Who is better (Javed chuhdari or Hamid Meer)

Khurram.k

Senator (1k+ posts)
javed choudhary's opening speech is usually the best but they both lack convincing or intimidating personality even with their sarcasm.
 

Nawazish

Minister (2k+ posts)
Hamid Mir is a paltu ***** of Nawaz Shareef. No respect left what so ever for him since what he did to Sheikh Rasheed. I don't like Sheikh Rasheed either but what he did was an obvious paid job. Shameless stuff really.

Javed Chaudhery seems like a legit guy.
 

msmirza007

MPA (400+ posts)
i have the same thoghts for hamid mir as your nawazish niice analysis.
Hamid Mir is a paltu ***** of Nawaz Shareef. No respect left what so ever for him since what he did to Sheikh Rasheed. I don't like Sheikh Rasheed either but what he did was an obvious paid job. Shameless stuff really.

Javed Chaudhery seems like a legit guy.
 

scary

Politcal Worker (100+ posts)
Hamid Mir is a paltu ***** of Nawaz Shareef. No respect left what so ever for him since what he did to Sheikh Rasheed. I don't like Sheikh Rasheed either but what he did was an obvious paid job. Shameless stuff really.

Javed Chaudhery seems like a legit guy.

summed it up nicely!
 

funkymonk

Minister (2k+ posts)
I think both are fine .. Javed Chaudhry might be better ...

Hamid Mir is not Nawaz Sharif agent whatsoever .. he is against Sheikh Rasheed no doubt ..
but who isnt ?
 

zubair.maalick

MPA (400+ posts)
I think Hamid Mir is the best Journalist of Pakistan. Even better than Talat. Talat is best in reporting only.
Javaid Ch. is Best in article writing.
 

BKKhan

Councller (250+ posts)
They both have merits and demerits.... Hamid Mir is more bold and always talks with facts and figures.....what he did with sh rasheed... was RIGHT... as people like sh rasheed were saying that they will elect Musharraf 1000 times in uniform.... and his hands are red with the blood of innocents of Lal masjid.... he should never be given chance to come to pakistani politics again..... while.... Javed chodhry is a good story maker... he knows how to relate a fairy tale to the current political situation in pakistan... but i think he needs more time to be mature in his profession
 

omerkashmiri

Siasat.pk - Blogger
Javed chaudhery is a best columnist we have in pakistan and hamid mir is an excellent investigative reporter but both are mediocre talk show hosts