Re: انشاء الله تعالیٰ پاکستان دنیا میں سر بلن&
I have read the booklet; my comments are as follows after reading it.
First Hadiths from Masnad Ahmed 369/2 is describing Prophet SAW predicting A Lashkar going from Arabia to Sind/Hind. We know such army was sent lead by Muhammad Bin Qasim.
The rest are not words of Prophet SAW, if anything they are wishes of Abu Harira Ra.
Imam Nisai repeated the same Hadith with slight differences in wordings, but the wishes of Abu Harira Ra are the same. This proves it is once again for the same historical events of Muhammad Bin Qasim landing in Sind/Hind.
You should pay attention to the explanations given under the Hadiths. It quoted Ibne Kathir, who stated only Imam Ahmed has quoted this Hadiths. In any case, like I said, it is relating to the historical army lead by M bin Q.
For the second Hadiths narrated by Abu Suban Ra, the notes in the book states; Ibn Hajir wrote, he saw a writing of Imam Dhabi, which stated I dont know who this is (narrator)? His narrations are false. Ibn Habban has narrated it in Zikir Saqat.
In the second quotation, once again the note says, Imam Tabrani wrote, one narrator of this Hadith Al-Zabidi Ra is a lone narrator.
The third quotation once again states an army of Arabs, this already happened. Once again a dissenting note is added at point 3. Imam Manawi quoted Dhabis Al-Daifa a saying of Imam Darul Qatni, Al-Jirahs narrations are nothing or in other words worthless.
Further down the writer of the book has stated there are additions in this Hadiths. The Hadith states the rulers of Sind would be brought in chain.
Once again it is the same Hadiths with different added wordings and even if Sahi it relates to Muhammad Bin Qasims led Arabic army attacking Sind/Hind.
The next Hadiths narrated by Hadarth Kaab Ra, is a different form of the same Hadiths with differences in narrations. Nevertheless, it is once again pointing to an Arab army attacking Hind.
Due to weakness in chain of commands according to the writer, this hadith is Hadith a Munqatih meaning discontinued or unreliable and hence rejected.
Brothers in a nutshell, it is a singular Hadiths doing rounds in different wordings and narrations.
And on each step the writer of this book himself has introduced a qualification, hinting that by many learned people this Hadith is not reliable.
If anything so many variances in its narrations of the same event, in itself an indication that it is not a very reliable hadiths.
And Allah SWT knows the best.
