Abdul Allah
Minister (2k+ posts)
Abdul Allah,
Please see this video when you get a chance. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjXYoX7l1zM
Question was about Life of Isa AS
and you bring Khatam-e-Nabowat.
So my Question stands there
1) if it is a wrong Concept in Islam that Isa AS is alive and will come back then why not any Mujadid did not remove this concept by his writings. Read Tafsir Jalayay a tafsir by a Muajdid on this Issue that is clearly against your believes.
2) even Khatam-e-Nabowat concept of Mujadid is against yours believes.
2.1 Mujadid Alif in his Muktobaat said "Nabowat apnyt MANSAB k lihaz sy khatam hy" kamalat k hisab sy nahi. But you believe MGA as APPOINTED NABI means you believe him NABI as per MANSAB.that is why Lahore sect of your jamat is against your mainstream stance as they think that he was not Nabi as per Mansab.
2.1 Ibn Arabi. divide Nobowat termonoligy in two parts(that is exactly the same thing as Mujadad Alif sani said) in one category he count all prophets 124000 in it and named it Nabowat Tashri. In second Category he count all other people like mother of Mosa as , Mariam AS who were not prophet but recieve Ilham from Allah in it and named it Nabowat taama. and he said that second category can not be said NABI but they are to termed as WALI.
So even on Khatam-e-Nabowat any mujadid of past did not agreed to your stance.
So once again i asked you to show us
1) if it is a wrong Concept in Islam that Isa AS is alive and will come back then why not any Mujadid did not remove this concept by his writings. Read Tafsir Jalayay a tafsir by a Muajdid on this Issue that is clearly against your believes.
as this is topic is about Isa AS.