Amjad Sabri Response On Bhar Do Jholi Controversy

[Hamza Naeem]

 

[kwan225]

Re: Amjad Sabri Repones On Bhar Do Jholi Controversy

All he wants to go to India to get his piece of cake ... (thumbsdown)

 

[sameer]

qawali to commom heritage hai, complaint banti nahi hai
ko bhi adopt kar sakta hai, like they did

man kunto maula by fana fillah

<font size="5"><span style="font-family:tahoma;">

http://fanna.bandcamp.com/track/man-kunto-maula

 

[taban]

Re: Amjad Sabri Repones On Bhar Do Jholi Controversy

All he wants to go to India to get his piece of cake ... (thumbsdown)

تو اس میں غلط کیا هے اس کے بزرگوں کی محنت اور اسکا ورثه هے انڈین چوروں کو اس کو معاوضه دینا چاہیے

 

[Kashi]

If he has copy right for this qawali? if yes, he must go ahead otherwise its normal. Its obvious, his intention is only to have a share from the record income of this movie.

 

[barca]

If he has copy right for this qawali? if yes, he must go ahead otherwise its normal. Its obvious, his intention is only to have a share from the record income of this movie.

اصل میں یہ قوالی سلمان خان کی فلم میں اگر یہ متھن چکروتی کی فلم میں ہوتی تو اس نے بولنا بھی نہیں تھا
پیسوں کے لیے تو یہ صابری جیل میں صولت مرزا کے لیے جا کر قوالیاں سناتا تھا

 

[syedalam1991]

He wants money for the song being used, but what hypocrisy is this, I just saw him and that Lodhi guy sing Indian song on their eid show for like 10 minutes, did he take permission for singing that song? Copy right works both ways! You can't keep singing their songs for free for a commercial purpose and then say you pay me for using my song! Its a two way transaction.

 

[PUNJABIMUNDANO1]

All he wants to go to India to get his piece of cake ... (thumbsdown)

تو اس میں غلط کیا هے اس کے بزرگوں کی محنت اور اسکا ورثه هے انڈین چوروں کو اس کو معاوضه دینا چاہیے

If he has copy right for this qawali? if yes, he must go ahead otherwise its normal. Its obvious, his intention is only to have a share from the record income of this movie.

اصل میں یہ قوالی سلمان خان کی فلم میں اگر یہ متھن چکروتی کی فلم میں ہوتی تو اس نے بولنا بھی نہیں تھا
پیسوں کے لیے تو یہ صابری جیل میں صولت مرزا کے لیے جا کر قوالیاں سناتا تھا

The Qawali was written by Purnam Allahabadi and It has been sung by a number of People but it became most popular when it was sung by Sabri Brothers!

Amjid Sabri cannot clam any right ......... He is just after some Media coverage!

 

[Pak Falcon]

qawali to commom heritage hai, complaint banti nahi hai
ko bhi adopt kar sakta hai, like they did

man kunto maula by fana fillah

<font size="5"><span style="font-family:tahoma;">

http://fanna.bandcamp.com/track/man-kunto-maula

Adopt koi b kar sakta hai lekin ijazat k beghair nahi!

 

[Pak Falcon]

The Qawali was written by Purnam Allahabadi and It has been sung by a number of People but it became most popular when it was sung by Sabri Brothers!

Amjid Sabri cannot clam any right ......... He is just after some Media coverage!

Doesnt matter who wrote the qawali, kiya movie k copyrights movie k writer k pass hote hain? Jo invest karta hai us he k paas copyright hota hai.
http://www.dawn.com/news/1193603

 

[PUNJABIMUNDANO1]

Doesnt matter who wrote the qawali, kiya movie k copyrights movie k writer k pass hote hain? Jo invest karta hai us he k paas copyright hota hai.
http://www.dawn.com/news/1193603

The producer or director of a movie always buy the story form writer

In this case the Qawali written by Punram Allahabadi became a public property and sung by many and became most popular when it was sung by Sabri Brothers!

You cannot claim right over Public Property or Cultural heritage

Even now the descendants of Purnam Allahbadi cannot claim any right because Purnam himself never claimed any right over it and it just became a Sufi heritage!

 

[Pak Falcon]

The producer or director of a movie always buy the story form writer

In this case the Qawali written by Punram Allahabadi became a public property and sung by many and became most popular when it was sung by Sabri Brothers!

You cannot claim right over Public Property or Cultural heritage

Even now the descendants of Purnam Allahbadi cannot claim any right because Purnam himself never claimed any right over it and it just became a Sufi heritage!

o bhai aapko kahan se pata rights kiske pass hain aur kiske pass nhi jo link share ki hai usay khol k dekho to pata chalayga rights kiske pass hain. Aur eik qawali sirf eik script nhi hota jo koi b parh lay usko compose kiya jata hai aur ganay keliye kayi mahinu ki practice karni parti hai. Making a qawali is harder than making a song!

 

[barca]

o bhai aapko kahan se pata rights kiske pass hain aur kiske pass nhi jo link share ki hai usay khol k dekho to pata chalayga rights kiske pass hain. Aur eik qawali sirf eik script nhi hota jo koi b parh lay usko compose kiya jata hai aur ganay keliye kayi mahinu ki practice karni parti hai. Making a qawali is harder than making a song!

صابری پچھلے دو سال میں روزانہ مورننگ شو میں آتا ہے اور انڈین گانے گاتا ہے
پہلے اس کو خود شرم کرنی چاہیے کیوں انڈین گانے گاتا ہے

 

[Pak Falcon]

صابری پچھلے دو سال میں روزانہ مورننگ شو میں آتا ہے اور انڈین گانے گاتا ہے
پہلے اس کو خود شرم کرنی چاہیے کیوں انڈین گانے گاتا ہے

Gata hai na bechta nahi ganay aur bechne mein farq hai