Incompetence worse than corruption: Atif Mian

[SaRashid]

بھگوان جی کے بھگوان کا فرمان ہے کہ نااہلی، بدعنوانی سے زیادہ بری چیز ہے، مگر بھگوان جی کے چیلوں کو یہ فرمان منظور نہیں۔
ان سے اپنے بھگوان جی کی بے عزتی اور رسوائی دیکھی نہیں جاتی۔​

 

[expert analysis]

Only if there is deliberate intent.

Deliberately or indelibertly no matter loss of money due to negligence is crime ...many cases are on sehbaz is with this reason that he was CM he should know

 

[Admiral]

I would appreciate it if you refrain from quoting me with your bigotry in the future.

You ruined his sarcasm unfortunately.

 

[SaRashid]

Then aleema baji ko tu na discuss kru she in not In politics

علیمہ باجی نے سونے کے انڈے دینے والی سلائی مشین ایجاد کی ہے۔ اب اتنی قابل خاتون کو کیوں ڈسکس نہ کریں بھائی جی؟
یہ سونے کے انڈے بیچ کر باجی جی نے دبئی اور امریکہ میں جائیدادیں بنائی ہیں، مگر دشمنوں کا خیال ہے کہ یہ سونے کے انڈے نہیں بلکہ شوکت خانم کے فنڈے ہیں۔​

 

[Enlightened10]

Pakistani-American economist Atif Mian put up a twitter poll on Wednesday that proved to be quite a discussion among the Twitterati.He asked if corruption is the bigger problem or incompetence, in the developing countries, Atif questions, “which one is the bigger constraint in the developing countries,” the poll had both ‘corruption of the elite’ and ‘incompetence of the elite’ as the answer.







The percentage was as followed, ‘corruption of elite’ had 60 percent of the votes and ‘incompetence of elite’ had 40 percent, which bagged Atif’s vote as well.

The economist stated while citing Saudi Arabia and China as examples, “I will go with the minority view on this poll and argue that incompetence is the bigger constraint on the development than corruption (of course ideally we want avoid both).”



He further added how China and Saudi Arabia have corruption at the top end regardless of being centralised powers. However, he said that the Chinese system encourages competition which leads to stronger productivity, appreciating the ‘growing pie’ which enables the centralised powers to stay longer. The Saudi Arabian system had failed to do something similar leading to no ‘dynamism’, hence leading to incompetent policies like ‘saudization’.

He continued: “The eventual success of a system relies on one key question: How effectively does it delegate power to the most competent? There is no doubt that corruption can come in the way of such delegation. But even a corrupt system can deliver if it finds a way to delegate to the competent.”

Atif Mian is also the author of the critically acclaimed book ‘House of Debt’ and was the former member in the Pakistan Economic Advisory Council, before he had to resign due to religious pressure he faced for his belief.

Incompetence worse than corruption: Atif Mian - Daily Times

Pakistani-American economist Atif Mian put up a twitter poll on Wednesday that proved to be quite a discussion among the Twitterati. He asked if corruption is the bigger problem or incompetence, in the developing countries, Atif questions, “which one is the bigger constraint in the developing...

dailytimes.com.pk

He is the same Qaidyani who was kicked out from Imran khan cabinet as they were saying that he is against Pakistan

 

[expert analysis]

علیمہ باجی نے سونے کے انڈے دینے والی سلائی مشین ایجاد کی ہے۔ اب اتنی قابل خاتون کو کیوں ڈسکس نہ کریں بھائی جی؟
یہ سونے کے انڈے بیچ کر باجی جی نے دبئی اور امریکہ میں جائیدادیں بنائی ہیں، مگر دشمنوں کا خیال ہے کہ یہ سونے کے انڈے نہیں بلکہ شوکت خانم کے فنڈے ہیں۔​

Chlo kr lu yar discuss ma ny tu our cultur ki waja sy kha tha ;)

 

[expert analysis]

He is the same Qaidyani who was kicked out from Imran khan cabinet as they were saying that he is against Pakistan

Jhoot khan never said he is against pak ...hamara culture bn gya jhoot jhoot aur jhoot ...isi liy ya hal hy hmara

 

[Usama Qayyum BU]

I dont agree with your views

 

[insouciant]

Just as you wouldn't appreciate someone derogately calling you a Muslim, please refrain from doing onto others what you won't like to be done on yourself/loved ones!

Thanks!

He is the same Qaidyani who was kicked out from Imran khan cabinet as they were saying that he is against Pakistan

 

[GreenMaple]

Deliberately or indelibertly no matter loss of money due to negligence is crime ...many cases are on sehbaz is with this reason that he was CM he should know

There is negligence and there is criminal negligence. The criminal negligence is always has an element of intent. A non-intent negligence is not a crime.

 

[GreenMaple]

علیمہ باجی نے سونے کے انڈے دینے والی سلائی مشین ایجاد کی ہے۔ اب اتنی قابل خاتون کو کیوں ڈسکس نہ کریں بھائی جی؟
یہ سونے کے انڈے بیچ کر باجی جی نے دبئی اور امریکہ میں جائیدادیں بنائی ہیں، مگر دشمنوں کا خیال ہے کہ یہ سونے کے انڈے نہیں بلکہ شوکت خانم کے فنڈے ہیں۔​

As a side note; Bill Gates also started his Microsoft from his father car garage.

 

[expert analysis]

There is negligence and there is criminal negligence. The criminal negligence is always has an element of intent. A non-intent negligence is not a crime.

Tu sehbaz shreef ky case ka ya asool kion bhol gay ;)

 

[Abdullah9]

Corruption is injustice and zulm with masses. And IF there is incompetency then it can turn into competency with a passage of time a little later or faster but corruption will get strong and stronger with every passing minute.

 

[GreenMaple]

Tu sehbaz shreef ky case ka ya asool kion bhol gay ;)

Because:
1 He intentionally built waste system to benefit his sugar mill in the guise of public interest;

1. He intentionally overpriced contracts with the intent of kickbacks, and then laundered money.
2. He failed so far to justify his assets;

and more...

 

[expert analysis]

Because:
1 He intentionally built waste system to benefit his sugar mill in the guise of public interest;

1. He intentionally overpriced contracts with the intent of kickbacks, and then laundered money.
2. He failed so far to justify his assets;

and more...

Proof tu kuch hota nai blames hi blames hy ..

 

[GreenMaple]

Proof tu kuch hota nai blames hi blames hy ..

Courts will decide that.

 

[TahiraUmmemomina]

ان کے خیال میں ۔۔۔۔ دوسرے لفظوں میں کام نہ کرنا ۔۔۔چوری کرنے سے زیادہ برا ہے ۔ یا چوری کرنا کام نہ کرنے سے اچھا ہے ۔۔۔۔۔ شیطانی سوچ وہاں جا بیٹھتی ہے جہاں کھوپڑیاں خالی ہیں ۔۔۔۔ یعنی ہر صورت میں ان کے نزدیک بے ایمانی بہتریں حکمتِ عملی ہے ۔۔۔۔ یہ مسلمان ہیں ؟۔۔۔۔ اصل میں ایک چور نالائق بھی ہوتا ہے ۔۔۔ اسی لئے درست راستے سے مال حاصل کرنے کی بجائے چوری جیسا قبیح کام کرتا ہے

 

[expert analysis]

Courts will decide that.

jo abi tak court na clear ky shebaz ko cases ma onka kya,NAB ko warn bhi kia hy

 

[GreenMaple]

jo abi tak court na clear ky shebaz ko cases ma onka kya,NAB ko warn bhi kia hy

He only has been granted arrest bail. His trial has not started yet. He still has to prove his innocence in the court.

 

[expert analysis]

He only has been granted arrest bail. His trial has not started yet. He still has to prove his innocence in the court.

chlo by law utill not proven guilty he is innocent...u cant guilt him..so far he is honest by law