Threadstarter's comments : In india too like Pakistan court justices fancy themselves as great thinkers and social trendsetters even if they may be actually be on the lower side of the society in academic qualification and brilliance .
In the decision below Indians have essentially copies current western ethical mores.We in Islam offcourse have our own ways of thinking in medical ethical issues like in www.medical-ethics.org
Euthanasia and beyond: on the Supreme Court's verdict
In a historic decision, the Supreme Court on Friday declared passiveeuthanasia and the right of persons, including the terminally ill, to give advance directives to refuse medical treatment permissible.
A Constitution Bench, led by Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra, in three concurring opinions, upheld that the fundamental right to life and dignity includes right to refuse treatment and die with dignity.
The fundamental right to a "meaningful existence" includes a person's choice to die without suffering, it held.
What's wrong with this verdict? Actually it's very humane to let someone go with dignity who is suffering and only alive using artificial life support systems. If I were in such miserable condition then I would rather like to die than living such miserable life.
I think it takes a little bit of cruelty to tell a person who is suffering in pain due to a terminal illness that no you can't die and you must suffer through this because morals...
What's wrong with this verdict? Actually it's very humane to let someone go with dignity who is suffering and only alive using artificial life support systems. If I were in such miserable condition then I would rather like to die than living such miserable life.
The problem is not in case of terminally ill people not desiring further treatment which many doctors will even now comply with patient's wishes and problem is not with advanced will to prohibit a ventilator or artificial life . There is much more to it and described in medical ethics books such as found and one was quoted above as well . Many people are thus denied life as there are several pitfalls in law and its execution on ground. I will write in detail one day.
I think it takes a little bit of cruelty to tell a person who is suffering in pain due to a terminal illness that no you can't die and you must suffer through this because morals...
The problem is not in case of terminally ill people not desiring further treatment which many doctors will even now comply with patient's wishes and problem is not with advanced will to prohibit a ventilator or artificial life . There is much more to it and described in medical ethics books such as found and one was quoted above as well . Many people are thus denied life as there are several pitfalls in law and its execution on ground. I will write in detail one day.
The problem is not in case of terminally ill people not desiring further treatment which many doctors will even now comply with patient's wishes and problem is not with advanced will to prohibit a ventilator or artificial life . There is much more to it and described in medical ethics books such as found and one was quoted above as well . Many people are thus denied life as there are several pitfalls in law and its execution on ground. I will write in detail one day.
It is first step to allow suicide as allowed in western countries .
The problem is not in case of terminally ill people not desiring further treatment which many doctors will even now comply with patient's wishes and problem is not with advanced will to prohibit a ventilator or artificial life . There is much more to it and described in medical ethics books such as found and one was quoted above as well . Many people are thus denied life as there are several pitfalls in law and its execution on ground. I will write in detail one day.
Yes your confusion is correct . The indian supreme court is taking up many social issues these days and mostly wrongly . There is more to follow this decision which is not going to be anything other than westernization of ethics and Euthanasia in more naked form ,
Yes your confusion is correct . The indian supreme court is taking up many social issues these days and mostly wrongly . There is more to follow this decision which is not going to be anything other than westernization of ethics and Euthanasia in more naked form ,
Yes your confusion is correct . The indian supreme court is taking up many social issues these days and mostly wrongly . There is more to follow this decision which is not going to be anything other than westernization of ethics and Euthanasia in more naked form ,
I have added this for you , issues connected are deeper , this article below is more about legal issues connected . There is much more on this issue from islamic point of view in www.medical-ethics.org about practical and ethical issues involved.
YES | SUSHILA RAO The right declared in ‘Common Cause’ extends to active euthanasia in circumscribed circumstances
Yes, the operative term in the question being “is”, and not “should... be”. If passive euthanasia is a guaranteed fundamental right, a rigid “active” versus “passive” euthanasia distinction (APD) is analytically unsustainable. In Common Cause v. Union of India, the Supreme Court expounded the basis of its 2011 ruling in Aruna Shanbaug v. Union of India, which permitted “passive” euthanasia, including “involuntary” passive euthanasia for mentally incompetent patients, in certain terminal cases. Ruling that Article 21 of the Constitution guaranteed the “right to die with dignity”, the court also issued interim guidelines to enforce individuals’ living wills in case of future incompetence. Active and passive
Aruna and Common Cause have incorporated the judicial APD evolved primarily by U.K. courts. In popular discourse, APD has become shorthand for an apparently axiomatic ethical and legal dichotomy between “killing” and “letting die”. But the ethical and jurisprudential underpinnings of the apex court’s rulings logically dictate that the right declared in Common Cause extends to “active” euthanasia in carefully circumscribed circumstances. Overall, judges and commentators recognise that in the context of euthanasia, ceteris paribus, there is no legally intelligible difference between deliberately “doing” (active) and “not doing or stopping to do” (passive) something that leads to death. Nor is there any articulable reason why “withdrawal” (as opposed to “withholding”) of current treatment isn’t an illegal “active” decision that hastens death from the underlying cause, much like a lethal injection that also accelerates imminent death. To quote Lady Hale of the U.K. Supreme Court in Nicklinson v. Ministry of Justice, “Why does active assistance give rise to moral corruption on the part of the assister (or, for that matter, society as a whole), but passive assistance [does] not?” As a result, APD is a morass of legal fictions about intentionality and the “ultimate” causation of death, which don’t withstand scrutiny. More importantly, it may unjustly deny a recognised fundamental right to those who need assistance to access it. A tragic U.K. case showcased the dangers of treating APD as an axiomatic rule that overrides legitimate requests to exercise the right. Diane Pretty, while mentally competent, was in the terminal stages of incurable motor neurone disease, which left her completely paralysed from the neck down. Faced with the prospect of progressive suffocation as her breathing and swallowing muscles failed, Pretty required assistance to effectuate a dignified and bearable death in a manner and time of her choosing. To be clear, these inherent contradictions in APD are the inevitable outcome of fragmented rule-making by courts hamstrung by the lack of a comprehensive and coherent legislative and policy framework. APD is an elaborate and flawed judicial construct arguably necessitated by overarching policy concerns, namely, potential for abuse by unscrupulous individuals; the spectre of criminal prosecution of benign doctors and families; and the exercise of judicial restraint on a sensitive issue that warrants legislation embodying the democratic will. These dilemmas fall within the realm of Parliament, which must act to resolve them. As Justice D.Y. Chandrachud notes, “the meeting point between bio-ethics and law does not lie on a straight course,” and these complex issues “cannot be addressed without the legalisation and regulation of active euthanasia” (emphasis added). By emphatically erring on the side of self-determination and recognising passive euthanasia with certain safeguards as a fundamental right, Common Cause signals that APD’s days are numbered. Whether couched as “dignified death” or “bodily autonomy”, there is no reasonable basis for negating the right vis-à-vis a patient whose circumstances warrant assistance to exercise it. The views expressed are personal Sushila Rao is a U.S.-based litigator
Yes Indians haven't innovated to invented anything since partition 1947 actually they were better off under British rule, Hollywood is copied by Bollywood and that's it.