History shows CPEC could be Pakistans golden ticket to prosperity

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
1329916-nawazjinping-1487325461-334-640x480.jpg


LAHORE:

Despite the several concerns that surround China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), the fact remains that the initiative will bring massive amount of money into the country in the form of loans, grants and investments. And if this new wealth is managed strategically and honestly, theres a high chance Pakistan can turn its economy around. Other countries have done it before and there is no reason why Pakistan cannot do it; the only requirements are good intention, focused policies and a sense of responsibility.The economic miracle of the following countries after they were devastated by war can be a source of inspiration and motivation for the movers and shakers of Pakistan.

Taiwan

At the end of World War II, Taiwan had a weak economy with severe food and housing shortages. The Chinese Civil War also brought chaos and 1.8 million refugees to the island further straining a region already exhausted because of the war against communism.

Financial aid and soft credit worth $4 billion in addition to food and military aid by the US between 1945 and 1965 provided Taiwan with the necessary capital to restart its economy. Annual flow of $50-55 million until 1955 focused on agriculture sector to curb food shortages. Later, medium-size private corporations were encouraged to support manufacturing which eventually enabled Taiwan to develop its massive textile industry and boost export. A major chunk of the funds were allocated to public authorities to overhaul the infrastructure Shihmen Dam was built and irrigation system was modernised on a huge scale.

As a result, Taiwan today is the 18th-largest economy in the world with GDP worth $1.6 trillion. With only 1.7% of its population living below the poverty line, inflation in the country stands at 0.3%. It is ranked highly in terms of freedom of the press, health care, public education, economic freedom, and human development. Since 1954, the percentage of population working in agriculture has reduced from 56% to 1.8%; services sector employs 63% of the people followed by industrial sector (29%) with unemployment rate as low as 3.7%.

South Korea
The Korean War killed and injured around 1.5 million people and destroyed properties worth $3.1 billion in South Korea. At the end of the conflict, the country had 43% of its industry and 42% of housing demolished and remained one of the poorest countries in the world for over a decade.

In 1960, its gross domestic product per capita was $79 lower than that of some sub-Saharan countries. With almost no natural resources and always suffering from overpopulation in its small territory, South Korean heavily depended on agriculture but productions were low due to small scale farming, governments restriction on land ownership and lack of modern equipment.

Aid from United States, under International Cooperation Administration and United Nations Korean Reconstruction Agency, poured $6.2 billion between 1955 and 1969 into the country to boost the economy. Railway system and power plants were established and enhanced as part of the aid program; millions more were provided to uplift the healthcare and education sectors taking literacy rate to 90% from 20%.

Called the Miracle on the Han River, the rapid economic growth following the Korean War transformed South Korea from a developing country to a developed country with fourth largest economy in Asia and the 11th largest in the world having the GDP of almost $2 trillion.

Japan
Japan was in ruins after the World War II; a significant proportion of the Japanese population was wiped out during World War II, including an estimated 210,000 people in the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki alone. At least 40% of national industrial plants and infrastructure were destroyed and manufacturing dropped to less than 10%. Inflation fluctuated between 60% and 130% per year till 1949 and there were severe food shortages.

Between 1946 and 1952, Washington invested $2.2 billion or $18 billion in real 21st-century dollars adjusted for inflation in Japans reconstruction effort. The Economic Rehabilitation in Occupied Areas programme was introduced to bring industrial raw materials and machinery worth $323 million dollar for the economic revival of Japan. The Government Aid and Relief in Occupied Areas programme provide Japan with $92.63 million in 1946, $287.33 million in 1947 and $351.40 million in 1948 just for food. The US also led free trade negotiations to provide production and export advantage to the growing Japanese economy. Further, with US providing military support to Japan as part of the efforts to restrict Japanese military growth, the island nation also saved on warfare costs.

As a result, Japan became the second largest economy in the world after the United States in 1968, experiencing average growth of up to 9% per year between 1955 and 1973. Today, it is worlds third largest economy with GDP of $4.92 trillion. From being aid-dependent after WWII to fourth largest donor in the world, Japan has truly made a remarkable economic transition.

Germany
The WWII had left around seven million Germans dead which were roughly 8% of the population. Agricultural production stooped to 35% and around 25% of Germanys pre-Anschluss territory was ceded to Poland and the Soviet Union. Many factories and much of the capital stock were destroyed and the little that was left was not enough to restart the economy.

The Marshall Plan, American aid to reconstruct Western Europe, dedicated 11% of the $13 billion $120 billion in current dollar value monetary assistance to Germany alone. A vast amount was invested in the rebuilding of industry, with the coal industry alone receiving 40% of these funds. Business procedures were modernised and best practices were adopted as part of the economic uplift. A new central bank was created and was given much more authority over monetary policy while a Federal Cartel Office was also established to prevent the return of German monopolies and cartels.

Today, Germany is the largest economy in Europe and fourth-largest in the world. Its service sector contributes around 70% of the total GDP, industry 29.1%, and agriculture 0.9%. In 2014, it was the third largest exporter in the world with 1.28 trillion in goods and services exported. And of the worlds 2000 largest publicly listed companies measured by revenue, 53 are headquartered in Germany such as Volkswagen, BMW and Siemens.

Hassan Sajjad is a lawyer based in Lahore.
Published in The Express Tribune, February 25[SUP]th[/SUP], 2017.


 
Last edited by a moderator:

Two Stooges

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
پٹواری جی، سی پیک مشرف کا منصوبہ ھے ۔ ۔ ۔ ۔ پرائی ٹٹی پر پھد مارنا چھوڑ دیں
 

Iconoclast

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Since you're dumb, short sighted and an idiot like your leader, Noora, here are a few links for you read. That should make any semi intelligent person understand how China actually robs countries of their resources after dishing out billions of dollars to them in loan or other forms of "help", CPEC is one form of it.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1036105/How-Chinas-taking-Africa-West-VERY-worried.html

https://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/26/...ons-with-loans-and-strings-attached.html?_r=0

Only a brainless patwari would believe in your propaganda post.
 
Last edited:

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Since you're dumb, short sighted and an idiot like your leader, Noora, here are a few links for you read. That should make any semi intelligent person to understand how China actually robs countries of their resources after dishing out billions of dollars to them in loan or other forms of "help", CPEC is one form of it.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1036105/How-Chinas-taking-Africa-West-VERY-worried.html

https://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/26/...ons-with-loans-and-strings-attached.html?_r=0

Only a brainless patwari would believe in your propaganda post.

You keep reading American NY Times and british daily mail because they suit your mentality. The mentality of those who have problem with Emerging Pakistan and China
Kisi hindi akhbar ki bhi niksl kur post kur do. Wo bhe tumhen kafi taskeen de ga.
 

Shahid Abassi

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Despite the several concerns that surround China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), the fact remains that the initiative will bring massive amount of money into the country in the form of loans, grants and investments. And if this new wealth is managed strategically and honestly, there’s a high chance Pakistan can turn its economy around. Other countries have done it before and there is no reason why Pakistan cannot do it; the only requirements are good intention, focused policies and a sense of responsibility.

And if there is lack of good intentions, focused policies, sense of responsibility and honesty, the same CPEC will destroy what ever industry we have today.
 

mrk123

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Idiotic logic! Roads and infrastructure to let trucks drive around on highways will never bring prosperity.

Stupid comparison between the situation of Germany, Japan and Korea to that of today's Pakistan.

There has never been a case where a huge transportation infrastructure project to facilitate commerce for another country has resulted in economic windfall for the country that just provides conduit for that commerce.

This is to say that Albania would get rich by just letting trucks carrying goods back and forth between Turkey and other EU countries.
Nothing could be more stupid!

Plus this "chooran" has been sold before to Pakistanis that economic prosperity on the shoulders of other countries are just around the corner.
RCD, SAARC, Saindak, etc. have all been sold as an economic revolution to Pakistanis to eventually fizzle out after investment of resources and man hours.

Nations that don't invest in their own people and infrastructure and look to ride on the coat tails of other countries' success will not prosper ever.

Whats needed is for the government to invest on the children of Pakistan and get them ready for them to take us out of this mess. This is what China, Malyasia and Indonesia did and this is what India is working on.

And, here we are sold this stupid idea by our dimwit and visionless leaders that we would get rich by letting chinese trucks loaded with chinese goods to ply between Khunjerab and Gawadar.
 
Last edited:

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
پٹواری جی، سی پیک مشرف کا منصوبہ ھے ۔ ۔ ۔ ۔ پرائی ٹٹی پر پھد مارنا چھوڑ دیں

Kyoon taafun aap ki naak men ruch bus gya he. Ab mehsoos nheen hota
Mujhey nheen pata tha musharuf ka kya kuch saaf kurtey rehey ho. Aaj kul tum dono hi UK Men ho. Achi baat he Nokri lagi hoi he tumhari.
Act like human and Stop messing with me. I have capability to go to any level you want.
 
Last edited:

PappuChikna

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
it may be, but I have no doubt pakistan's permanent elite class will keep the lion's share of it and only pass down 5%-6% to awam, or they will simply screw up the whole project.
 

Iconoclast

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
You keep reading American NY Times and british daily mail because they suit your mentality. The mentality of those who have problem with Emerging Pakistan and China
Kisi hindi akhbar ki bhi niksl kur post kur do. Wo bhe tumhen kafi taskeen de ga.

And it only suits you when they award your fake Minister Ishaq Dar with fake awards huh? At least make sense when you attempt to post a reply. BTW if you read my post, I am one of those who least trusts journalists in general and western journalists in particular. If you have a brain even as small as a pea, you'd look in to it for yourself and do your own research. Then come back and tell me if I am right or otherwise.

Next time post something intelligent or don't bother quoting me cause you will only make a fool of yourself like you just did. Oh wait you wouldn't know since you're a patwari on mission, more of a payroll.
 

Two Stooges

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Kyoon taafun aap ki naak men ruch bus gya he. Ab mehsoos nheen hota
Mujhey nheen pata tha musharuf ka kya kuch saaf kurtey rehey ho. Aaj kul tum dono hi UK Men ho. Achi baat he Nokri lagi hoi he tumhari.
Act like human and Stop messing with me. I have capability to go to any level you want.
1329916-nawazjinping-1487325461-334-640x480.jpg

15439894_1811787609098074_5413303688850632582_n.jpg
 

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
So dose it mean that it is taken fro granted that there will be no management, strategy and honesty ?

Despite the several concerns that surround China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), the fact remains that the initiative will bring massive amount of money into the country in the form of loans, grants and investments. And if this new wealth is managed strategically and honestly, there’s a high chance Pakistan can turn its economy around. Other countries have done it before and there is no reason why Pakistan cannot do it; the only requirements are good intention, focused policies and a sense of responsibility.

And if there is lack of good intentions, focused policies, sense of responsibility and honesty, the same CPEC will destroy what ever industry we have today.
 

Dream Seller

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Yeah it can be if noora is jailed, only then it's possible...when I say noora I don't only mean two chawal brothers...agli gall te samaj ee gai o
 

Munawarkhan

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Kyoon taafun aap ki naak men ruch bus gya he. Ab mehsoos nheen hota
Mujhey nheen pata tha musharuf ka kya kuch saaf kurtey rehey ho. Aaj kul tum dono hi UK Men ho. Achi baat he Nokri lagi hoi he tumhari.
Act like human and Stop messing with me. I have capability to go to any level you want.

Good article Raja, ignore the critics and try to keep your hunt for a fact finding mission.

The Point you are missing in all the examples you mentioned is the key turnaround for all of these countries. Their industry. All of these countries are now one of the biggest exporters. All of them invested in human development and industry. We on the other hand have gone in reverse. In 60's we were better off than some of them. Our industry was more mature we have gone on a reverse spiral since.

If you replace the word Pakistan with China in your Title it will make more sense. Pakistan has given the Gawadar port to China on a 40 year lease (Dubai port is only 35 yr old and see where it took them), China doesn't have to pay Pakistan for its cargo movement so basically unless every country starts using Gawadar, don't expect a mega income from this belt. How will Pakistan make money from CPEC is still beyond my understanding.

Again this is just my 2 cents; and I'm not an economy expert.
 

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Good article Raja, ignore the critics and try to keep your hunt for a fact finding mission.

The Point you are missing in all the examples you mentioned is the key turnaround for all of these countries. Their industry. All of these countries are now one of the biggest exporters. All of them invested in human development and industry. We on the other hand have gone in reverse. In 60's we were better off than some of them. Our industry was more mature we have gone on a reverse spiral since.

If you replace the word Pakistan with China in your Title it will make more sense. Pakistan has given the Gawadar port to China on a 40 year lease (Dubai port is only 35 yr old and see where it took them), China doesn't have to pay Pakistan for its cargo movement so basically unless every country starts using Gawadar, don't expect a mega income from this belt. How will Pakistan make money from CPEC is still beyond my understanding.

Again this is just my 2 cents; and I'm not an economy expert.

Thanks Munawar Khan.
 

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Have posted the real data for the power distribution companies performance in controlling circular debt. Please see if you want the truth.

https://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthre...48#post4383548

Good article Raja, ignore the critics and try to keep your hunt for a fact finding mission.

The Point you are missing in all the examples you mentioned is the key turnaround for all of these countries. Their industry. All of these countries are now one of the biggest exporters. All of them invested in human development and industry. We on the other hand have gone in reverse. In 60's we were better off than some of them. Our industry was more mature we have gone on a reverse spiral since.

If you replace the word Pakistan with China in your Title it will make more sense. Pakistan has given the Gawadar port to China on a 40 year lease (Dubai port is only 35 yr old and see where it took them), China doesn't have to pay Pakistan for its cargo movement so basically unless every country starts using Gawadar, don't expect a mega income from this belt. How will Pakistan make money from CPEC is still beyond my understanding.

Again this is just my 2 cents; and I'm not an economy expert.
 

Back
Top