Sharmila Farooqui is a patriotic lady no doubt about it, i admire that but calling someone else non-patriotic is gone too far specially when it comes to Atiqa Odho who have done so much for the country . As for the failed state theory is concerned, our nation is a failed state-someone agrees with it or not. I have done my university education in finance and economics so i know the backdrops of the failed state. Just last week IMF gave the warning to pakistan that it will not meet its growth what it promised, also criticised our monetary and macro econimic policy so our finance minister came back empty hand from there . The nation dont have law and order,econnomic collapse,anarchy,corruption,incompetence,no accountability,favourtism and nepotism,no electricity,water,gas, terror attacks all over the country,in three provinces most of the structures have been damaged because of flood and terror. I like to ask that beautiful single lady sharmila farooqui that i think pakistan is a failed state. what do you think about me ? Could you please tell then what are the symptoms of a failed state,do your assessment and tell,thanks.