Advertisement

Can the civil-military hybrid be sustained and expanded to the rest of Pakistan ?? :

Is the civil-military hybrid sustainable?

Farrukh Saleem
Wednesday, March 18, 2015
From Print Edition


543f9fecb1142.jpg


ISLAMABAD: A new experimental governance structure has been imposed on Karachi, the city with ten percent of Pakistan’s population. The GHQ-crafted Apex Committee is a civil-military hybrid. On the face of it, the Apex Committee is captained by Chief Minister Syed Qaim Ali Shah with V Corps Commander Lieutenant-General Naveed Mukhtar as a member of the committee.

The ground reality is that under the new governance structure there has been an incremental shifting of power from Bilawal House to V Corps Headquarters. The Provincial Assembly of Sindh has long been irrelevant and now the Provincial Cabinet is also out of the business of provincial decision making. The ground reality may be different but on the face of it the Apex Committee is a monitoring committee.

Over the past two decades, Karachi has become an intersection where politics, organized crime syndicates and militancy meet to hold 10 percent of Pakistan’s population and 25 percent of Pakistan’s GDP hostage. Unfortunately, Karachi’s political elite now has a vested interest in the maintenance of status quo.

The Apex Committee was meant to send out a strong message to Karachi’s political elite to voluntarily separate politics from crime. Clearly, the message did not go through. Can the Apex Committee, the offspring of two entities of different species, be tasked to separate politics from crime? Can the Apex Committee, the civil-military hybrid, be tasked to break Karachi’s status quo? The Qaim Ali Shah-captained Apex Committee failed to separate politics from crime. Proof: On March 11, MQM’s headquarters had to be raided.

The V Corps-led raid sent out two distinct messages. One – the civil-military hybrid is not sustainable. Two - the V Corps has taken over Karachi.

Pakistan Army has broken Karachi’s status quo. In addition to that, there are military courts, convicted terrorists are being hanged, targeted operations are taking place and the Chief of Army Staff has undertaken trips to London and Kabul.

To be certain, the GHQ has two constituencies to satisfy-the uniformed rank-and-file and the non-uniformed public opinion. So far, the GHQ has managed to satisfy both the rank-and-file and the public opinion.To be sure, expectations are high-and going through the roof.We have all seen magicians pulling rabbits out of hats. Who can pull habits out of rats?

Source
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
I think for the time being the Civil-Military hybrid is the best option, we already have civil military governance along with military courts, now all we need is a new political system backed by the Pakistani Military and we shall be good to go :biggthumpup:...but first lets clean up all the political filth from yesteryears....
 
Yes its can be...but first need to clean up all mess then
do the rest..Accountability..Honest and patriot judiciary.
neutral election process...zero tolerance against corruption.
these all things need to formed by the Army..then we can easily
go for any type of system..
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Agreed....the current judiciary should be disbanded and an honest and accountable judicial system must be setup...

Yes its can be...but first need to clean up all mess then
do the rest..Accountability..Honest and patriot judiciary.
neutral election process...zero tolerance against corruption.
these all things need to formed by the Army..then we can easily
go for any type of system..
 
Clean the filth that sitting in bilawal house, half of the problems of Karachi would be solved.
 
Political elite must be cursing itself for their outright rejection of the idea of National Security Council. That was much better a way to rule the country smoothly, with necessary backing from Armed Forces but they did not like a supervisory institution overhead. Their lust for abusive power, arrogant corruption and dictatorial mindset has finally led them to the loop around their neck, they won't be able to unwind. Problem with political class is that in current equation of claims they don't have masses behind them. Pakistani nation stands behind the Army.
 
It is exactly because of this evil nexus that we are staring at a bottomless pit...
It is because of this exact reason that we have to endure the ruthless reigns of NS and Zerdari with army working as their guarantors (NRO 1 & 2).

It is high time to put army back in the barracks and political thugs in gallows and prision cells!!!

Why army did not play it's role in cleaning up the mess when it had ABSOLUTE power for decades???
 
Last edited: