Ho Kya Raha Hai ? - 20th July 2015 - Muslim League Aur PTI Karachi Say Gaib Ku ?

kkkkk

Minister (2k+ posts)
Excellent analysis!

No, unfortunaely again a biased and self serving analysis, if we look at it from Karachi point of view. Historically, the analysis is wrong as the ethnic politics was not startedby MQM but by the successive governments of Pakistan in which theUrdu Speaking were systematically removed from the government and economy. Theother groups found it still difficult and under Ayub Khan the first languageriots against Urdu Speaking were created. We were children, we still rememberhow our houses were attacked by mobs and burnt and we had to live in houses ofour family and friends. We knew verywell as to who did it and why it was done. Later, the capital was shifted fromKarachi, and the same day Bangladesh was practically created. Then the hatredof Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto resulted in rural-urban quota, removal of Urdu Speakingfrom almost all the government jobs, and this time of provincial government,Urdu-Sindhi language riots once again on the lines in Ayub Khan time andopening of university in interior Sindh to give fake degrees to Sindhis thatthey could be given jobs in place of Urdu speaking. This is how the persecutionof Urdu Speaking has been happening. The recent history of PPI creation, MQMHaqiqi formation, cleaning up operations, etc are known and no need to dwellupon them.
So the ethnicpolitics was done by the governments of other powerful ethnic groups, formationof MQM was a reaction only. Urdu Speaking had been innocent till then, they hadcreated Pakistan in the name of Islam and had accordingly been voting forJamaat Islami in Karachi but to their surprise they realized that even JIleadership being from Punjab and KPK had been exploiting and serving the ethnicinterest of their groups. Thus the MQM was a natural consequence. MQM was alsogiven no choice but to create an armed group given the JIs Jamiaat Talaba’sheavy handed tactics against Urdu Speaking. When students from Karachiuniversity had gone to take admission in interior Sindh, they were beaten bystudent gangs and their degrees were burnt and told to leave.
And now ourlearned anchors are suggesting more dominance of Karachi by advising to PTI andPMLN to take over full control. The real solution has always been a separate provincefor Urdu Speaking and its administration by its own people, but that has neverbeen accepted as all other ethnic mafias want their piece of booty in Karachi withtheir muscle power, in addition to what they already have in their own areasand cities. Pathans certainly want to own KPK and Karachi together, Punjabissimilarly want to own Punjab and Karachi, Balochis want Balochistan and Karachiand Sindhis forgot their history of 80% ownership of Sindh by Hindus with whomUrdu Speaking exchanged their assets and as such became owners of that 80% andnot Sindhis become the owner because their name is Sindhi. Legally, it is UrduSpeaking who become owner of Sindh.
So, thesolution in fact has always lied in creating a peaceful, prosperous Pakistan,with equal rights for every citizen where ethnicity like religion should be aprivate business of an individual only and not becomes a mean to share theeconomic pie of the country. Till the time ethnicity and sect are used foreconomic gains, systematically, our country will never improve. Sincerity hadcreated Pakistan and only sincerity and honesty will keep it and strengthen it.
 

jaanmark

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
India only counted every 10 years in big cities, just 40% of the people not 100% that is why they are still out of toilets in the big cities like bombui . please do not lies on the shows