Advertisement

Indian Army pinned Pakistan soldier's slaughtered head on a tree: Burkha Dutt (Eye Witness)

IN21_LOC_148213f.jpg


The Lines of Control [Hindustan Times] by KARAN THAPAR

​

The beheading of an Indian soldier on the LoC and the mutilation of another were undoubtedly unacceptable and unpardonable. This was barbaric behaviour. The anger and revulsion it’s provoked is understandable. There’s no denying that. However, there’s one question we need to ask but mainly failed to raise. Have we ever been guilty of similar behaviour ourselves?

From what I can tell the answer seems to be yes. On the 10th, The Hindu reported that last year, during a skirmish at Karnah, “Indian Special Forces responded by attacking a Pakistani forward post, killing several soldiers, and]by the account of one military official which The Hindu could not corroborate independently, beheaded two.”



What makes this claim credible is that it’s reported by military sources who not only ought to know but would not denigrate the reputation of Indian soldiers.

Alas, there’s more evidence. [HI]This time from eye-witnesses.[/HI]

In her ‘Confessions of a War Reporter’, published in June 2001 by Himal, a well-known Nepalese magazine, [HI]Barkha Dutt recounted how she witnessed a decapitated Pakistani soldier’s head at Kargil[/HI]. This is what she wrote: “I had to look three times to make sure I was seeing right … “Look again,” said the army colonel, in a tone that betrayed suppressed excitement. This time, I finally saw. [HI]It was a head, the disembodied face of a slain soldier nailed onto a tree.[/HI] “The boys got it as a gift for the brigade,” said the colonel, softly, but proudly.”


Harinder Baweja, the editor (Investigation) of this paper (Hindustan Times), witnessed something similar. This is the account from her book A Soldier’s Diary, Kargil — The Inside Story: “The experiences of 18 Garhwal show another side of the war … [HI]one of them took out his knife and slit the head of a Pakistani soldier in one stroke.[/HI] The head was sent to Brigade Headquarters at Drass and pinned to a tree trunk … the enemy head, a grisly trophy, became an exhibition piece. Major General Puri came down from Mughalpura to see it. Other officers dropped in to Brigade Headquarters to take a look. So did some journalists …[HI] it was there pinned on the tree for anyone who could bear to look at it[/HI].”


So is this proof that Indian soldiers, both in the recent past and during Kargil, have done to Pakistanis what they did to our jawans last week? The Hindu report is clearly not proof.


On the other hand, what Barkha and Harinder saw seems like it. They are eye-witnesses. They’re highly regarded journalists. They have a reputation for telling the truth. More importantly, they have no reason to lie.


However, my intention is not to establish moral equivalence between Indian and Pakistani soldiers, although some might come to that conclusion. It’s to ask why did the media, other than The Hindu, not point this out? You can’t argue it was irrelevant information. More importantly, it would have put a different complexion on the decapitation of our soldiers. And, certainly, it would have tempered the furious discussions on television.


As journalists we owe our audience not just the truth but both sides of it when that’s pertinent. To not be evenhanded is to leave them half-informed.


[HI]In this instance, we whipped up passions when we should have helped audiences realise the LoC is a tough place, where brutal actions often happen and both sides retaliate in equally gruesome ways. When tempers cool and time lends perspective, our audience won’t forgive us for half-truths.

[/HI] Views expressed by the author are personal.
---

Direct Link of Burkha Dutt Article [Confession of a War Reporter - June 2001. Hemal Magazine]
On (21:15) Admiral Ramdas says, [HI]“Beheading of Troops has been going on from both sides has been for some time, I mean there is evidence of this…”[/HI]

[video]http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/the-buck-stops-here/india-pakistan-another-tipping-point/261981?pfrom=home-topstories[/video]

[HI]Barkha Dutt, eager to change the subject, nervously interjects and says ‘I want you to comment, Sir, on Sporting and Cultural ties, because that is what has been hit today..' [/HI]...

Gen. V.P. Malik says (around 24:40 minutes into the program), “…And I don’t agree with Admiral (Ram) Das that both sides have been doing this, I would like to see anybody give me one instance where this kind of inhuman act has been done by the Indian army… I know that with great respect, we not only buried their bodies with great respect…we returned any body that they asked for.”



Further Interesting reading @ Indian Kafila. Catching Burkha Dutt cover up.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
P.S: I do not want to create hatred, or war hysteria but to counter recent Indian Media's continuous war mongering and propaganda. Instead of pure hatred, lets talk logically.
 
Advertisement
but india is still you peoples beloved country and even your beloved leaders love indian actors who celebrated pakistans every defeat from 1971 to kargil.shame on such people who love their enemy and their culture but use their full resources against mujahideen of islam
 
but india is still you peoples beloved country and even your beloved leaders love indian actors who celebrated pakistans every defeat from 1971 to kargil.shame on such people who love their enemy and their culture but use their full resources against mujahideen of islam

:P an emotional statement !!
 
Majority of the commissioned officers of pakistan, are baigharat, coward, lazy, corrupt and unable to fight. But the Jawans are true warriores.
 
Advertisement
1999 Indians Soldiers Beheaded Pakistanis

270827_584383678256455_1276541451_n.jpg



[h=1]Dear Barkha Dutt: The Buck Stops Where?[/h]

by Shuddhabrata Sengupta



On the of latest edition, (telecast a few hours ago, on the evening of the 15th of January, 2013) of The Buck Stops Here, (a flagship news show on NDTV anchored by Barkha Dutt) India-Pakistan:Another Tipping Point, Admiral (Retd.) Ramdas, former chief of the Indian Navy said he knew that Indian forces have beheaded Pakistani soldiers in the past. Gen. (Retd.) V.P. Malik, former chief of the Indian Army contradicted him, and said this had never happened. Barkha Dutt was silent on this matter. Below is a summary of some highlights of the discussion. Around 21:15 minutes into the programme, Admiral Ramdas says, Beheading of Troops has been going on from both sides has been for some time, I mean there is evidence of this Barkha Dutt, eager to change the subject, nervously interjects and says I want you to comment, Sir, on Sporting and Cultural ties, because that is what has been hit today. Why is she so anxious to change the subject? Is it because Admiral Ramdas is clearly speaking about something she personally does not want spoken about? Then, a little later, Ms. Dutt asks Gen. Malik to speak, she also asks him to talk whether Sporting and Cultural Ties should become the fall-guy. Gen. V.P. Malik says (around 24:40 minutes into the program), And I dont agree with Admiral (Ram) Das that both sides have been doing this, I would like to see anybody give me one instance where this kind of inhuman act has been done by the Indian army I know that with great respect, we not only buried their bodies with great respectwe returned any body that they asked for. Barkha Dutt knows what Admiral Ramdas was talking about. As has been pointed out before on Kafila, she has written about it (the decapitation of Pakistani soldiers by the Indian army during the Kargil conflict in the summer of 1999) herself in Himal magazine (June, 2001).
I had to look three times to make sure I was seeing right. Balanced on one knee, in a tiny alley behind the armys administrative offices, I was peering through a hole in a corrugated tin sheet. At first glance, all I could see were some leaves. I looked harder and amidst all the green, there was a hint of blackit looked like a moustache. Look again, said the army colonel, in a tone that betrayed suppressed excitement. This time, I finally saw.

It was a head, the disembodied face of a slain soldier nailed onto a tree. The boys got it as a gift for the brigade, said the colonel, softly, but proudly. [Himal]​
So that is an instance where this kind of inhuman act did happen. So why did she not say so to Gen. Malik. She is not anybody, she was there, and this is an issue that is being discussed on a show that she is anchoring. How long can it be before she gets called out for the gross irresponsibility of her reticence on this very crucial matter. Was she lying in 2001, or, is she concealing the truth now?
But the buck, doesnt stop here. Then, a BJP Politician and spokesman for his party, Ravi Shankar Prasad is asked by Barkha Dutt about the NDAs record on India-Pakistan relations. She mentions Vajpayee as the architect of the India Pakistan Peace Process , Kargil, Parliament Attack, Hijacking of IC 814, Historic Ceasefire of 2003 etc. Ravi Shankar Prasad begins, not by immediately addressing Barkha Dutts question, but by contradicting Admiral Ramdas. Around 26:39 minutes into the program, Ravi Shankar Prasad says Mr. Ramdas has been a distinguished Naval chief, but for him to make a comment that even Indian forces have been beheading, I am happy Gen. Malik contradicted him very conclusively, Admiral Ramdas you need to understand that Pakistani people will lap up your comment, and seek to condemn Indian army in no uncertain terms, I am seeing that happening, for heavens sake dont make these sweeping comments. Dont call on Heaven, Mr. Prasad (Admiral Ramdas says, attempting to interject) but Barkha Dutt doesnt let him speak. Once again, she does not contradict, question or challenge Ravi Shankar Prasad. Her evasion in this matter, at this point, when it has popped up on her program for the third time now, is a truly sweeping statement. Then, Barkha Dutt moves on to Congress spokesman, Avishek Manu Singhvi, and other matters, and other panelists, Ashutosh Varshney and Leela Ponnappa, the question that Admiral Ramdas raised is forgotten, but it lingers, silent, and sullen, like the ghost of a beheaded soldier in the studio. At the end of the programme, Shahvar Ali Khan, a musician from Lahore, Pakistan says All the peace loving people of Pakistan are with the grief of the people of India. He hopes that the present situation will not affect cultural and social ties. Ravi Shankar Prasad says that he loves Pakistani Ghazal songs, but says artists, sportsmen and people who want peace are fringe players. Then, Barkha Dutt asks Admiral Ramdas for a comment. He says, If for so many years things have gone wrong, the fault lies not with sportsmen and artists, why punish them for what why have not done? Who makes the constituency of peace a fringe, and who makes the dogs of war, the people Shahvar Ali Khan calls the hate-mongers, on either side of the LOC, occupy the centre-stage, again and again? If an important television journalist like Barkha Dutt talks about the fact that both armies have committed acts of savagery, which, I repeat, she says she knows, because she has said that she has seen this with her own eyes, it will weaken the dogs of war. This admission, coming from a public figure like her, will make it more difficult for the war-party on either side of the LOC to point their fingers only at people across the border. Nothing can strengthen the constituency of peace more at this crucial juncture, than a little honest and public introspection, on both sides. Let us hope that will occur. Barkha Dutt can set the ball rolling, if she chooses to. The buck, starts with her.

SOURCE
http://kafila.org/2013/01/16/dear-barkha-dutt-the-buck-stops-where/
 
Majority of the commissioned officers of pakistan, are baigharat, coward, lazy, corrupt and unable to fight. But the Jawans are true warriores.

What a marvelous and keen observation by an nihilistic brain. It also settles once for all that a jawan should never be promoted to save him from decay. Perhaps that is one of the reasons that a visit to toilet is advised before sitting before the computer to exhale your filth out.