Advertisement

کیا ڈنڈے کے زور پر پارٹیاں ختم ہو جاتی ہیں؟ صنم جاوید کا جیل سے ایک اور خط

Advertisement
5 times in last 35 years they tried to dismantle Nawaz Shareef's political base, but he is still strong and relevant. So, the answer is NO.

But, PTI was never a political party. It was always a fan club that has now transformed into a dumb, stupid, idiot, blind and ignorant cult.
 
Advertisement
DSCfNEqWsAAXUy8
 
5 times in last 35 years they tried to dismantle Nawaz Shareef's political base, but he is still strong and relevant. So, the answer is NO.

But, PTI was never a political party. It was always a fan club that has now transformed into a dumb, stupid, idiot, blind and ignorant cult.
Why don't asim munir and his generals arrange a meeting with the cult and sort things out, pick some hardliners and they go meet with them, see where the differences are, and propose a road map. GHQ is the powerful here, it should initiate such a dialogue, maybe peace can be achieved.
 
5 times in last 35 years they tried to dismantle Nawaz Shareef's political base, but he is still strong and relevant. So, the answer is NO.

But, PTI was never a political party. It was always a fan club that has now transformed into a dumb, stupid, idiot, blind and ignorant cult.
and what is/was the magic potion NS has for that? would you like to explain?
 
Advertisement
Jail se chithi vithi lixna acha ha, udhar ja k zra haraam k charbi utarti xulta ha aur xaraab dimaag thora kaam kerna shrouh ho jata ha. Aaag lagana yaad tau aata ho ga!
 
Jail se chithi vithi lixna acha ha, udhar ja k zra haraam k charbi utarti xulta ha aur xaraab dimaag thora kaam kerna shrouh ho jata ha. Aaag lagana yaad tau aata ho ga!
لعنت ہو اللہ کی جھوٹے اور ظالموں پر

آگ لگانے کا کوئی ثبوت ہوتا تو اب تک سزا ہو چکی ہوتی اور پوری دنیا وہ ثبوت دیکھ چکی ہوتی
 
Advertisement
Why don't asim munir and his generals arrange a meeting with the cult and sort things out, pick some hardliners and they go meet with them, see where the differences are, and propose a road map. GHQ is the powerful here, it should initiate such a dialogue, maybe peace can be achieved.

After what Imran did with Gen Bajwa, you would be naive to think that any Army Chief would ever want to sit down with him. Remember, Army Chief's power comes from Formation Commanders and the Institute today has no appetite for Imran any more. The Institute knows that Imran was brought in power by Institute as a replacement of Nawaz & Zardari. Imran never understood this and kept hammering Gen Bajwa.

Imran, made another blunder when he went above and beyound normal politics and tried to stop appointment of Asim Munir, institite did not like it. Finally, he attacked GHQ in hope for a mutiny that ofcourse did not happen.

It is the institute that dnt want to talk with Imran anymore. It was institute that brought Musharaf in power (when he was in air), it was institute that threw Nawaz out (Bajwa's father in law still remains a very good friend of Nawaz) finally it was the institute that forced Jahangir Karamat out and not Nawaz Sharif.

Pakistan dnt have a Presidential system and establishment is a reality. Even the most powerful Obama could not fight his country's estab and deliver his campaign promises in 8 yrs. Trump was thrown out after 4 yrs. Obama and Trump did not come in power riding on an Umpire's stick!
 
Last edited:
After what Imran did with Gen Bajwa, you would be naive to think that any Army Chief would ever want to sit down with him. Remember, Army Chief's power comes from Formation Commanders and the Institute today has no appetite for Imran any more. The Institute knows that Imran was brought in power by Institute as a replacement of Nawaz & Zardari. Imran never understood this and kept hammering Gen Bajwa.

Imran, made another blunder when he went above and beyound normal politics and tried to stop appointment of Asim Munir, institite did not like it. Finally, he attacked GHQ in hope for a mutiny that ofcourse did not happen.

It is the institute that dnt want to talk with Imran anymore. It was institute that brought Musharaf in power (when he was in air), it was institute that threw Nawaz out (Bajwa's father in law still remains a very good friend of Nawaz) finally it was the institute that forced Jahangir Karamat out and not Nawaz Sharif.

Pakistan dnt have a Presidential system and establishment is a reality. Even the most powerful Obama could not fight his country's estab and deliver his campaign promises in 8 yrs. Trump was thrown out after 4 yrs. Obama and Trump did not come in power riding on an Umpire's stick!
Suppose all of this is true, does the institute acknowledge that where do people of Pakistan stand now, and if their calculation is that regardless of the public support they can engineer out imran khan without any long term consequences then i would offer my disagreement.

Ground reality is not == institute wishes. Definitely, Power is in the hands of institute but the public has no appetite for institute's selection board. Please at least agree on this premises that public is on board Imran khan's ship. Also do observe that this is not US, here state power is full naked and creates hate, in US the power of state is hidden and exercised through different means. Public here due to information and media has accepted a viewpoint and is willing to resist the state power to engineer out the idea.

This confrontation between people and power of state/Institute will result in damage for both, if the institute realizes atleast that then i think that space can be made for PTI and Imran khan, and also institute can be given its own space, for that there should be direct meeting between hardliners of PTI and institute leadership for the sake of people and state. That is my argument without any biasness against the institute because after all it is a reality and we live in same country.
 
Also note that no one has definite answers about the dark street we are in, this is a buildup of 75 years of corruption in our society such that now two of the biggest pillars of our country are on each other's throat with vengeance, one is army , the other is people who are supporters of PTI who were previously the biggest supporters of army.

If judiciary and police/bureaucracy was honest and did according to rule of law rather then brutal and naked aggression, we would not have reached this stage. Now either institute will finish IK and PTI OR institute will surrender and accept/give in to the demands of public.
 
Advertisement
Let some PTI hardliners sit in a formation commanders meeting so that in front of everyone a respectful dialogue could be done and we open heartily see if there is a way out. If there is no way and disagreement continues then so be it, both parties do what they think is best, but i think an effort should be done for peaceful resolution.
 
and what is/was the magic potion NS has for that? would you like to explain?

After late 80s, it is no secret estab wants to dump Nawaz but it has no alternative available. Imran was prepared but he failed to deliver.

If, estab has option today, Nawaz will be dumped again. Shehbaz is different case as estb has no issues with him but he has no own political feet
 
After late 80s, it is no secret estab wants to dump Nawaz but it has no alternative available. Imran was prepared but he failed to deliver.
No one can deliver neither the generals, nor politicians , Let the public decide who they think delivers best in elections. And let state machinery and justice system be neutral and follow the rule of law and go by the book.
 
No one can deliver neither the generals, nor politicians , Let the public decide who they think delivers best in elections. And let state machinery and justice system be neutral and follow the rule of law and go by the book.
Today its no secret that Public wanted Nawaz in 2018 but Imran offered his bich services.....today its the reverse
 
Today its no secret that Public wanted Nawaz in 2018 but Imran offered his bich services.....today its the reverse
I agree but with a lot of benefit of doubt given to nawaz because in my own constituency, my cousins were polling agents for N league and they told me that everyone of the vote was fully counted and all was done free and fair, that seat was the most contested seat in whole Pakistan in terms of number of voters and votes given to a single party, but PTI won and 2 times were recounting was done, but anyways i agree about pre poll rigging etc .

SO NOW it is REVERSE, you also agree, but this time consequences are different, at least PTI is clear about this, and i also think Institute is clear about this.