Molviees Ki Pataai

biomat

Minister (2k+ posts)
Salam
Thanks for sharing, but this should not go into sect war or sect hate debate. We can disagree with MUTAH as AHLE SUNNAT donot accept it, also bad apples do exist in every group.. But main point is that it should not be taken as whole picture.. WALLAH ALAM..
Enemies of Islam will make fun & laugh at these types of news.. Also brother can u post BBC URDU original news not from any other hate spreading site. I hope u will understand. Jaza-k-ALLAH
 

Knowledge Seeker

Senator (1k+ posts)
Salam
Thanks for sharing, but this should not go into sect war or sect hate debate. We can disagree with MUTAH as AHLE SUNNAT donot accept it, also bad apples do exist in every group.. But main point is that it should not be taken as whole picture.. WALLAH ALAM..
Enemies of Islam will make fun & laugh at these types of news.. Also brother can u post BBC URDU original news not from any other hate spreading site. I hope u will understand. Jaza-k-ALLAH

Agreed with brother Biomat. Following is the original news link:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/urdu/india/2010/06/100630_lukhnow_beaten.shtml
 

molson4u

Senator (1k+ posts)
Agreed with brother Biomat. Following is the original news link:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/urdu/india/2010/06/100630_lukhnow_beaten.shtml

brother in Case of Taliq you need halala not Muta so the story writter at BBC deesnt know what he is writing and has no clue of Islamic Law. This case is Taliq and return to the spouse, Halala is required not Muta...sound like a fake story for people who have hatred for other people of different sect. May Allah Guide us all
 
Last edited:

Knowledge Seeker

Senator (1k+ posts)
molson4u said:
brother in Case of Taliq you need halala not Muta so the story writter at BBC deesnt know what he is writing and has no clue of Islamic Law. This case is Taliq and return to the spouse, Halala is required not Muta...sound like a fake story for people who have hatred for other people of different sect. May Allah Guide us all

The statement about Mutah is not generated by BBC Correspondent but Actually, The lady mentioned it to BBC reporter.Please Check out the following link:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/urdu/multimedia/2010/06/100630_lucknow_arshibibi_twoway.shtml
 
Last edited:

karachiwala

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
brother in Case of Taliq you need halala not Muta so the story writter at BBC deesnt know what he is writing and has no clue of Islamic Law. This case is Taliq and return to the spouse, Halala is required not Muta...sound like a fake story for people who have hatred for other people of different sect. May Allah Guide us all

Depends what your sect is here. Halala is for sunnis (which by the way The Holy Prophet Sallalahu Alahi Wassalam abhorred). This might be for Shia sect.