Advertisement

2019 Cricket World Cup: Indian fans fire up over Martin Guptill's 'surgical strike' - was amazing run out legal?

Indian fans have erupted after a TV graphic appeared to show New Zealand broke the fielding rules when Martin Guptill produced his match sealing runout in the Cricket World Cup semifinal.

D_IIHVTUcAE5yME.jpg


Guptill's brilliant throw - labelled a "surgical strike" by one fan - to strand MS Dhoni is being hailed around the world.

The Indian veteran was close to masterminding another one of his great rear-guard acts when Guptill struck with a direct throw to the stumps at Old Trafford.

Television coverage included a graphic which showed New Zealand having six fielders outside the circle, as Kane Williamson adjusted his field by sending Guptill back.


But analysis of the moment appears to show that Williamson compensated for this change by bringing Colin de Grandhomme up from third man, making New Zealand's fielding strategy legal.

Dhoni would still have been out on a retrospective ruling because a run out is the one form of dismissal allowed on a no-ball.

But some fans believe, probably mistakenly, that Guptill should not have been in a position to make his wonder throw.

"This is a matter of serious concern," one Tweet groaned. "If Guptill was inside the circle, there would have been a possibility that he wouldn't have been run out."

Loading X post…
Open original post on X

Loading X post…
Open original post on X

Loading X post…
Open original post on X

Loading X post…
Open original post on X

In the end, Guptill's superb throw left India needing 25 off nine balls, and without the experienced Dhoni at the crease, they had no hope, falling 18 runs short.

 
Advertisement
Doesn't matter if it was a no ball, because no ball per run out tao phir bhi hota hai?
 
Kuch bhi ho lekin is age me Dhoni khawab me bhi 9 balls pe 24 runs nahi score krskta tha. Mar mar k usne second last over me pace ko use krte howe apna pehla six maara. Jadeja ko bhi pata tha k is baabay me ab dum nahi hai isliye khud aggressive khel raha tha aur Dhoni singles leke ose strike deraha tha. Isne India k saath Misbah waala kaam kiya aur 72 balls pe 50 runs bnaaye jb k Misbah ne WC 2011 k semi final me 76 balls pe 56 runs bnaaye jiski wajah se ose aaj tk Mr. Tuk Tuk kaha jaata hai halaankay tb uski innings me 5 fours aur 1 six shamil tha aur Dhoni ki innings me just 1 four aur 1 six tha.
 
Kuch bhi ho lekin is age me Dhoni khawab me bhi 9 balls pe 24 runs nahi score krskta tha. Mar mar k usne second last over me pace ko use krte howe apna pehla six maara. Jadeja ko bhi pata tha k is baabay me ab dum nahi hai isliye khud aggressive khel raha tha aur Dhoni singles leke ose strike deraha tha. Isne India k saath Misbah waala kaam kiya aur 72 balls pe 50 runs bnaaye jb k Misbah ne WC 2011 k semi final me 76 balls pe 56 runs bnaaye jiski wajah se ose aaj tk Mr. Tuk Tuk kaha jaata hai halaankay tb uski innings me 5 fours aur 1 six shamil tha aur Dhoni ki innings me just 1 four aur 1 six tha.
yes that is true, it was already too late.
 
Advertisement
لعنت تمام ہندوستان پر

ہندوستان مردہ باد
​
 
انڈیا سارے ائی سی سی رولز ،امپیائر۔ میچ فکسنگ ۔ پیسہ لگانے کے باوجود بھی ہار گیا۔ کتنا بڑا مذاق بن گیا انڈین کرکٹ
 
Dhoni nay England k match mein win k liye try nahi kia.. aaj kar raha tha to apni auqat ka andaza hogaya ..
 
ان کا خیال تھا کہ اپنی مرضی سے کوئی بھی میچ ہار سکتے ہیں (جیسے انگلینڈ والا)، تو اپنی مرضی سے کوئی بھی میچ جیت بھی لیں گے
لیکن ایسا ہوتا نہیں نا
عقل کے ***** ہیں یہ
​