in the Dearborn area, and the day before the primary he visited the city itself.

In an hour-long speech where he was introduced by Rep. Keith Ellison, D-Minnesota, the first Muslim-American elected to Congress, Sanders condemned Islamophobia and pledged to treat all parties in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as equals.

This outreach stood in contrast to the Clinton campaign. Hillary Clinton never visited Dearborn or held any events there; her husband Bill Clinton did a short swing through market areas there while campaigning for his wife in Detroit.

“I was at the [Sanders] event…most of the crowd was Arab American,” Ali Harb, a reporter at the Arab American News, said in an interview. “Bernie Sanders has successfully mobilized young voters and Arab American young folks were no exception. They were moved by his message, they were excited.”


Harb also cited another factor in the enthusiasm for Sanders: GOP frontrunner Donald Trump. “You can’t have a political conversation in Dearborn without Donald Trump coming up. A lot of people are anxious about Donald Trump so they’ve become more interested in the political process because they’re quite frankly scared of what happens if Trump becomes president. So that helped draw turnout.”

A number of media commentators wondered why the first viable Jewish contender for the presidency would be winning support from Arab and Muslim Americans. The answer appears to be simple: Sanders won Dearborn the same way any candidate wins any constituency, by listening to them and responding to their concerns.

For Asha Mohamood Noor, a Muslim American voter registration activist who lives in the Dearborn area, Sanders’s Jewish background was a plus. “I think that one really key element of that is that Bernie often discusses, often talks about, the oppression faced by the Jewish people in Europe,” she said in an interview. “Definitely, I think it appeals to [Muslim American] emotions because they’re feeling a lot of backlash in America and around the world, and he often draws a parallel between the Jewish struggle and the Arab and Muslim struggle in a way that is very genuine and very true.”

She also pointed to Sanders ultimately gaining ground in the community for the same reasons he is attracting support from many others. “I know people want to run with the narrative of Arabs and Muslims voting for a Jew, but I think it all boils down to socioeconomic status, unions, fair wages, labor reform….his religion almost never came up [among voters], it was his vision for restoring a middle class, and uplifting folks out of poverty.”

https://theintercept.com/2016/03/09...largest-arab-community-by-being-open-to-them/
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
why would a sane Muslim ever vote for Clinton?...she voted for Iraq war and pushed for intervention in Libya and Syria...she is still being very hawkish in her campaign and pushing for more regime changes in the middle east..

and she can claim credit for the Iran deal all she wants but those of us who keep track of politics have not forgotten that in 2008 campaign against Obama, she was even against starting talks with Iran over a deal..the only reason there was a deal and not a war was because Obama was elected...

Also lets not forget that in her emails, she said that its time for US corporations to think of Iraq as an investment opportunity...lets not forget that her campaign is being funded by many companies who would benefit from these "investment opportunities" in middle east..

So please, for the sake of peace in Muslim countries -do not vote for Clinton.
 
Advertisement
Vote should be based on future policies and performance. Nothing to do with religion.

May be not in a typical election but not in this one where one of the strongest candidates is gaining momentum by dividing the country on the basis of religious belief and origin!
 
He is honest and bold and much better a candidate than Hilary Clinton who is nothing but political ****. She is supported by special interests of war mongers. His campaign is supported by common people that is revolutionary diffirence btween the two.
 
May be not in a typical election but not in this one where one of the strongest candidates is gaining momentum by dividing the country on the basis of religious belief and origin!

It would be an over-simplification to think he is getting his support just from racists..
 
Advertisement
We have had Jewish people stand should to shoulder with us during our protest for Palestine. They brought their families including babies. I am not going to lie but I was a bit shocked and surprised at first but they helped me come of the bubble that I was stuck in. People (or I should say Humans) can really come together regardless of race, religion, ethnicity and so on. Beside that I love Sanders but unfortunately in my opinion He won't survive Washington and the promises that he is making are not going to happen or lets say not going to be effective. I personally voted for Clinton during the Primaries but to be honest it felt like I was voting to elect the best clown for the White House. I know may of you would have objections to this but President Obama has set the bar really high for future presidents and non these clowns are fit for the White House. Don't even mention the Republican candidates lol.
 
the only sane choice america left with, but seems like they l go for an insane one, like modi is ruining india, trump/hilary will ruin US for ever

what is terrifying is that Trump is to the left of Hillary when it comes to foreign policy...she is a neo-con dressed as a democrat
 
We have had Jewish people stand should to shoulder with us during our protest for Palestine. They brought their families including babies. I am not going to lie but I was a bit shocked and surprised at first but they helped me come of the bubble that I was stuck in. People (or I should say Humans) can really come together regardless of race, religion, ethnicity and so on. Beside that I love Sanders but unfortunately in my opinion He won't survive Washington and the promises that he is making are not going to happen or lets say not going to be effective. I personally voted for Clinton during the Primaries but to be honest it felt like I was voting to elect the best clown for the White House. I know may of you would have objections to this but President Obama has set the bar really high for future presidents and non these clowns are fit for the White House. Don't even mention the Republican candidates lol.

well, Sanders was set to lose michigan with 20+ but won it...nothing is impossible..what's the point of life if you don't even want to hope for a better option?
 
Advertisement
why would a sane Muslim ever vote for Clinton?...she voted for Iraq war and pushed for intervention in Libya and Syria...she is still being very hawkish in her campaign and pushing for more regime changes in the middle east..

and she can claim credit for the Iran deal all she wants but those of us who keep track of politics have not forgotten that in 2008 campaign against Obama, she was even against starting talks with Iran over a deal..the only reason there was a deal and not a war was because Obama was elected...

Also lets not forget that in her emails, she said that its time for US corporations to think of Iraq as an investment opportunity...lets not forget that her campaign is being funded by many companies who would benefit from these "investment opportunities" in middle east..

So please, for the sake of peace in Muslim countries -do not vote for Clinton.

Muslims in the US had made a big mistake with similar short sighted approach by supporting Bush over Gore.

Clinton may not be the ideal candidate but she has a lot better chance to withstand the pressure from the strident right compared to Sanders.

Don't get me wrong, I like Sanders and would support him over Clinton in a presidential race if they were the only candidates but you have to understand that white america is charged after 8 years of Obama and would not stand to elect a person who is far to the left of Obama. They will come out in droves to beat Sanders as they will see him as an extension of Obama with even a far more sharper bent to the left.

The ideal situation would be for Sanders to give Hillary a tough fight and rally the base so that she tilts to the left to make sure that Sanders supporters don't desert the party and stay at home and therein lies the win for the saner element over the crazies on the right.

In the bigger scheme of things even if Sanders wins the presidential election he will have a tougher fight than what Obama or Carter faced. The gang on the right is all riled up and a Sanders presidency would be a non-starter.

We just have to be realistic. Ideally Sanders is the best candidate but realistically if he is the candidate for the democratic party then there is a very strong chance that you will see a crazy named Trump in the white house.
 
Last edited:
what is terrifying is that Trump is to the left of Hillary when it comes to foreign policy...she is a neo-con dressed as a democrat

well, she will have to re-calibrate her stances and message on foreign policy after Sanders' challenge.


don't forget that she served as foreign sec. in the obama administration. You couldn't be a neo-con and be in charge of obama's foreign policy.
 
HISTORY IN THE MAKING

Clinton will be the First Female President

Sanders will be the First Jewish President

Cruze will be the First Canadian President

Trump will be the Last President



Who do you support?
 
Muslims in the US have made a big mistake with similar short sighted approach by supporting Bush over Gore.

Clinton may not be the ideal candidate but she has a lot better chance to withstand the pressure from the strident right compared to Sanders.

Don't get me wrong, I like Sanders and would support him over Clinton in a presidential race if they were the only candidates but you have to understand that white america is charged after 8 years of Obama and would not stand to elect a person who is far to the left of Obama. They will come out in droves to beat Sanders as they will see him as an extension of Obama with even a far more sharper bent to the left.

The ideal situation would be for Sanders to give Hillary a tough fight and rally the base so that she tilts to the left to make sure that Sanders supporters don't desert the party and stay at home and therein lies the win for the saner element over the crazies on the right.

In the bigger scheme of things even if Sanders wins the presidential election he will have a tougher fight than what Obama or Carter faced. The gang on the right is all riled up and a Sanders presidency would be a non-starter.

We just have to be realistic. Ideally Sanders is the best candidate but realistically if he is the candidate for the democratic party then there are very strong chances that you will see a crazy named Trump in the white house.

What pressure you think she is going to stand coming from Republicans which Sanders can't? TPP? Corporations who want TPP back her, she will compromise and pass it...Moving towards green energy? Fossil fuel industry is backing her so she will be with republicans on that..She is going to be the same old as Obama..go back to centre-right and compromise with them instead of pulling them to left...and as far as foreign interventions are concerned, puh-lease! as if a neo-con like her needs pressure from republicans to be persuaded to go to war...she is hawkish enough already..

P.S: Almost all polls have Sanders beating Trump by bigger margins than Clinton because he pulls in independents at >70% whereas Clinton gets them around only30% - and 42% of Americans are independents so I do not buy that argument as she will have trouble winning the swing states


and yes, you have a point about having the black president making GOP crazy but if there is anyone who they hate as much as they hate Obama, its Clinton..they are already talking about impeaching her..so you are going to see that issue with her nomination as well since they will come out in huge numbers just to vote against her...they really really hate her too..and just like they are racists, they are big misogynists as well..so no matter which Dem candidate it is, the socialist Jew or the women they have despised for decades, its only going to radaclize their base further

and no matter what, I will not condemn Muslims for not voting for Clinton who is almost surely bound to increase interventions in middle east...
 
Advertisement
well, she will have to re-calibrate her stances and message on foreign policy after Sanders' challenge.


don't forget that she served as foreign sec. in the obama administration. You couldn't be a neo-con and be in charge of obama's foreign policy.

that's true but you know election year...moving to left in election year doesn't mean you won't go back to center right after getting elected which she most certainly will..
 
HISTORY IN THE MAKING

Clinton will be the First Female President

Sanders will be the First Jewish President

Cruze will be the First Canadian President


Trump will be the Last President



Who do you support?

Please don't let anyone know he is Canadian born again...EVER!
 
well, Sanders was set to lose michigan with 20+ but won it...nothing is impossible..what's the point of life if you don't even want to hope for a better option?
Well you are absolutely right Humi, I guess I will have to make a better decision next time when I go out to vote. Like I said this probably the worst election to witness. There are many other factors that I had to consider before making the decision and to just name a few are Tax Policies, Universal Health care system and all that. I don't agree with paying a good cut of my paycheck that I had work so hard and then lazy people get to live on that money. I would be happy to choose such candidate where I know the opportunities are few (like Pakistan or any other developing country) but in America many people misuse the system for their own benefits with million of unethical excuses. We are already dealing with the flaws of Obama Care. Young people like myself may have a good paying job but don't forget the amount of student loans that we have to pay and the rest I am sure you can understand.
 
Well you are absolutely right Humi, I guess I will have to make a better decision next time when I go out to vote. Like I said this probably the worst election to witness. There are many other factors that I had to consider before making the decision and to just name a few are Tax Policies, Universal Health care system and all that. I don't agree with paying a good cut of my paycheck that I had work so hard and then lazy people get to live on that money. I would be happy to choose such candidate where I know the opportunities are few (like Pakistan or any other developing country) but in America many people misuse the system for their own benefits with million of unethical excuses. We are already dealing with the flaws of Obama Care. Young people like myself may have a good paying job but don't forget the amount of student loans that we have to pay and the rest I am sure you can understand.

yes, I get it...some people are more worried about innocent civilians dying in air strikes and trillions being wasted on interventions instead of being spent at home and some are more concerned about the potential new taxation structure...everyone has their preference over what their bigger issue is..but the point I was making was that if you believe in a candidate, not voting for him just because you think he won't win is silly because if everyone who liked him voted instead of saying it is hopeless - guess what, he will win..
 
Well you are absolutely right Humi, I guess I will have to make a better decision next time when I go out to vote. Like I said this probably the worst election to witness. There are many other factors that I had to consider before making the decision and to just name a few are Tax Policies, Universal Health care system and all that. I don't agree with paying a good cut of my paycheck that I had work so hard and then lazy people get to live on that money. I would be happy to choose such candidate where I know the opportunities are few (like Pakistan or any other developing country) but in America many people misuse the system for their own benefits with million of unethical excuses. We are already dealing with the flaws of Obama Care. Young people like myself may have a good paying job but don't forget the amount of student loans that we have to pay and the rest I am sure you can understand.

BTW, sanders has plan to replace Obamacare with a less flawed plan...Clinton is just going to keep it there or change in a way so it helps big pharma and insurance companies even more...big pharma is not stupid enough to contribute millions to her current campaign otherwise..