desan
President (40k+ posts)
Judges intentions can be contrued not only by how they grilled Naeem Bukhari, but also by the pin drop silence against NS counsel...
Will keep adding their remarks made in the court.
Please include your insights and further info about these judges.
Can get further info from:
http://www.supremecourt.gov.pk/web/page.asp?id=205
Justice Asif Saeed Khan Khosa (Appears to be Neutral)
Justice Asif Saeed Khan Khosa on Monday observed that honesty in parliament, apex court, and with the nation is more important than the issue of the Sharif familys ownership of the Mayfair properties in London.
Justice Khosa observed that PM Nawaz had failed to give a reference about Qatari investments in his speech.
If there were some omissions in PM Nawazs speech, should it be termed as a lie or half truth? he observed
Accusations are not against the entire government, but the entire government is being defensive, remarked Justice Khosa.
Allegations against Maryam Nawaz are inseparable from her father, remarked Justice Khosa.
Justice Ejaz Afzal Khan (Appears to be tilting towards NS)
Justice Ejaz Afzal asked Bukhari to confine the case to the London flats.
"What is the point of bringing in Ishaq Dar? Is he among the respondents?" he asked. "Explain why NAB should have filed an appeal in the Hudaibya case."
We will not set an example by disqualifying PM on the basis of speech - Justice Ejaz Afzal remarks in Panama case.
Zar-e-kafalat hone ka ilzam lagane walo ko bhi saboot dena hoge:--Justice Ijaz Afzal remarks in Panama case
Justice Gulzar Ahmed (Appears to be Neutral)
Justice Gulzar said that if transactions are done through the bank then there is no objection.
Justice Gulzar Ahmed asked if Dar denied his confession, to which Hamid assented, saying that Dar had denied his statement completely.
Justice Ijaz Ul Ahsan (Not enough info)
He was appointed as the Chief Justice of Lahore High Court on 06.11.2015. His lordship was elevated as Judge, Supreme Court of Pakistan on 28.06.2016.
Makhdoom Ali Khan said that the prime minister could not be disqualified on the basis of speeches and dual nationality and stressed the countrys premier never lied in his speeches and has immunity from prosecution.
You are saying that the prime minister never lied and you are also seeking immunity, said Justice Ijaz-ul-Hasan.
Justice Sh. Azmat Saeed (Appears to be tilting towards NS)
But Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed, pointing towards PTIs Advocate Naeem Bokhari, emphasised the need for caution in deciding a disqualification case under Articles 62 and 63 of the Constitution on the basis of a statement made by the holder of a public office, which later turned out to be false. If we start disqualifying people under this pretext, no one will be spared, not even your clients, the judge observed.
But Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed dissented, observing that the real issues that needed attention were the questions: whether the trust deed was an admitted, valid and effective document; whether the two children were obliged to disclose the deed under UK laws; and under what capacity Maryam was declared the trustee or the owner of these companies.
Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed of the Supreme Court Wednesday said the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) was playing the role of a facilitator for the corrupt.
Will keep adding their remarks made in the court.
Please include your insights and further info about these judges.
Can get further info from:
http://www.supremecourt.gov.pk/web/page.asp?id=205

Justice Asif Saeed Khan Khosa (Appears to be Neutral)
Justice Asif Saeed Khan Khosa on Monday observed that honesty in parliament, apex court, and with the nation is more important than the issue of the Sharif familys ownership of the Mayfair properties in London.
Justice Khosa observed that PM Nawaz had failed to give a reference about Qatari investments in his speech.
If there were some omissions in PM Nawazs speech, should it be termed as a lie or half truth? he observed
Accusations are not against the entire government, but the entire government is being defensive, remarked Justice Khosa.
Allegations against Maryam Nawaz are inseparable from her father, remarked Justice Khosa.
Justice Ejaz Afzal Khan (Appears to be tilting towards NS)
Justice Ejaz Afzal asked Bukhari to confine the case to the London flats.
"What is the point of bringing in Ishaq Dar? Is he among the respondents?" he asked. "Explain why NAB should have filed an appeal in the Hudaibya case."
We will not set an example by disqualifying PM on the basis of speech - Justice Ejaz Afzal remarks in Panama case.
Zar-e-kafalat hone ka ilzam lagane walo ko bhi saboot dena hoge:--Justice Ijaz Afzal remarks in Panama case
Justice Gulzar Ahmed (Appears to be Neutral)
Justice Gulzar said that if transactions are done through the bank then there is no objection.
Justice Gulzar Ahmed asked if Dar denied his confession, to which Hamid assented, saying that Dar had denied his statement completely.

Justice Ijaz Ul Ahsan (Not enough info)
He was appointed as the Chief Justice of Lahore High Court on 06.11.2015. His lordship was elevated as Judge, Supreme Court of Pakistan on 28.06.2016.
Makhdoom Ali Khan said that the prime minister could not be disqualified on the basis of speeches and dual nationality and stressed the countrys premier never lied in his speeches and has immunity from prosecution.
You are saying that the prime minister never lied and you are also seeking immunity, said Justice Ijaz-ul-Hasan.

Justice Sh. Azmat Saeed (Appears to be tilting towards NS)
But Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed, pointing towards PTIs Advocate Naeem Bokhari, emphasised the need for caution in deciding a disqualification case under Articles 62 and 63 of the Constitution on the basis of a statement made by the holder of a public office, which later turned out to be false. If we start disqualifying people under this pretext, no one will be spared, not even your clients, the judge observed.
But Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed dissented, observing that the real issues that needed attention were the questions: whether the trust deed was an admitted, valid and effective document; whether the two children were obliged to disclose the deed under UK laws; and under what capacity Maryam was declared the trustee or the owner of these companies.
Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed of the Supreme Court Wednesday said the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) was playing the role of a facilitator for the corrupt.
Last edited: