Barring heavy transport: Bab-e-Peshawar flyover construction quality comes under question

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
569d014f2691e.jpg


PESHAWAR: Barring heavy transport from the multi-level Bab-e-Peshawar flyover has raised concerns about the construction quality and reliability of the structure that had developed cracks recently.
The 2.2 kilometer long flyover was constructed by the National Logistics Cell at the Phase-III Chowk in Hayatabad in a record five months.The project was completed at a cost of Rs1.72 billion to regulate traffic to Hayatabad, Karkhano Market, and the adjacent Khyber Agency.

Viewed as one of the flagship projects of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI)-led Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government, the flyover was inaugurated on January 18, 2016.The importance of the project could be gauged from the fact that the PTI Chairman Imran Khan and PTI’s junior coalition partner Jamaat-e-Islami (JI) chief Senator Sirajul Haq had attended the inaugural ceremony and claimed credit for executing the project

The PTI had time and again boasted that the project was completed in a record time.The flyover, however, later developed cracks. These were repaired after the media highlighted the issue. Now the Peshawar Development Authority (PDA) has deployed private security guards and traffic wardens at the flyover and displayed a public notice for the motorists and public transport vehicles.

The notice reads: “Heavy traffic not allowed to pass through the flyover. We are sorry for the inconvenience.”A traffic warden Anwarul Haq, who was on duty at the flyover to keep out heavy vehicles, said he had been deployed some three days ago. He was instructed not to allow heavy transport to use the flyover for entering or leaving Hayatabad.The traffic cop said he was told that heavy vehicles plying the flyover had caused damage to the structure and were now barred from using it.Almas, a PDA security guard deployed along with the traffic wardens, said he came on duty on January 31 and wasn’t sure for how long he would remain there.

Director General PDA Israrul Haq said that heavy vehicles were barred from Bab-e-Peshawar flyover on the directives of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Chief Secretary Muhammad Azam Khan.He said the flyover was not meant for use by heavy vehicles.
“It was designed to sustain up to 70 tonnes of weight but unfortunately heavy vehicles plying the bridge carry over 100 tonnes of weight. That is why we barred heavy vehicles from using the flyover,” he added.

The PDA chief pointed out that heavy vehicles carrying goods from the Karachi seaport to Afghanistan through Torkham border carried over 100 tonnes of weight while using the flyover.He said heavy vehicles carrying construction material for the Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) project also used the flyover.

“These heavy machines which carry more than standard 70 tonnes of weight are not now allowed to ply the flyover as this could cause damage to the structure,” he elaborated.The PDA director general denied the reports that the flyover had been closed to heavy transport because it developed cracks. He insisted there was no threat to the structure.“These reports are mere assumptions and are not true. The flyover is safe for traffic and there is no risk of its collapse,” he maintained.

Source
 
Last edited by a moderator:

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Along with other claims PTI always claimed the lesser per square foot cost of the construction compared to Punjab Govt projects.
I was always fascinated with this claim but my bad habit of looking deeper into the things always nagged me on this claim. I was looking for some Civil engineers involved in the construction of this project. I wanted to get the copy Engineering specs to know what was less in this project which made it cheaper.

Turned out that it was actually the quality of the project that was lesser.
Now they are saying it was not designed for the heaver traffic.
Phooooof
 
Last edited:

araein

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
@Muqadas, ab aaap se discussion ka maaaza nahin aaata.... This is the reason, i am ignoring your threads... Anyway i hope you will get the salary on time... And keep

sharing JANG group news.....:biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup:
 

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
PCFV01P10_15.jpg


@Muqadas, ab aaap se discussion ka maaaza nahin aaata.... This is the reason, i am ignoring your threads... Anyway i hope you will get the salary on time... And keep

sharing JANG group news.....:biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup:
 

araein

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)

[hilar][hilar][hilar][hilar][hilar][hilar] Chor ki darhi mein tinkaaa..... [hilar][hilar][hilar][hilar][hilar][hilar]

@Muqadas, I am not getting any salary from PTI... But u and JANG are getting salaries and benefits from PML-N.... So who is more trust worthed... [hilar][hilar][hilar][hilar][hilar]
 

RajaRawal111

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
یہ لو یار آپ کی تسلی تشفی کے لئے --- دوسرے سورس

https://twitter.com/azzkhann/status/952896341243514880

https://www.pakistantoday.com.pk/20...hawar-flyover-putting-citizens-lives-at-risk/


@Muqadas, ab aaap se discussion ka maaaza nahin aaata.... This is the reason, i am ignoring your threads... Anyway i hope you will get the salary on time... And keep

sharing JANG group news.....:biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup::biggthumpup:
 

araein

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)

@Muqadas, Ab huwi naaa baaaat :P

Let me share some news with you, then we can discuss further on.. I can share dozen of news like this...

https://en.dailypakistan.com.pk/pakistan/rs330m-bridge-collapses-in-jhelum/

https://www.dawn.com/news/1260318


One thing, if this is true: Then that's not a big deal... There are some carcks that will be fixed... No problem... Until there are cracks heavy load should not be allowed.

Second thing: I am 100% sure ke is bridge mein, Imran Khan ne paisaaa nahin khaya ho gaaaa...

In case of Punjab Projects: I am 100% sure that sharif families are making money through those projectss....

Now i hope you will give the answer on the incidents in punjab..
 

miafridi

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Along with other claims PTI always claimed the lesser per square foot cost of the construction compared to Punjab Govt projects.
I was always fascinated with this claim but my bad habit of looking deeper into the things always nagged me on this claim. I was looking for some Civil engineers involved in the construction of this project. I wanted to get the copy Engineering specs to know what was less in this project which made it cheaper.

Turned out that it was actually the quality of the project that was lesser.
Now they are saying it was not designed for the heaver traffic.
Phooooof

Since you are fond of looking deep into matters, can you please tell us with proof how much load Azaadi chowk(built more than 3 times expensive) can sustain?
 

arafay

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Not all flyovers are meant for heavy vehicles specially pathans are famous for overloading.
 

mhafeez

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
سڑک کا حال دیکھیں ، دوسرے جو ٹریفک اس پل پر سے گزرنی تھی وہ اب کہاں سے گزرتی ہوگی ، کیا اس سے ٹریفک جام نہیں ہو جاتا ہوگا

DVcKDKKXcAAygB3.jpg


DVcKAn4WAAAS47w.jpg
 

miafridi

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Will judge when the board of "no heave traffic" will appear on it.

Ok but I thought it was important to know if you had a better standard(than 70 Tons) for 3 times expensive Flyover at home, before you criticize the 70 tons standard. But yes of course time will reveal itself, and I am not a short memory so will keep this in mind.

As for your statement that you now believe that it was 3 times cheaper only because of substandard material(this is your belief, and not a reality, because of course a standard for flyovers are always set by engineers and this standard can't be called as using substandard material etc), then perhaps you can tell me what might have been the actual cost of Lahore, Multan, and Isb Metro buses, since they all had developed cracks time and again(and they were not even getting heavy load traffic)? As per your logic using good material is the reason a project is 3 times expensive. And all the Metro buses developing cracks were surely built using substandard materials(as per your logic)..
 

Champion 01

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
a ss hole, your patwarri guardians have constructed thousands of projects which have been poor quality . Go and count the cracks there.
You also hVe one in your rear- go explore it:angry_smile:

I think THIS one is done by Rana mirassi with the help of Mariam Qatri...
 

mhafeez

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Since you are fond of looking deep into matters, can you please tell us with proof how much load Azaadi chowk(built more than 3 times expensive) can sustain?

ہمیں اپنے پراجیکٹ کیلئے سیمنٹ منگوانا تھا جو اس فلائی اوور سے گزرنا تھا تب ٹیپا نے بتایا تھا کہ ستر ٹن تک کا ٹرالر گزار سکتےہیں اس سے زائد کیلئے آلٹرنیٹ روٹ استعمال کرنا ہو گا ، یہ فل ٹرالر پر جس پر دو بیس فٹے کنٹینر لدے ہوتے ہیں کا زیادہ سے زیادہ ویٹ لمٹ ہے جسکی پاکستان میں اجازت ہے ، عام ٹرک میں زیادہ سے زیادہ آٹھ ٹن سامان آتا ہے