آپ اور ہم ایک ہیں

[atensari]

ایک ہندو کی نظر میں ہندو مسلمان ایک ہیں،
فیصلہ مسلمان خود کریں

 

[Mujahid]

پنڈت جی آپ نے کمال کر دیا بہت بڑہیا لکھا ہے آپ نے مگر ایک گلہ ہے کہ یہ شرک کی عادت ہمیں بٹوارے میں آپ سے ملی ہے

 

[aqeel813]

baat to sach ha magar baat ha ruswai ki.

 

[atensari]

پنڈت جی آپ نے کمال کر دیا بہت بڑہیا لکھا ہے آپ نے مگر ایک گلہ ہے کہ یہ شرک کی عادت ہمیں بٹوارے میں آپ سے ملی ہے

ہمیں اب یہ عادت چھوڑ دینی چاہیے

 

[Knowledge Seeker]

ایک ہندو کی نظر میں ہندو مسلمان ایک ہیں،
فیصلہ مسلمان خود کریں

We don't need to rely on the perception of any non muslim to decide what is right or wrong. Qadiani also claim that they are same like us. The tone of the poem is giving impression that instead of a hindu Pandit, it might be the work of a person using the title of Pandit who has been trapped with the ideology of those groups who are spreading hatred day and night against people of Tassawwaf by labeling muslims as Mushrik.

I hope that you must have done research before posting on this forum about the credibility of this poem linked to hindu poet.

Could you please share with us the original source of this poem??

 

[zulnorain]

Yar yah Sach hai. Shadi per JAHEZ ka eawaj hamaray han bi hai. Mehni ka function Basant Festival or ab toh dewali bi shoroh ho gayi hai. Hamary loog star plus or zee tv dekh dekh ker bat kertay waqt kuch words hindi language ka bi bol detay hain. Shab e barat or ramzan mei hum nah tarah tarah ki batain ijad ker li hain jis ka benefit Mullah ko hai. Hum loog hindus ki tarah Idols ki pooja nahi kertay magar hum chaltay phirtay idols ko poojtay hain. Rishwat yahan aam hai. yahan kisi ghar me jab beeti pedah hoti hai toh itni khushi nahi hoti. Pakistan kis angle se Islamic republic lagta hai mujhay aaj tak samaj nahi aayi. saudi arabia or iran hum se kahin behtar hain.

 

[Raaz]

ہمیں اب یہ عادت چھوڑ دینی چاہیے

This is not written by any hindu, may be written by a JI molve, the friends of Hindu.

Because they are saying , on the right side in way that hindu could not write like that......

Anyway, what about, Kaba Tullah? ( Khana Kabah)

I am , personally , not in the favor of Baralvi, lots of wrong habits they have, but no good habit in Deo banis.....

The real path is in between these two sects. As I feel in Quran Kareem.

The difference betwen hindu's activity and muslim activity that we respect all those who belong to Allah Talah. but hindu do not.

 

[nasirsadiq]

A Peom

 

[Zaidi Qasim]

Thought provoking Poem from a mushrik !!!!! Can anyone answer ???

 

[Muhammad Ikhlaq Siddiqui]

There are many customs and rituals which have become prevelant in the Muslims of subcontinent because of spending so many years with them... but the matter the fact is that ... Islam is not what muslims do... Actually there are so many bad things which are prevelant in muslims and some of them are shirkia as well but it doesnt mean that hinduism and islam are same ... yes to some extent it is true that muslims and hindus are doing same things... but it isnt the logic or reasoning to compare islam with hinduism.... and another point is that if hindus are doing all these things, they are on the right path but on the other hand if muslims are doing all these things, it is obivious and clear that they are on the wrong path !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Zaidi Qasim]

There are many customs and rituals which have become prevelant in the Muslims of subcontinent because of spending so many years with them... but the matter the fact is that ... Islam is not what muslims do... Actually there are so many bad things which are prevelant in muslims and some of them are shirkia as well but it doesnt mean that hinduism and islam are same ... yes to some extent it is true that muslims and hindus are doing same things... but it isnt the logic or reasoning to compare islam with hinduism.... and another point is that if hindus are doing all these things, they are on the right path but on the other hand if muslims are doing all these things, it is obivious and clear that they are on the wrong path !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Indeed , it is the actions of Muslims which are questioned in this poem.I do not think the actual religion is being compared.It raises valid questions of the actions of the muslims who have adopted these rituals and practising it.

 

[Knowledge Seeker]

@nasirsadiq

Please check the following similar thread initiated 4 days ago and address my post if you can.


http://www.siasat.pk/forum/showthread.php?40796-%26%231570;%26%231662;-%26%231575;%26%231608;%26%231585;-%26%231729;%26%231605;-%26%231575;%26%231740;%26%231705;-%26%231729;%26%231740;%26%231722;&p=208583#post208583

 

[QaiserMirza]

کفر اور اسلام کیسا - آپ اور ہم ایک ہیں

کفر اور اسلام کیسا - آپ اور ہم ایک ہیں ​

ہمارے بھائی جو "ہندو مسلم بھائی بھائی" کا نعرہ لگاتے ہیں -
جن کی زبان بھارت کی تعریف کرتے نہیں تھکتی -
جو اپنے آپ کو روشن خیال کہتے ہیں -​

 

[Pragmatic]

Re: کفر اور اسلام کیسا - آپ اور ہم ایک ہیں

Excellent -----------He has beautifully summed up the religious evolution .....it does't matter which religion it it...each take the same course of evolution.......

 

[Knowledge Seeker]

Re: کفر اور اسلام کیسا - آپ اور ہم ایک ہیں

Could you provide the original source of this Poetry???