If no water for Sindh, no port for Punjab : Adviser to CM Sindh

[karachi]

KARACHI: Sindh can stop supplying gas to Punjab, block highways leading towards the province and cut its connection from seaports if Punjab tries to block its water, said Dr Kaisar Bengali, Adviser to Chief Minister on planning and development

Addressing a seminar titled Democracy, Provincial Autonomy, Challenges and Future Prospects on Sunday, he said the decision of the Indus River System Authority (Irsa) acting chairman to open the Chashma-Jhelum link canal was a violation of the Irsa act.

This irrational attitude of the Punjab bureaucracy is not new, Bengali claimed, adding that they have been controlling more than their share of the nation’s resources

“Punjab and Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa would have no other option but to ink [transit] agreements with India if we cut off their link of Port Qasim and stopped supplying gas,” he said.

Punjab has forgotten that the province receives rainfall as all the clouds head towards Punjab from Sindh, the adviser said with a smile

The participants of the seminar resolved that the Chashma-Jhelum link canal should be closed and demanded for the federal government to honour its commitments and agreements regarding the distribution of the Indus waters

They also claimed that the Irsa acting chairman should be punished for violating regulations

He went on to say that Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) is now confined to Punjab and 50 per cent of the parliamentarians who have fake degrees belong to the party.

Meanwhile, Sindh Assembly Speaker Nisar Ahmed Khuhro said that the Sindh government has achieved the National Finance Commission (NFC) award after a 19-year struggle. The people opposing the government’s policies had signed the NFC award allotting only 37 per cent of the share to the provinces, he said, adding, “Credit should be given to the present government for giving 56 per cent share of the finances to the provinces.” (The Express Tribune)


http://tribune.com.pk/story/27234/%e2%80%98if-no-water-for-sindh-no-port-for-punjab%e2%80%99/

 

[molson4u]

Dr Kaisar Bengali, Adviser to Chief Minister...Sindh can stop supplying gas to Punjab, block highways leading towards the province and cut its connection from seaports...is a shameful remark. It will hurt no one except PAKISTAN and its Economy. He must be drunk when he said that. Without punjab karachi is nothing and without Karachi Punjab is nothing. Punjab produces everything that goes to the port, cotton, rice, leather, sports good, medical equipment, wheat, water fruits, vegitables and the list is long. All export reply on punjab and karachi thrives because of export. The day Punjab decided to use Guwadar as its future port to permote Blochistan, Sindh and Karachi will be history like Majo Daro...If punjab just cuts of the water...everyone will die so its time to stop threats and stop drinking before the press conference.

 

[karachi]

Dr Kaisar Bengali, Adviser to Chief Minister...Sindh can stop supplying gas to Punjab, block highways leading towards the province and cut its connection from seaports...is a shameful remark. It will hurt no one except PAKISTAN and its Economy. He must be drunk when he said that. Without punjab karachi is nothing and without Karachi Punjab is nothing. Punjab produces everything that goes to the port, cotton, rice, leather, sports good, medical equipment, wheat, water fruits, vegitables and the list is long. All export reply on punjab and karachi thrives because of export. The day Punjab decided to use Guwadar as its future port to permote Blochistan, Sindh and Karachi will be history like Majo Daro...If punjab just cuts of the water...everyone will die so its time to stop threats and stop drinking before the press conference.

Illusions :13:

 

[hkniazi]

Very sad to see the comments from both sides. and we blame outside powers for all these mishaps. shame on us.

 

[hawk eyed]

@karachi................sharam ani chahye aisi baat krte huay v r one nation MQM central gov k sath hai n they support the gov to phr aisi bakwas krne ka maqsad?tamiz se baat krte huay b apni demands puri krwai ja skti hen......jb saanp hmari aasteen mein hai to dosron pr kia ilzam lgaen............AFSOS HOTA HAI TUM JESE LOGON KO PAKISTANI DEKH K

 

[hassam]

Very sad to see the comments from both sides. and we blame outside powers for all these mishaps. shame on us.

The kind of hate monger muslims that we have in our ranks we do not need an enemy to destroy us. For many of us the ethnic pride is more important than rationality and resolution of issues.

 

[harisuae]

Dr Kaisar Bengali, Adviser to Chief Minister...Sindh can stop supplying gas to Punjab, block highways leading towards the province and cut its connection from seaports...is a shameful remark. It will hurt no one except PAKISTAN and its Economy. He must be drunk when he said that. Without punjab karachi is nothing and without Karachi Punjab is nothing. Punjab produces everything that goes to the port, cotton, rice, leather, sports good, medical equipment, wheat, water fruits, vegitables and the list is long. All export reply on punjab and karachi thrives because of export. The day Punjab decided to use Guwadar as its future port to permote Blochistan, Sindh and Karachi will be history like Majo Daro...If punjab just cuts of the water...everyone will die so its time to stop threats and stop drinking before the press conference.

Very well said. We are one nation, people who are saying these thins are not Pakistani and they are not sincere with country. These matters should be solved with dialogue. What have they done for the people who have selected them to solve their problems.

 

[Ammad Hafeez]

@karachi................sharam ani chahye aisi baat krte huay v r one nation MQM central gov k sath hai n they support the gov to phr aisi bakwas krne ka maqsad?tamiz se baat krte huay b apni demands puri krwai ja skti hen......jb saanp hmari aasteen mein hai to dosron pr kia ilzam lgaen............AFSOS HOTA HAI TUM JESE LOGON KO PAKISTANI DEKH K

Ohh.. MQM ne kia boldiya mere Bhai?? Can you plz indicate..
Afsoos toh mjhe horaha hai k is Thread mei MQM ka koi Subject hi nai hai aur ap toh andhey takleed ho k apne Masters ki tarah yehan Bias Statement pass kr rahe ho. !! Kch bolne se pehle Socha toh kro !! Yaar.. had hai

 

[karachi]

]@karachi................sharam ani chahye aisi baat krte huay[/U] v r one nation MQM central gov k sath hai n they support the gov to phr aisi bakwas krne ka maqsad?tamiz se baat krte huay b apni demands puri krwai ja skti hen......jb saanp hmari aasteen mein hai to dosron pr kia ilzam lgaen............AFSOS HOTA HAI TUM JESE LOGON KO PAKISTANI DEKH K

This r not my views on news
I have just sharred this news from Express tribune read the last line

(sorry for my rude comments)

 

[Ajnabi27]

Brother Karachi ... I think its better we do not promote these kind of statements by stupid Dr Kaisar Bengali, Adviser to a dumb Chief Minister. Its all about equality, one nation and one country. Every provence is like important and a must have part of a body. We should promote unity and brotherhood among Pakistanies so that we can progress as a Proud Nation. Sab se Pehle Pakistan.:)

 

[karachi]

@QADIANITRUTH

Well said
QADIANI-TRUTH yor plans won't work

 

[hawk eyed]

This r not my views on news
I have just sharred this news from Express tribune read the last line

(sorry for my rude comments)

mind ur language mr y did u put such a news here?what really was ur intention?

 

[R.A.W.K]

Dr Kaisar Bengali, Adviser to Chief Minister...Sindh can stop supplying gas to Punjab, block highways leading towards the province and cut its connection from seaports...is a shameful remark. It will hurt no one except PAKISTAN and its Economy. He must be drunk when he said that. Without punjab karachi is nothing and without Karachi Punjab is nothing. Punjab produces everything that goes to the port, cotton, rice, leather, sports good, medical equipment, wheat, water fruits, vegitables and the list is long. All export reply on punjab and karachi thrives because of export. The day Punjab decided to use Guwadar as its future port to permote Blochistan, Sindh and Karachi will be history like Majo Daro...If punjab just cuts of the water...everyone will die so its time to stop threats and stop drinking before the press conference.

Though i hate both pml n and ppp and have severe disagreements with MQM (on violence and consistent playing ''mazloom'')... but Karachi is a port city like Dubai. so in a way Karachi or gawadar dont really need anything or body to survive.. how ever this stuff by dr bengali is sad and should be condemned and i dont know what the guy posting thins wants to convey, I really think that Sindh's share of water should be given to it but blackmailing sorts nothing.. ''*****y aap par bhonktay hain to aap wapis nahi bhonktay'' we need provincial harmony(with autonomy) and they should not behave like independent states but parts of THE SAME COUNTRY.

Just a thought

 

[ramses2x1]

LOL .. what an idiot advisor and whoever agrees with him .. i cant believe sindh CM got such wonderful jokers as his advisor ..

God bless CM sindh and the province and pakistan .

 

[sarbakaf]

idher hum . udher tum same statement but different words

 

[Waseem]

Koe hum se bhi badnaseeb qoum hay, jis ke leader chotay chotay issues per idher hum , udhar tum ya mulk tornay ke naray lagana shru ker datay hain ?? Keya Pakistan ke charo subay allag allag reh saktay hay. Akhar kub hum logoun ko aqal aye ge?

 

[shaheedchoudry]

IRSA decision has been reversed and CJ canal is going to be closed.
Port Kaisar Bangali kay baap ki hai?

 

[Ammad Hafeez]

Koe hum se bhi badnaseeb qoum hay, jis ke leader chotay chotay issues per idher hum , udhar tum ya mulk tornay ke naray lagana shru ker datay hain ?? Keya Pakistan ke charo subay allag allag reh saktay hay. Akhar kub hum logoun ko aqal aye ge?

Haha Aur woh naara bhi Drugs k liye lagaya tha Drug Mafia ne :D

 

[Ammad Hafeez]

IRSA decision has been reversed and CJ canal is going to be closed.
Port Kaisar Bangali kay baap ki hai?

Hahaha Bengali Khisak giya hai :D

 

[A.Ali.T]

Shame on all of you guys who think one province is more important than another. We all depend on each other. Without each other we are nothing. If we want the world to respect us then first we must respect each other.

The way we start fighting with each other over petty things is really shameful. Anyone who thinks that they can survive without other provinces is living in fools world. They way you guys are fighting it makes me think that only thing Pakistan is self sufficient in is fools like you.