انجینئیر مرزا --- دونکات

Doctor sb

Senator (1k+ posts)
انجینئیر محمد علی مرزا نوجوان محقق اور سلیف میڈ اسکالر ہیں- دین کی تعلیمات پر قدرے دسترس رکھتے اور اپنی راۓ کا برملا اظہار بھی کرتے ہیں- قلیل وقت میں سوشل میڈیا کو بروۓ کار لاتے ہوۓ ہوۓ وہ نسلِ نو کو اپنا گرویدہ بناچکے جو روایتی علماء کے وعظ وتلقین میں زیادہ دلچسپی نہیں رکھتی- یوں وہ بھی ان یوٹیوبی علما کے کارواں کا نمایاں حصہ بن چکے جس کے سرخیل معروف مبلغ مولانا طارق جمیل ہیں

ان کا میں باقاعدہ ناظر یا سامع نہیں مگر کبھی کبھار کہیں سے کوئی ویڈیو سامنے آجاۓ تو سن لیتا ہوں- چونکہ فین بیس والی عمر نہیں رہی اس لیے اپنی راۓ محتاط بناتا ہوں- لیکن اتنا کہہ سکتا ہوں کہ ان کے کھلے ڈھلے انداز کا معترف ہوں

گزشتہ دنوں ان کی دو عدد متنازعہ ویڈیوز منظرِعام پرآئیں جن پر کافی واویلہ بھی ہوا- بات تھانے کچہرے تک جاپہنچی- شاید ایک آدھ دن موصوف کو حوالات کی ہوا بھی کھانے کا شرف حاصل ہوا جو وطن عزیز میں غیرمعمولی بات نہیں

انہیں ویڈیوز میں سے ایک میں وہ قادیانیت بارے دلیل دیتے ہوۓ کہتے ہیں کہ وہ (قادیانی) یہود ونصاری سے اس لحاظ سے بہتر ہیں کہ وہ بنیادِ اسلام یعنی اللہ کی وحدانیت اور حضرت محمدﷺ کی رسالت پر ایمان رکھتے ہیں- چونکہ یہ ایک بودی اور کم فہمی پر مبنی دلیل ہے، لہذا ردِ دلیل دینا وقت کا ضیاع ہوگا- سادہ سمجھنے کی بات یہ ہے کہ ختم نبوت میں نقب لگانے سے وہ دین اسلام سے خارج ہوچکے- ملکی دستور بھی انہیں غیرمسلم قرار دیتا ہے مگر چونکہ اسلام کا لبادہ اوڑھتے ہیں --- تو یہودونصاریٰ سے زیادہ مضر ہیں
دوسری ویڈیو میں وہ صوفی ازم، طریقت اور بیعت کے تصور پر حملہ آور ہیں- تصورات نئے ہیں اور نہ ہی ان پر بحث- یہ موضوعات اب مختلف اسکول آف تھاٹس میں بدل چکے- ہر دو طرفین سے بےبہا دلائل اور دعوی جات بھی نص کے ساتھ! نئی نسل نہ ان موضوعات میں دلچسپی رکھتی ہے اور نہ یہ سبجیکٹس ایسے ہیں کہ جنھیں یوٹیوب ویڈیوز میں عامیانہ انداز میں بیان کیا جاۓ- معتبر ثقہ علماء کی ان پر طویل بحثیں ہیں جو ضخیم کتب کی شکل میں لائبریروں کی زینت بنی ہیں
انجینئر مرزا اور ان کے ہمعصر--- سوشل میڈیا کے علما کے ساتھ دو مسائل ہیں
پہلا: چونکہ ویڈیو میں --- میڈیم یعنی زریعہ پیغام رسانی تقریر ہے اور اکثر فی البدیہیہ، تو اس میں غلطیوں کا احتمال زیادہ ہوتا ہے- انسان جذبات کی رو میں یا مخصوص ماحول کے تحت ایسی بہت ساری باتیں کہہ جاتا ہے جو تحقیق طلب ہوتی ہیں- عام عوام سے متعلق نہیں ہوتیں یا پھر ان پر عمومی راۓ منقسم ہوتی ہے- بعض اوقات مقرر کے لہجے کا لاابالی پن، غیرسنجیدگی اور عامیانہ پن ایک نازک مسئلہ کو تفریق کا باعث بناتا اور سماج میں نفرت بڑھاتا ہے- ان پریشانیوں سے بچنے کی واحد صورت بات کو لکھ لینا ہوتا ہے بالخصوص جب مقصد اپنے پیغام کو پھیلانا ہو- ویسے بھی دین کی تعلیمات پھیلانے کا طریق تو حکمت، دانش، علم، اور میانہ روی ہے

دوسرا: یہ پہلو زیادہ اہم ہے- مبلغ کو اس منقسم معاشرے کی حرکیات
dynamics
سے بلد ہونا چاہیے- ایسی متنازعہ راۓ سے پرہیز کرنا چاہیے جو عوام کو مشتعل کرے، تفریق کو مزیدگہرا کرے- ایسا ممکن نہیں کہ مبلغ ہر موضوع پر دسترس رکھتا ہو- کچھ مسائل اس بات کے متقاضی ہوتے ہیں کہ ان پر خامہ فرسائی کرنے سے قبل مقرر کو تاریخی، قانونی، اور سماجی
پہلوؤں سے مکمل آگاہی ہونی چاہیے- اگر ایسا نہیں تو راۓ دینے سے قبل اپنے سے زیادہ باعلم علما اور قانون شناس سے مشورہ کرنا چاہیے- ایک اچھا محقق تو علم کی مسلسل کھوج میں رہتا ہے اور محض کتابی علم یا اپنی محدود سوچ پر اکتفا نہیں کرتا بلکہ سیکھنے کا دائرہ بڑھاتا ہے

محمد علی مرزا ابھی سیکھنے کے مراحل میں ہیں- اگر مقصد دین کی خدمت اور نوجوان نسل کو اسی جانب راغب کرنا ہے تو پھر اپنی حکمتِ عملی کا جائزہ لیں- لیکن اگر مقصد دوسروں کی تذلیل وتحقیر سے ذاتی تسکین کشید کرنی ہے تو اپنا معمول جاری رکھیں

رب کریم اپنے دین کی بہتر سمجھ عطا فرماۓ، آمین
 
Featured Thumbs


Pakistani1947

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
گزشتہ دنوں ان کی دو عدد متنازعہ ویڈیوز منظرِعام پرآئیں جن پر کافی واویلہ بھی ہوا- بات تھانے کچہرے تک جاپہنچی- شاید ایک آدھ دن موصوف کو حوالات کی ہوا بھی کھانے کا شرف حاصل ہوا جو وطن عزیز میں غیرمعمولی بات نہیں

انہیں ویڈیوز میں سے ایک میں وہ قادیانیت بارے دلیل دیتے ہوۓ کہتے ہیں کہ وہ (قادیانی) یہود ونصاری سے اس لحاظ سے بہتر ہیں کہ وہ بنیادِ اسلام یعنی اللہ کی وحدانیت اور حضرت محمدﷺ کی رسالت پر ایمان رکھتے ہیں- چونکہ یہ ایک بودی اور کم فہمی پر مبنی دلیل ہے، لہذا ردِ دلیل دینا وقت کا ضیاع ہوگا- سادہ سمجھنے کی بات یہ ہے کہ ختم نبوت میں نقب لگانے سے وہ دین اسلام سے خارج ہوچکے- ملکی دستور بھی انہیں غیرمسلم قرار دیتا ہے مگر چونکہ اسلام کا لبادہ اوڑھتے ہیں --- تو یہودونصاریٰ سے زیادہ مضر ہیں

I agree with you point number # 1 that although Qadianis say that they that they believe in the Prohethood of Prophet Muhammad pbuh but they do not believe Prophet Muhammad pbuh as last Prophet hence they are outside the boundary of Islam. Since they still present themselves as Muslims they are more dangerous to Muslims than non-Muslims or Ahle Kitab. And I think that Engineer should correct himself on this issue as it is very sensitive for Muslims.

I have been Listening to Engineer Ali Mirza recently. Unlike majority of so called Pakistani Aalim's, I found Engineer Ali Mirza has great command in ilm-e-Hadeeth. His comments are very logical and are based mostly on authentic Hadeeth from Sahih Muslim and Sahih Bukhari. But nobody is Perfect and hence can make mistake. I hope that he would apologize for what he said about Qadianis and continue to guide Young Generation through Qur'an and authentic Hadeeths without any bias with existing Muslim sects.

I am confident that Engineer Ali Mirza will be successful in creating unity and harmony among all major Muslim sects in Pakistan such as Deobandi, Brelvi, Ahle Hadeeths and Shias and by promoting the idea that we should call ourselves Muslim rather than Deobandi or Brelvi which is against the Allah's order in Qur'an:

Allah has prohibited us to create sects in Islam:

(Qur'an 30:31) ۞ مُنِيبِينَ إِلَيْهِ وَاتَّقُوهُ وَأَقِيمُوا الصَّلَاةَ وَلَا تَكُونُوا مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ
(Qur'an 30:32) مِنَ الَّذِينَ فَرَّقُوا دِينَهُمْ وَكَانُوا شِيَعًا ۖ كُلُّ حِزْبٍ بِمَا لَدَيْهِمْ فَرِحُونَ
Turn ye back in repentance to Him, and fear Him: establish regular prayers, and be not ye among those who join gods with Allah,-Those who split up their Religion, and become (mere) Sects,- each party rejoicing in that which is with itself!
اسی کی طرف رجوع کیے رہو اور اس سے ڈرو اور نماز قائم کرو اور مشرکوں میں سے نہ ہوجاؤ- جنہوں نے اپنے دین کو ٹکڑے ٹکڑے کر دیا اور کئی فرقے ہو گئے سب فرقے اسی سے خوش ہیں جو ان کے پا س ہے

Narrated Hudhaifa bin Al-Yaman: The people used to ask Allah's Apostle pbuh about good, but I used to ask him about evil for fear that it might overtake me. Once I said, "O Allah's Apostle! We were in ignorance and in evil and Allah has bestowed upon us the present good; will there by any evil after this good?" He pbuhsaid, "Yes." I asked, "Will there be good after that evil?" He pbuh said, "Yes, but it would be tained with Dakhan (i.e. Little evil)." I asked, "What will its Dakhan be?" He pbuh said, "There will be some people who will lead (people) according to principles other than my tradition. You will see their actions and disapprove of them." I said, "Will there by any evil after that good?"
He pbuh said, "Yes, there will be some people who will invite others to the doors of Hell, and whoever accepts their invitation to it will be thrown in it (by them)." I said, "O Allah's Apostle! pbuh Describe those people to us." He pbuh said, "They will belong to us and speak our language" I asked, "What do you order me to do if such a thing should take place in my life?" He pbuh said, "Adhere to the group of Muslims and their Chief." I asked, "If there is neither a group (of Muslims) nor a chief (what shall I do)?" He pbuh said, "Keep away from all those different sects, even if you had to bite (i.e. eat) the root of a tree, till you meet Allah while you are still in that state." (Sahih Bukhari; Book #56, Hadith #803)

Question: After reading clear verses of Quraan and Hadith from Sahih Bukhari, if we still stick to our sects like, Hanafi, Shaafi. Maliki, Hambali, Ahle-Hadeeth, Shia, and Ismailee etc. wouldn't we be dis-obeying Allah's Order?
 
Last edited:

AhmadSaleem264

Minister (2k+ posts)
The thing is most of these hefty books contain less actual substance and arguments and more nonsensical details As they say in urdu "Baal ki khaal utarna". I have seen people writing long essays to describe simple arguments that can be described in two lines and are usually flawed.
 

Pakistani1947

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
انجینئیر محمد علی مرزا نوجوان محقق اور سلیف میڈ اسکالر ہیں- دین کی تعلیمات پر
دوسری ویڈیو میں وہ صوفی ازم، طریقت اور بیعت کے تصور پر حملہ آور ہیں-

Following is the extract (نچوڑ) written by Dr Shabbir Ahmad. I am not fan of this Munkir e Hadeeth but the grave accusation (سنگین الزامات) he had made can not be ignored and deserved to be investigated. I am not sure how authentic these accusations are against Sufism. But I see some glimpse of these accusations in real life in pakistan.The writer has given references along with all of the accusation. I do not have means to verify the references and leave it to the readers:

"Now discover why Allama Iqbal calls Tasawwuf/Sufism (Mysticism) “An Alien Plant in the Soil of Islam.” The following paragraph summarizes the opinion of two of the greatest thinkers of the 19-20 century India, namely Sir Syed Ahmad Khan and Allama Shibli Na’mani. They state: “It is often claimed that the Sufis brought Islam to the Indo-Pak Subcontinent. A careful review of history gives us quite a different picture. Muslims ruled the Subcontinent for more than eight centuries, and today 80% of the population remains Hindu. The Muslims adopted and absorbed so much of Hindu mythology, customs, and traits that they became half-Hindus and half-Muslims. This happened because the philosophy of the “Unity of Being” was exactly the same among the Muslim Sufis and the Hindu Yogis. The only difference was that of nomenclature. The Hindu “Hama Oost” (All is He) was, and is, fully interchangeable with “Wahdat-al-Wujood” (The Unity of Being) of the Sufi. Essentially, both mean that everything in the Universe is God.” Afkaar-e-Sir Syed Wa Shibli

Now prepare your mind for an awesome flight. See hundreds of criminals insulting human intelligence in the name of Islam. Watch them making mockery of God, His Messengers, His Guidance and the Laws of Nature. They go as far as their imagination can take them. Watch them play God, produce miracles, bash reason and kill common sense. Their true miracle, however, is that millions of Muslims still consider them as champions of Islam.

Here are some quotes from the Sufi books. Read---enjoy---


I am superior to Prophets and I am higher in rank than they are. (Sheikh Mohiuddin Ibn-Arabi, Hadeeqa Sultania Pg190)
I have denounced Islam. I believe this is incumbent on people. Allah is God sitting in the heavens, I am the God on earth. (Statement of Hussain bin Mansoor Hallaj, Khateeb Baghdadi Vol 8, Ibne Athir chapter 11:140)
Men of knowledge see the Shi’as as swines. (Mohiuddin Ibn-Arabi, Futoohat Makkia 2:8)

Sheikh Imam Abul Hassan Noori was in the company of his disciples. The call to prayers came. The Sheikh said, “It is death.” Then a dog barked. The Sheikh replied, "Labbaik ya Sayyedi!" - Yes, O My Master! (Ibn-e-Jozi Talbees-e-Iblis Pg 383)

My body has merged with the body of Rasulullah. Therefore, we are one. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain)

I recite Surah Fatiha and walk across the river. (Mulfoozat Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri). The strange thing is not their silly claims. It is the people who believe in them.

In the assemblies of "URS" (communion of Sufi souls with God, literally, wedding with God), spirits of the dead Sufis come to dance around. (Mullah Abul Kalam Azad, the late Minister of Education in India. Iman-e-Khalis by Fazil ‘Uloom-e Deeniyah, Dr. Masooduddin Usmani Pg 63)

Allama Shibli Na’mani, Muhammad Husain Azad, Deputy Nazeer Ahmed and Sir Syed Ahmad Khan noted a weird exchange of religious dogmas in the Subcontinent. Centuries ago, the Brahmans (priest class) of India were alarmed as Hindu masses, impressed by the Message of true Monotheism and human equality, were finding Islam irresistible. To safeguard Hinduism, the Brahmans started the “Bhagti” movement in the 11th century, which preached that Raam and Raheem were one. Hindu Yogis befriended Muslim Sufia. They learned tricks from each other and called them “Karamat” and “Chamatkar” (Miracles). Their followers portrayed them as super-humans. Sheikh Sa’di Shirazi has correctly pointed out, “Saints fly not. Their disciples make them fly.”

The end result was a wholesale amalgamation of Islam and Hinduism, giving birth to a new religion that has been termed as the Ittihadi Deen (Unified Faith) by Dr. Usmani. In the process, Hindus who embraced Islam, and Muslims who were exposed to the currents of Vedant (Hindu Mysticism), all remained half-Hindus and half-Muslims. If some Hindus embraced Islam, many Muslims embraced Hinduism. Most Muslims of the subcontinent are in fact followers of the Unified Faith. It is no wonder that Hindus are very respectful of the “Muslim” Sufis.

Here is a glimpse of the Unified Faith: Hindus worship idols, Muslims worship graves. We have ‘Urs instead of Yatra, Tawaf of graves instead of Phairay, Agarbatti in place of Momebatti, Tabarruk versus Prashad, Qawwali versus Bhajan, Araq-e-Gulab versus Gangajal, Kharqa versus Zunnar, and so on.
(Iman-e-Khalis by Fazil ‘Uloom-e Deeniyah, Dr. Masooduddin Usmani)

Hazrat Dawood Jawarbi had seen Allah. When asked about Allah, he said, “Ask me not about His genitals and His beard. Ask about anything else.(Al-Milil-wan-Nahil, Imam Shahristani 1:96). Imam Shahristani should have reported ‘Hazrat’ Jawarbi to the authorities. And the authorities should have painted both as clowns and placed them on donkeys for a ride around the town for spreading such rubbish.

The priest in the church is our Allah. (Sheikh Ibn-Arabi, Qasasul Ulema Pg 53)

There is none else worthy of worship. Come and worship me. (Mullah Jalaluddin Rumi, Mathnawi 4:52)

Time for a hearty laugh: This morning Allah wrestled with me. He floored me because I am 2 years younger than He is. (Abul Hassan Kharqani, Fawaid Faridiya Pg 78)

Alas! The Muslim fails to understand that Allah can be found only in idol worship.
(Sufi Mahmood Shabistri, Sharah Gulshan-e-Raz Pg 294)

Hanafis are people who are pacing toward Hellfire. The death anniversary of Imam Husain must be celebrated like the Festival of Eid. (“Piran-e-Pir Dastgeer” - The Saint of saints, Holder of hands - Abdul Qadir Jeelani, Ghania- til-Talibain Pg 190)

My foot is on the neck of every saint. So, I placed my foot on Hazrat Ali's neck. (Abdul Qadir Jeelani, Asrar-ul-Qadam Pg 191)
FACT: Jeelani was exhumed

It is worth recalling that the governor of Baghdad, Ubaidullah Yunus, leveled the home of “Peeraan-e-Peer, Dastgeer” abdul Qadir Jeelani (d. 1166), threw out his sons, exhumed his grave, burnt his remains, and plunged them in the river Tigris in 1170 CE. (Nujoom-uz-Zahrani 6:142)

I hate the God who does not appear as a dog or cat. (Ibn-Arabi, Khazeena Imaniyah Pg 168). Note: This is same Ibn-Arabi who is portrayed as great Sufi Saint in the Drama Serial Ertugal
Whenever Khwaja Maudood Chishti desired to see the Ka’bah, angels airlifted it to the land of Chisht in India. (Malfoozat Khwaja Qutubuddin Bukhtiar Kaki, Fariduddin Ganj Shakar). This Khwaja Maudood Chishti is reported to be the ancestor of the famous Mullah-in-Chief of the 20th century, Maududi.
One thousand years have gone and so has the time of Muhammad. Now it is my time, the time of Ahmad. The second millennium is mine. (Sheikh Ahmad Sarhindi, the so-called “Mujaddid Alf-Sani”, Revivalist of the Second Millennium. (Mubda-wa-Ma’ad)

Books of the Tableeghi Nisab “Fazael A’mal” were presented to the exalted Prophet (in the twentieth century!) and he graciously certified them. (Behjatil Quloob Pg 12)

Khwaja Qutbuddin Maudood Chishti’s dead body flew in the air on its way to the graveyard. Khwaja Fareeduddin Ganj Shakar upon narrating this fell unconscious. (Rahatil-Quloob, Ganj Shakar). Ganj Shakar could not bear his own forgery, but he should have expired.

Adam cried for 300 years, so much so that birds made nests on his face. His tears brought forth so much grass that it covered his 60 meters long body. (Rahatul Muhibbeen c/o Ameer Khusro. Khwaja Nizamuddin Awliya)

A bird came and told us, "Tomorrow is Eid. Unlike humans we are free from lies.” Sheikh Faqirullah knew a crow that often learned Monotheism from him. (Reference same)

If Awliya (saints) wish, they can accept invitations from 10,000 towns and be there at the same time. (Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi, Malfoozat part I Pg 127)

When Shah Waliullah was in his mother’s womb, she said a prayer. Two tiny hands appeared from her belly for prayer. She was frightened. Her husband said, "You have Qutubul Aqtab (Saint of Saints) in your womb. (Mullah Ashraf Ali Thanwi, Hikayaat-e-Awliya Pg 17). What a breakthrough!

The Prophet laid the foundation of Darul ‘Uloom, Deoband, India (in the 19th century!) He comes to check the accounts of the Madrasah. He has learnt Urdu from the Ulema of Deoband. (Mubasshirat-e-Darul ‘Uloom and Deoband Number of the Darul ‘Uloom). Was this tale made up to lend credence to the Deoband Mullah factory?

One night I started flying from heaven to heaven until I reached the Prophet. He accepted my allegiance. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain Pg 38-39).

Allah revealed Himself to me as an extremely beautiful, irresistible woman, adorned with fine ornaments and see-through garments. She suddenly embraced me and merged into my body. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain Pg 94-95).

The sun cannot rise before greeting me. The new year, the new month, the new day, cannot dawn without greeting me and informing me of every single event. (Malfoozat Ahmad Raza Barelwi about the exhumed ‘Ghaus Azam’ Abdul Qadir Jeelani)

A wolf was brought before Prophet Jacob. He said to the wolf, “Tell me about my son, Joseph.” The wolf said, “I am an animal, but I do no backbiting.” (Reference same)

Prophet Job prayed, “O God! Give me 12,000 tongues so that I may glorify Your Name.” God accepted his prayer and infested his body with 12,000 insects. (Reference same)

The mosquito that killed King Nimrod (Shaddad) of Babylon was lame. (Malfoozat Chishti). Thanks for the lame information!

Hazrat Uthman brought home a fish. All the firewood was burnt off, but the fish remained fresh (uncooked). When the Prophet asked the reason, the fish said, “I had sent my salutations to you once.” (Reference same)

Shah Waliullah believed in the Unity of Being. He believed that insects, animals, idols and human beings were all God. (Syed Farooq Al-Qadri, Anfasul Arifain)

Allah has only 99 virtuous names. I have more than 99, in fact 4000. (Shah Waliullah quoting his uncle, Anfasul Arifain Pg 210)

Some people told Shah Abdur Raheem (Shah Waliullah’s father) that they were trying to find God. My father said, “I am He!” They stood up and shook hands. (Reference same, Pg 93). Why didn’t they prostrate?

God came to me in a cloak in the guise of an extremely beautiful woman. I became passionate and said, “Cast aside your cloak.” The response came, “The cloak is very thin. It reveals my beauty.” I insisted, upon which the cloak was lifted. (Quote of father and son, Shah Abdur Raheem & Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain Pg 94)

Imam Ahmad Bin Hanbal got his undeserved fame when his ego caused him to suffer lashes for a vain argument with the Abbasi Caliph. (Al-Tawassul Wal Waseela Pg 136). This one sounds true.

The great Pir (master saint) of the 19th century, Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi, has been quoted in his Malfoozat Pg 32, "Prophets are alive in their graves like ever before. They eat, drink, pray and receive their wives in the grave and engage with them in sex."

Now watch God’s retirement plan: Sheikh Abdul Qadir Jeelani claimed: Allah has made me Eternal and has joined me with Him. He has given in my hand this world and the Hereafter and all Creation. (Jeelani, Malfoozat Fuyuz Yazdani,
Fath-e-Rabb-ani, Majlis 51)

PIRAN-E-PIR DASTGEER JEELANI DOOMED! The governor of Baghdad, Ubaidullah Yunus, leveled the home of Jeelani (d. 1166), threw out his sons, exhumed his grave, burnt his remains, and plunged them in the river Tigris (1170 CE). The governor had attained Fatwas against Jeelani that he was a Mushrik and Kaafir. (Nooruddin Shams, a disciple of the Pir Jeelani, Nujoom-uz-Zahrani 6:142). The “Piran-e-Pir”, the eternal master of the universe, could not help himself. Even then, millions of Muslims continue to call Jeelani as Piran-e-Pir ‘Dastgeer’ (The Saint of saints, the Holder of hands).
Prophet David and Prophet Muhammad both sinned because they saw the beauty of unclothed women. Then Uriah’s wife and Zaid’s wife became Haram (forbidden) for their husbands. (Ali Hajweri, alias “Daata Ganj Baksh,” the Giver of Treasures, Kalamil Marghoob Pg 349)
Junaid Baghdadi said that Prophet Solomon was the illegitimate son of David from Uriah’s wife. Sheik Seereen wrote that Surah Ahzab of the Quran means to say that Muhammad (S) was hiding the carnal love of Zainab (the wife of Zaid), in his heart. (Malfoozal Al-‘Asl Pg 219)

A wife of the Prophet (S) saw a male sparrow mounting the female sparrow. She challenged the Prophet. When the night set in, the Prophet mounted her in a most furious manner 90 times and said, “See! There is no deficiency here.” (Shamsuddin Akhlaqi, Manaqib-il-Arifain Pg 70-71). We wonder whether these are sacred writings or pornography!

These dogs and swines are our God. (Fusoosul Hukm, Mohiuddin Ibne Arabi)

Ba-Yazeed Bustami, supposedly the head of all saints, is quoted in his Malfoozat, the book of narratives:
  • I am Glorious, the Ultimate, the Pure. My Glory is beyond description.
  • My Kingdom is greater than the Kingdom of God.
  • Allah is in my pocket.
  • My flag flies higher than the flag of Muhammad.
  • I dived into the sea of Knowledge while the Prophets watched by the shore.

Ali Hajweri, “Daata Ganj Bakhsh,” in his Kashfil Mahjoob, Pg 255-256 supports Ba-Yazeed Bustami's claim that he was God in human form.

Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri taught his disciples a different Kalema (Creed) “There is no god but Allah and Chishti is His Messenger.” (Khwaja Fareed-ud-Din Ganj Shakar, Fawaed-us-Saalikeen Pg 126-127)

Dear reader, if you recapture briefly what you have read so far, it is easy to see why it is important to get rid of these insults from our books, or at least try to neutralize them. Any preaching based on these absurdities leaves a strongly negative impact on our society. They promote human worship and other forms of shirk. They encourage immodesty and degrade women. The Muslim gets further away from the Quran and gets enslaved by superstition and nonsensical themes. It is regrettable that non-Muslims think that this trash represents Islam and then, of course, despise our Deen. In addition, many of our youth get disenchanted with this man-made Islam, and lose their faith.

Now, what message is Sheikh Afeef-ud-Din Talmisani trying to convey when he says: The Quran is loaded with Shirk (idolatry, polytheism). True Monotheism is that everything in the universe is God. (Malfoozat Talmisani Pg 205)

It was right for the Pharaoh to say, “I am God”. He, of course, was a part of the Essence of God. (Reference same)

Ibraheem Adham reached the Ka’bah in 14 years because he prayed two nawafil (units of physical prayer) at every step. But the Ka’bah was not there! A voice came from the heavens, "It has gone to visit Rabia Basri.” (Malfoozat Khwaja Uthman Harooni, Aneesul Arwah Pg 17). Doesn’t it make us think why the Ka’bah could not go to meet the Prophet (S) in Hudaibiyah or Madina? According to Sheikh Afifuddin Talmisani’s Malfoozat Pg 177, Rabia Basri was in romantic love, first with Hasan Basri and then with Ibrahim Adham.

In Cordova, I fell in love with Fatima. In Makkah I fell in love with the beautiful Ain-ush-Shams. The spiritual windows opened upon me hence. (Sheikh Mohiuddin Ibne Arabi, Fusoosul Hukm)

Ba-Yazid Bustami could take the soul of any person whenever he wanted. My uncle Abu Raza Muhammad, upon hearing this became very upset and said, “Ba-Yazid could not return the soul and restore life. I can take a soul and return it as I want.” Then my uncle took the soul of Rahmatullah Kafshdoze and brought him back to life. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Afrifain Pg 95)

Junaid Baghdadi was sitting when a dog crossed by. He merely glanced at the dog which then reached such glory that all dogs of the town followed him. Then he sat down and all dogs sat around him in meditation. (Ashraf Ali Thanwi, Imdadul Mushtaq)

“There is no priesthood in Islam” is a very common but erroneous statement. There should be no priesthood in Islam, but in reality the Sufi and the Mullah have formed a very strong union. They are always ready to attack any semblance of reason from all quarters and they are always vigilant to label any voice of reason as infidelity. Many of them maintain that thinking and reasoning are forbidden in Islam.

The Messenger (S) came to Shah Waliullah (in the 18 century!) and said “Why do you worry, my son? Your children are the same as mine.” (Ashraf Ali Thanwi, Hikayaat-e-Awliya)

It is obligatory upon a mu’min (believer) that he quits eating and drinking. He must get weak to the point where he becomes unable to pray. (Sahl bin Abdullah Tastari, Malfoozat Arabi Pg 289)

Hazrat Sha’raani was the Sheikh of miracles. He resided in a meadow and used to visit the town riding a wolf. He walked on water. His urine was drinkable like pure milk. (Allama Tareshi’s excerpts, Misra’ Tasawwuf Pg 194). Did Tareshi try his milk?

Jalaluddin Rumi never prayed. When the time for prayers came he used to vanish. At last, it was discovered that he used to pray in the Ka’bah - 2000 miles away from Quniah, five times a day. (Khwaja Nizamuddin Awliya, Raahat-il-Quloob). Have you noticed the Sufis patting one another’s back?

My uncle saw me create and destroy the universe. (Shah Waliullah, Afasul Arifain Pg 210)

Once there was a Sheikh who used to grab a dog every day and put him on the prayer rug and said, “O dog, you are in the hands of God!” Those dogs then started walking on water and healed people by giving them Ta’weez (amulets). (Qutubuddin Bakhtiar Kaki, Malfoozat)

Here is a funny one: The dead body of a dervish was lying in a jungle laughing. I asked him, “You are dead. How can you laugh?” The dead body replied, “This is what happens in the love of Allah.” (Khwaja Ghareeb Nawaz, Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri, Malfoozat)

The Universe lies within Koh Qaaf (the Mount Caucasus). This mountain is 40 times bigger than the earth. A cow is holding it on its head. (Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti, Dalilul Arifain). Isn’t it pathetic that people of such miniscule minds are considered the saints of Islam? This mythology is obviously borrowed from Hinduism which holds that the entire earth is perched on one horn of a cow and when it shifts the load to the other horn, earthquakes occur.

The people of Multan refused to provide fire to Shah Shams Tabrez for roasting meat. He became enraged, brought the sun down and roasted the meat. As people became restless with heat, they came to the saint and asked his forgiveness and then he ordered the sun to go back. Since that day, the town became known for its hot summers. (Ali Quli Baghdadi, Karamaat Shah Tabrez Pg 233)

A great saint Hazrat Abdul Wahab went to visit the grave of Pir Syedi Ahmad Kabir. Abdul Wahab saw a beautiful bondwoman. Syedi Kabir called from his grave, “Hey, do you like her?” The owner of the bondwoman instantly dedicated her to the grave. The dead Pir spoke again, "O Abdul Wahab! Take her to the side room and satisfy your desire." (Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi, the greatest master of Islamic law, and Mujaddid, revivalist of Islam for the 19th century, Malfoozat part 3 Pg 28)

Ibraheem Adham was the governor of Balakh. While hunting, a deer turned back and scolded him. Since that day, Adham quit his throne and became a saint. (“Daata” Ganj Bakhsh, the Giver of Treasures, Kalamil Marghoob Pg 229)
When the companions went with the Prophet for Ghazwaat (battles), some of their wives had sex with other men. (Mullah Jalaluddin Rumi, Feeh-Ma-Feeh, Saleem Chishti, Islami Tasawwuf Pg 66). According to a forged Hadith, the Prophet (S) used to advise them not to go home before dawn, saying, “Would any of you like to see his wife in bed with another man?” What an insult to the noble men and women companions, quite contrary to the Quran!

Women are the source of all tribulation (فتنہ) in the world, religious or otherwise. (Ali Hajweri “Daata Ganj Bakhsh” in Malfoozat Ahmad Raza Barelwi)

There was a 140 year old worshipper. He had an amputated foot. When asked, he said, “I was in I’tikaaf (seclusion for worship in a Masjid). I stepped one foot out. An angel warned me, and I immediately cut off my foot with a knife.” (Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri in Malfoozat Uthman Harooni)

Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri writes in the same book that the moon and the sun eclipse because of the sins of people! The Prophet (S) had explained that eclipses occur according to Divine Laws in Nature.
A man stole shrouds from graves for 40 years, but he went to the highest degree in Paradise. Why? Because he held on to the prayer rug (he prayed all the time). (Malfoozat Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri, by Khwaja Qutub Alam, Daleel Arifain)
Now, Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri decides to display his prowess in the English language: Where the Quran says, “Fawelullil musalleen” it means there is a “well” for Musalleen, the praying ones… (Reference same)

Watch for more wisdom from Chishti in the same book: The Hellfire is placed in the mouth of a snake deep in the seventh level of the earth. Otherwise the whole Universe would burn.

Khwaja Qutubuddin Bakhtiar Kaki knew half the Quran by heart when he was born. (Fawaaid-as-Salikeen, Khwaja

Fareed-ud-Din “Ganj Shakar”, The Treasure of Sugar). What titanic forces prevented him from completing it?
Fareeduddin “Ganj Shakar” turned bushels of sugar into salt and again into sugar. (The Beloved of God, “Mehboob-e-Elahi”, Khwaja Nizamuddin Awliya, Raahatul Quloob)

Now watch arrogance at its height: The Prophet attended the funeral of Barakat Ahmed. And I led the prayer (the Prophet was his follower in prayer). (Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi, Malfoozat). Sir Syed Ahmad Khan rightly points out that the supposed Islamic saints were frequently envious of the exalted Prophet.
Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti says, “What do you ask of Koh Qaaf, the Mount Caucasus? This mountain is resting on the head of a cow. The greatness and size of this cow equals 30,000 years of travel. Her head is in the East and her tail in the West. She has been standing since eternity praising the Lord.” Sheikh Uthman Harooni reports that after narrating this (insult to human intelligence), Sheikh Maudood Chishti and a companion sank into deep meditation. Both disappeared leaving their gowns behind. They had gone to take a stroll up the Mount Caucasus. (Malfoozat Khwaja Chishti Ajmeri by Khwaja Bakhtiar Kaki, Daleelul Arifain pPg 85-86). They should have disappeared from the planet.

By God! I know 99 out of 100 thoughts that come in the heart of an ant living in the lowest stratum of the earth. Allah knows all one hundred. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain Pg 205)

“Maulana” Ashraf Ali Thanwi separated the way of Salaat between men and women in his book “Bahishti Zaiwar”. (Muhammad Sultan, Masjid Tauheed, Karachi)

Do not try to understand the Quran ever! Else, you will go astray. Fifteen ‘Uloom” (Sciences) are required to understand the Book. (“Maulana” Zakaria Kandhalwi, Fazaael A’maal Pg 2). The Quran claims that it is an easy book to understand, and it is (41:3). But the Mullahs and Sufis want the masses to remain oblivious to the Glorious Book."

Source
 
Last edited:

There is only 1

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
The thing is most of these hefty books contain less actual substance and arguments and more nonsensical details As they say in urdu "Baal ki khaal utarna". I have seen people writing long essays to describe simple arguments that can be described in two lines and are usually flawed.
جی درست فرمایا آپ نے
مذہبی تعلیمات کے میدان میں ، میں نے یہ مشاہدہ کیا ہے کہ حق بات بہت مختصر اور جامع ہوتی ہے اور فضول باتوں میں فضول طوالت
 

peaceandjustice

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
انجینئر صاحب کو کیسی بھی کیٹیگری میں رکھا جائے اس سے عوام کو کوئی غرض نہیں ھے لیکن دین کا ترجمان بن کر دین اسلام کی تعلیمات کا یہ مزاج بالکل صحیح نہیں ھے جس طرح سے مرزا انجینئر صاحب پیش کر رہے ہیں مرزا انجینئرصاحب وہ دینی معاملات لانے کی کوششیں کرتے ہیں جس پر آگر انجینئر صاحب یا کوئی اور عالم دین یا اسکالرز ڈارکٹ بات کر کے قرآن اور صحیح حدیث کی روشنی میں اپنا موقف بیان فرما دیں بغیر کسی کو ٹارگٹ کئے تو عوام تک پیغام پہنچ جائے گا اور پھر عوام جس طرح چاہیں دین اسلام کی تعلیمات پر قرآن اور سنت کے مطابق عمل کریں
میرے نزدیک طارق جمیل صاحب جس انداز سے دین کا پیغام پہنچا رھے ھیں وہ بہترین ھے غلطیاں سب سے ہوتی ہیں لیکن ھر کیسی کو پاکستان کے آئین وقانون کے دائرے میں رہتے ہوئے ملک کی اور عوام کی خدمت کرنی چاہیے ھے
اسلام ایک مکمل دین ھے جو کہ اللّٰہ کے آخری نبی حضرت محمد صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم کے زریعے قرآن مجید کی آخری کتاب کی صورت میں امت محمدی کے پاس موجود ھے اور اگر ھر انسان اس کو سمجھ کر پڑھ لے تو انشاءاللہ دنیا اور آخرت کی بھلائیاں اور کامیابیاں حاصل کی جاسکتی ہیں۔ الحمدللہ
اللّٰہ سبحان و تعالیٰ سے دعا ھے ھمیں دین اسلام کے سیدھے راستے پر چلنے کی توفیق عطا فرما آمین ثم آمین
 

Pakistani1947

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)

دوسری ویڈیو میں وہ صوفی ازم، طریقت اور بیعت کے تصور پر حملہ آور ہیں-

Engineer Ali Mirza criticize Sufism based on their deviated Aqaid. According to Sufi's Book Hasht Bahisht, great Sufi scholar, Khwaja Muinuddin Chishti, made their mureed read Kalima "Chishti Rasool Allah" (Astughfirullah) and one of the most Prominent scholar (ممتاز عالم) of Deobandi school of thought made his Mureed say "Ashraf Rasool Allah" (Astughfirullah) .









Now, tell me why it is permitted to print these Gutakhana Books in Pakistan. In my opinion, this is far greater crime than what Engineer Ali Mirza said about Qadianis.
 
Last edited:

Saboo

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)

جی درست فرمایا آپ نے
مذہبی تعلیمات کے میدان میں ، میں نے یہ مشاہدہ کیا ہے کہ حق بات بہت مختصر اور جامع ہوتی ہے اور فضول باتوں میں فضول طوالت
ہاہاہا..ارے واه جی واه ! آپ تو بڑے استاد نکلے؟
یعنی در پردہ آپ نے ایک اچھی خاصی دلچسپ جگت
کر بھی دی اور کسی کا نام بھی نہیں لیا؟ یہ فن تو کوئی
آپ سے سیکھے؟.....@Pakistani1947
 

Citizen X

President (40k+ posts)
Following is the extract (نچوڑ) written by Dr Shabbir Ahmad. I am not fan of this Munkir e Hadeeth but the grave accusation (سنگین الزامات) he had made can not be ignored and deserved to be investigated. I am not sure how authentic these accusations are against Sufism. But I see some glimpse of these accusations in real life in pakistan.The writer has given references along with all of the accusation. I do not have means to verify the references and leave it to the readers:

"Now discover why Allama Iqbal calls Tasawwuf/Sufism (Mysticism) “An Alien Plant in the Soil of Islam.” The following paragraph summarizes the opinion of two of the greatest thinkers of the 19-20 century India, namely Sir Syed Ahmad Khan and Allama Shibli Na’mani. They state: “It is often claimed that the Sufis brought Islam to the Indo-Pak Subcontinent. A careful review of history gives us quite a different picture. Muslims ruled the Subcontinent for more than eight centuries, and today 80% of the population remains Hindu. The Muslims adopted and absorbed so much of Hindu mythology, customs, and traits that they became half-Hindus and half-Muslims. This happened because the philosophy of the “Unity of Being” was exactly the same among the Muslim Sufis and the Hindu Yogis. The only difference was that of nomenclature. The Hindu “Hama Oost” (All is He) was, and is, fully interchangeable with “Wahdat-al-Wujood” (The Unity of Being) of the Sufi. Essentially, both mean that everything in the Universe is God.” Afkaar-e-Sir Syed Wa Shibli

Now prepare your mind for an awesome flight. See hundreds of criminals insulting human intelligence in the name of Islam. Watch them making mockery of God, His Messengers, His Guidance and the Laws of Nature. They go as far as their imagination can take them. Watch them play God, produce miracles, bash reason and kill common sense. Their true miracle, however, is that millions of Muslims still consider them as champions of Islam.

Here are some quotes from the Sufi books. Read---enjoy---

I am superior to Prophets and I am higher in rank than they are. (Sheikh Mohiuddin Ibn-Arabi, Hadeeqa Sultania Pg190)
I have denounced Islam. I believe this is incumbent on people. Allah is God sitting in the heavens, I am the God on earth. (Statement of Hussain bin Mansoor Hallaj, Khateeb Baghdadi Vol 8, Ibne Athir chapter 11:140)
Men of knowledge see the Shi’as as swines. (Mohiuddin Ibn-Arabi, Futoohat Makkia 2:8)

Sheikh Imam Abul Hassan Noori was in the company of his disciples. The call to prayers came. The Sheikh said, “It is death.” Then a dog barked. The Sheikh replied, "Labbaik ya Sayyedi!" - Yes, O My Master! (Ibn-e-Jozi Talbees-e-Iblis Pg 383)

My body has merged with the body of Rasulullah. Therefore, we are one. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain)

I recite Surah Fatiha and walk across the river. (Mulfoozat Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri). The strange thing is not their silly claims. It is the people who believe in them.

In the assemblies of "URS" (communion of Sufi souls with God, literally, wedding with God), spirits of the dead Sufis come to dance around. (Mullah Abul Kalam Azad, the late Minister of Education in India. Iman-e-Khalis by Fazil ‘Uloom-e Deeniyah, Dr. Masooduddin Usmani Pg 63)

Allama Shibli Na’mani, Muhammad Husain Azad, Deputy Nazeer Ahmed and Sir Syed Ahmad Khan noted a weird exchange of religious dogmas in the Subcontinent. Centuries ago, the Brahmans (priest class) of India were alarmed as Hindu masses, impressed by the Message of true Monotheism and human equality, were finding Islam irresistible. To safeguard Hinduism, the Brahmans started the “Bhagti” movement in the 11th century, which preached that Raam and Raheem were one. Hindu Yogis befriended Muslim Sufia. They learned tricks from each other and called them “Karamat” and “Chamatkar” (Miracles). Their followers portrayed them as super-humans. Sheikh Sa’di Shirazi has correctly pointed out, “Saints fly not. Their disciples make them fly.”

The end result was a wholesale amalgamation of Islam and Hinduism, giving birth to a new religion that has been termed as the Ittihadi Deen (Unified Faith) by Dr. Usmani. In the process, Hindus who embraced Islam, and Muslims who were exposed to the currents of Vedant (Hindu Mysticism), all remained half-Hindus and half-Muslims. If some Hindus embraced Islam, many Muslims embraced Hinduism. Most Muslims of the subcontinent are in fact followers of the Unified Faith. It is no wonder that Hindus are very respectful of the “Muslim” Sufis.

Here is a glimpse of the Unified Faith: Hindus worship idols, Muslims worship graves. We have ‘Urs instead of Yatra, Tawaf of graves instead of Phairay, Agarbatti in place of Momebatti, Tabarruk versus Prashad, Qawwali versus Bhajan, Araq-e-Gulab versus Gangajal, Kharqa versus Zunnar, and so on. (Iman-e-Khalis by Fazil ‘Uloom-e Deeniyah, Dr. Masooduddin Usmani)

Hazrat Dawood Jawarbi had seen Allah. When asked about Allah, he said, “Ask me not about His genitals and His beard. Ask about anything else.” (Al-Milil-wan-Nahil, Imam Shahristani 1:96). Imam Shahristani should have reported ‘Hazrat’ Jawarbi to the authorities. And the authorities should have painted both as clowns and placed them on donkeys for a ride around the town for spreading such rubbish.

The priest in the church is our Allah. (Sheikh Ibn-Arabi, Qasasul Ulema Pg 53)

There is none else worthy of worship. Come and worship me. (Mullah Jalaluddin Rumi, Mathnawi 4:52)

Time for a hearty laugh: This morning Allah wrestled with me. He floored me because I am 2 years younger than He is. (Abul Hassan Kharqani, Fawaid Faridiya Pg 78)

Alas! The Muslim fails to understand that Allah can be found only in idol worship. (Sufi Mahmood Shabistri, Sharah Gulshan-e-Raz Pg 294)

Hanafis are people who are pacing toward Hellfire. The death anniversary of Imam Husain must be celebrated like the Festival of Eid. (“Piran-e-Pir Dastgeer” - The Saint of saints, Holder of hands - Abdul Qadir Jeelani, Ghania- til-Talibain Pg 190)

My foot is on the neck of every saint. So, I placed my foot on Hazrat Ali's neck. (Abdul Qadir Jeelani, Asrar-ul-Qadam Pg 191)
FACT: Jeelani was exhumed

It is worth recalling that the governor of Baghdad, Ubaidullah Yunus, leveled the home of “Peeraan-e-Peer, Dastgeer” abdul Qadir Jeelani (d. 1166), threw out his sons, exhumed his grave, burnt his remains, and plunged them in the river Tigris in 1170 CE. (Nujoom-uz-Zahrani 6:142)

I hate the God who does not appear as a dog or cat. (Ibn-Arabi, Khazeena Imaniyah Pg 168)
Whenever Khwaja Maudood Chishti desired to see the Ka’bah, angels airlifted it to the land of Chisht in India. (Malfoozat Khwaja Qutubuddin Bukhtiar Kaki, Fariduddin Ganj Shakar). This Khwaja Maudood Chishti is reported to be the ancestor of the famous Mullah-in-Chief of the 20th century, Maududi.
One thousand years have gone and so has the time of Muhammad. Now it is my time, the time of Ahmad. The second millennium is mine. (Sheikh Ahmad Sarhindi, the so-called “Mujaddid Alf-Sani”, Revivalist of the Second Millennium. (Mubda-wa-Ma’ad)

Books of the Tableeghi Nisab “Fazael A’mal” were presented to the exalted Prophet (in the twentieth century!) and he graciously certified them. (Behjatil Quloob Pg 12)

Khwaja Qutbuddin Maudood Chishti’s dead body flew in the air on its way to the graveyard. Khwaja Fareeduddin Ganj Shakar upon narrating this fell unconscious. (Rahatil-Quloob, Ganj Shakar). Ganj Shakar could not bear his own forgery, but he should have expired.

Adam cried for 300 years, so much so that birds made nests on his face. His tears brought forth so much grass that it covered his 60 meters long body. (Rahatul Muhibbeen c/o Ameer Khusro. Khwaja Nizamuddin Awliya)

A bird came and told us, "Tomorrow is Eid. Unlike humans we are free from lies.” Sheikh Faqirullah knew a crow that often learned Monotheism from him. (Reference same)

If Awliya (saints) wish, they can accept invitations from 10,000 towns and be there at the same time. (Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi, Malfoozat part I Pg 127)

When Shah Waliullah was in his mother’s womb, she said a prayer. Two tiny hands appeared from her belly for prayer. She was frightened. Her husband said, "You have Qutubul Aqtab (Saint of Saints) in your womb. (Mullah Ashraf Ali Thanwi, Hikayaat-e-Awliya Pg 17). What a breakthrough!

The Prophet laid the foundation of Darul ‘Uloom, Deoband, India (in the 19th century!) He comes to check the accounts of the Madrasah. He has learnt Urdu from the Ulema of Deoband. (Mubasshirat-e-Darul ‘Uloom and Deoband Number of the Darul ‘Uloom). Was this tale made up to lend credence to the Deoband Mullah factory?

One night I started flying from heaven to heaven until I reached the Prophet. He accepted my allegiance. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain Pg 38-39).

Allah revealed Himself to me as an extremely beautiful, irresistible woman, adorned with fine ornaments and see-through garments. She suddenly embraced me and merged into my body. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain Pg 94-95).

The sun cannot rise before greeting me. The new year, the new month, the new day, cannot dawn without greeting me and informing me of every single event. (Malfoozat Ahmad Raza Barelwi about the exhumed ‘Ghaus Azam’ Abdul Qadir Jeelani)

A wolf was brought before Prophet Jacob. He said to the wolf, “Tell me about my son, Joseph.” The wolf said, “I am an animal, but I do no backbiting.” (Reference same)

Prophet Job prayed, “O God! Give me 12,000 tongues so that I may glorify Your Name.” God accepted his prayer and infested his body with 12,000 insects. (Reference same)

The mosquito that killed King Nimrod (Shaddad) of Babylon was lame. (Malfoozat Chishti). Thanks for the lame information!

Hazrat Uthman brought home a fish. All the firewood was burnt off, but the fish remained fresh (uncooked). When the Prophet asked the reason, the fish said, “I had sent my salutations to you once.” (Reference same)

Shah Waliullah believed in the Unity of Being. He believed that insects, animals, idols and human beings were all God. (Syed Farooq Al-Qadri, Anfasul Arifain)

Allah has only 99 virtuous names. I have more than 99, in fact 4000. (Shah Waliullah quoting his uncle, Anfasul Arifain Pg 210)

Some people told Shah Abdur Raheem (Shah Waliullah’s father) that they were trying to find God. My father said, “I am He!” They stood up and shook hands. (Reference same, Pg 93). Why didn’t they prostrate?

God came to me in a cloak in the guise of an extremely beautiful woman. I became passionate and said, “Cast aside your cloak.” The response came, “The cloak is very thin. It reveals my beauty.” I insisted, upon which the cloak was lifted. (Quote of father and son, Shah Abdur Raheem & Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain Pg 94)

Imam Ahmad Bin Hanbal got his undeserved fame when his ego caused him to suffer lashes for a vain argument with the Abbasi Caliph. (Al-Tawassul Wal Waseela Pg 136). This one sounds true.

The great Pir (master saint) of the 19th century, Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi, has been quoted in his Malfoozat Pg 32, "Prophets are alive in their graves like ever before. They eat, drink, pray and receive their wives in the grave and engage with them in sex."

Now watch God’s retirement plan: Sheikh Abdul Qadir Jeelani claimed: Allah has made me Eternal and has joined me with Him. He has given in my hand this world and the Hereafter and all Creation. (Jeelani, Malfoozat Fuyuz Yazdani,
Fath-e-Rabb-ani, Majlis 51)

PIRAN-E-PIR DASTGEER JEELANI DOOMED! The governor of Baghdad, Ubaidullah Yunus, leveled the home of Jeelani (d. 1166), threw out his sons, exhumed his grave, burnt his remains, and plunged them in the river Tigris (1170 CE). The governor had attained Fatwas against Jeelani that he was a Mushrik and Kaafir. (Nooruddin Shams, a disciple of the Pir Jeelani, Nujoom-uz-Zahrani 6:142). The “Piran-e-Pir”, the eternal master of the universe, could not help himself. Even then, millions of Muslims continue to call Jeelani as Piran-e-Pir ‘Dastgeer’ (The Saint of saints, the Holder of hands).
Prophet David and Prophet Muhammad both sinned because they saw the beauty of unclothed women. Then Uriah’s wife and Zaid’s wife became Haram (forbidden) for their husbands. (Ali Hajweri, alias “Daata Ganj Baksh,” the Giver of Treasures, Kalamil Marghoob Pg 349)
Junaid Baghdadi said that Prophet Solomon was the illegitimate son of David from Uriah’s wife. Sheik Seereen wrote that Surah Ahzab of the Quran means to say that Muhammad (S) was hiding the carnal love of Zainab (the wife of Zaid), in his heart. (Malfoozal Al-‘Asl Pg 219)

A wife of the Prophet (S) saw a male sparrow mounting the female sparrow. She challenged the Prophet. When the night set in, the Prophet mounted her in a most furious manner 90 times and said, “See! There is no deficiency here.” (Shamsuddin Akhlaqi, Manaqib-il-Arifain Pg 70-71). We wonder whether these are sacred writings or pornography!

These dogs and swines are our God. (Fusoosul Hukm, Mohiuddin Ibne Arabi)

Ba-Yazeed Bustami, supposedly the head of all saints, is quoted in his Malfoozat, the book of narratives:

  • I am Glorious, the Ultimate, the Pure. My Glory is beyond description.
  • My Kingdom is greater than the Kingdom of God.
  • Allah is in my pocket.
  • My flag flies higher than the flag of Muhammad.
  • I dived into the sea of Knowledge while the Prophets watched by the shore.

Ali Hajweri, “Daata Ganj Bakhsh,” in his Kashfil Mahjoob, Pg 255-256 supports Ba-Yazeed Bustami's claim that he was God in human form.

Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri taught his disciples a different Kalema (Creed) “There is no god but Allah and Chishti is His Messenger.” (Khwaja Fareed-ud-Din Ganj Shakar, Fawaed-us-Saalikeen Pg 126-127)

Dear reader, if you recapture briefly what you have read so far, it is easy to see why it is important to get rid of these insults from our books, or at least try to neutralize them. Any preaching based on these absurdities leaves a strongly negative impact on our society. They promote human worship and other forms of shirk. They encourage immodesty and degrade women. The Muslim gets further away from the Quran and gets enslaved by superstition and nonsensical themes. It is regrettable that non-Muslims think that this trash represents Islam and then, of course, despise our Deen. In addition, many of our youth get disenchanted with this man-made Islam, and lose their faith.

Now, what message is Sheikh Afeef-ud-Din Talmisani trying to convey when he says: The Quran is loaded with Shirk (idolatry, polytheism). True Monotheism is that everything in the universe is God. (Malfoozat Talmisani Pg 205)

It was right for the Pharaoh to say, “I am God”. He, of course, was a part of the Essence of God. (Reference same)

Ibraheem Adham reached the Ka’bah in 14 years because he prayed two nawafil (units of physical prayer) at every step. But the Ka’bah was not there! A voice came from the heavens, "It has gone to visit Rabia Basri.” (Malfoozat Khwaja Uthman Harooni, Aneesul Arwah Pg 17). Doesn’t it make us think why the Ka’bah could not go to meet the Prophet (S) in Hudaibiyah or Madina? According to Sheikh Afifuddin Talmisani’s Malfoozat Pg 177, Rabia Basri was in romantic love, first with Hasan Basri and then with Ibrahim Adham.

In Cordova, I fell in love with Fatima. In Makkah I fell in love with the beautiful Ain-ush-Shams. The spiritual windows opened upon me hence. (Sheikh Mohiuddin Ibne Arabi, Fusoosul Hukm)

Ba-Yazid Bustami could take the soul of any person whenever he wanted. My uncle Abu Raza Muhammad, upon hearing this became very upset and said, “Ba-Yazid could not return the soul and restore life. I can take a soul and return it as I want.” Then my uncle took the soul of Rahmatullah Kafshdoze and brought him back to life. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Afrifain Pg 95)

Junaid Baghdadi was sitting when a dog crossed by. He merely glanced at the dog which then reached such glory that all dogs of the town followed him. Then he sat down and all dogs sat around him in meditation. (Ashraf Ali Thanwi, Imdadul Mushtaq)

“There is no priesthood in Islam” is a very common but erroneous statement. There should be no priesthood in Islam, but in reality the Sufi and the Mullah have formed a very strong union. They are always ready to attack any semblance of reason from all quarters and they are always vigilant to label any voice of reason as infidelity. Many of them maintain that thinking and reasoning are forbidden in Islam.

The Messenger (S) came to Shah Waliullah (in the 18 century!) and said “Why do you worry, my son? Your children are the same as mine.” (Ashraf Ali Thanwi, Hikayaat-e-Awliya)

It is obligatory upon a mu’min (believer) that he quits eating and drinking. He must get weak to the point where he becomes unable to pray. (Sahl bin Abdullah Tastari, Malfoozat Arabi Pg 289)

Hazrat Sha’raani was the Sheikh of miracles. He resided in a meadow and used to visit the town riding a wolf. He walked on water. His urine was drinkable like pure milk. (Allama Tareshi’s excerpts, Misra’ Tasawwuf Pg 194). Did Tareshi try his milk?

Jalaluddin Rumi never prayed. When the time for prayers came he used to vanish. At last, it was discovered that he used to pray in the Ka’bah - 2000 miles away from Quniah, five times a day. (Khwaja Nizamuddin Awliya, Raahat-il-Quloob). Have you noticed the Sufis patting one another’s back?

My uncle saw me create and destroy the universe. (Shah Waliullah, Afasul Arifain Pg 210)

Once there was a Sheikh who used to grab a dog every day and put him on the prayer rug and said, “O dog, you are in the hands of God!” Those dogs then started walking on water and healed people by giving them Ta’weez (amulets). (Qutubuddin Bakhtiar Kaki, Malfoozat)

Here is a funny one: The dead body of a dervish was lying in a jungle laughing. I asked him, “You are dead. How can you laugh?” The dead body replied, “This is what happens in the love of Allah.” (Khwaja Ghareeb Nawaz, Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri, Malfoozat)

The Universe lies within Koh Qaaf (the Mount Caucasus). This mountain is 40 times bigger than the earth. A cow is holding it on its head. (Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti, Dalilul Arifain). Isn’t it pathetic that people of such miniscule minds are considered the saints of Islam? This mythology is obviously borrowed from Hinduism which holds that the entire earth is perched on one horn of a cow and when it shifts the load to the other horn, earthquakes occur.

The people of Multan refused to provide fire to Shah Shams Tabrez for roasting meat. He became enraged, brought the sun down and roasted the meat. As people became restless with heat, they came to the saint and asked his forgiveness and then he ordered the sun to go back. Since that day, the town became known for its hot summers. (Ali Quli Baghdadi, Karamaat Shah Tabrez Pg 233)

A great saint Hazrat Abdul Wahab went to visit the grave of Pir Syedi Ahmad Kabir. Abdul Wahab saw a beautiful bondwoman. Syedi Kabir called from his grave, “Hey, do you like her?” The owner of the bondwoman instantly dedicated her to the grave. The dead Pir spoke again, "O Abdul Wahab! Take her to the side room and satisfy your desire." (Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi, the greatest master of Islamic law, and Mujaddid, revivalist of Islam for the 19th century, Malfoozat part 3 Pg 28)

Ibraheem Adham was the governor of Balakh. While hunting, a deer turned back and scolded him. Since that day, Adham quit his throne and became a saint. (“Daata” Ganj Bakhsh, the Giver of Treasures, Kalamil Marghoob Pg 229)
When the companions went with the Prophet for Ghazwaat (battles), some of their wives had sex with other men. (Mullah Jalaluddin Rumi, Feeh-Ma-Feeh, Saleem Chishti, Islami Tasawwuf Pg 66). According to a forged Hadith, the Prophet (S) used to advise them not to go home before dawn, saying, “Would any of you like to see his wife in bed with another man?” What an insult to the noble men and women companions, quite contrary to the Quran!

Women are the source of all tribulation in the world, religious or otherwise. (Ali Hajweri “Daata Ganj Bakhsh” in Malfoozat Ahmad Raza Barelwi)

There was a 140 year old worshipper. He had an amputated foot. When asked, he said, “I was in I’tikaaf (seclusion for worship in a Masjid). I stepped one foot out. An angel warned me, and I immediately cut off my foot with a knife.” (Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri in Malfoozat Uthman Harooni)

Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri writes in the same book that the moon and the sun eclipse because of the sins of people! The Prophet (S) had explained that eclipses occur according to Divine Laws in Nature.
A man stole shrouds from graves for 40 years, but he went to the highest degree in Paradise. Why? Because he held on to the prayer rug (he prayed all the time). (Malfoozat Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri, by Khwaja Qutub Alam, Daleel Arifain)
Now, Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti Ajmeri decides to display his prowess in the English language: Where the Quran says, “Fawelullil musalleen” it means there is a “well” for Musalleen, the praying ones… (Reference same)

Watch for more wisdom from Chishti in the same book: The Hellfire is placed in the mouth of a snake deep in the seventh level of the earth. Otherwise the whole Universe would burn.

Khwaja Qutubuddin Bakhtiar Kaki knew half the Quran by heart when he was born. (Fawaaid-as-Salikeen, Khwaja

Fareed-ud-Din “Ganj Shakar”, The Treasure of Sugar). What titanic forces prevented him from completing it?
Fareeduddin “Ganj Shakar” turned bushels of sugar into salt and again into sugar. (The Beloved of God, “Mehboob-e-Elahi”, Khwaja Nizamuddin Awliya, Raahatul Quloob)
Now watch arrogance at its height: The Prophet attended the funeral of Barakat Ahmed. And I led the prayer (the Prophet was his follower in prayer). (Ahmad Raza Khan Barelwi, Malfoozat). Sir Syed Ahmad Khan rightly points out that the supposed Islamic saints were frequently envious of the exalted Prophet.
Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti says, “What do you ask of Koh Qaaf, the Mount Caucasus? This mountain is resting on the head of a cow. The greatness and size of this cow equals 30,000 years of travel. Her head is in the East and her tail in the West. She has been standing since eternity praising the Lord.” Sheikh Uthman Harooni reports that after narrating this (insult to human intelligence), Sheikh Maudood Chishti and a companion sank into deep meditation. Both disappeared leaving their gowns behind. They had gone to take a stroll up the Mount Caucasus. (Malfoozat Khwaja Chishti Ajmeri by Khwaja Bakhtiar Kaki, Daleelul Arifain pPg 85-86). They should have disappeared from the planet.

By God! I know 99 out of 100 thoughts that come in the heart of an ant living in the lowest stratum of the earth. Allah knows all one hundred. (Shah Waliullah, Anfasul Arifain Pg 205)

“Maulana” Ashraf Ali Thanwi separated the way of Salaat between men and women in his book “Bahishti Zaiwar”. (Muhammad Sultan, Masjid Tauheed, Karachi)

Do not try to understand the Quran ever! Else, you will go astray. Fifteen ‘Uloom” (Sciences) are required to understand the Book. (“Maulana” Zakaria Kandhalwi, Fazaael A’maal Pg 2). The Quran claims that it is an easy book to understand, and it is (41:3). But the Mullahs and Sufis want the masses to remain oblivious to the Glorious Book."

Source
And also based on this how can you not say they are not as IF not worse than Qaidianis?
 

FahadBhatti

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Tum mein se behtereen wo hai jiss ke ikhlaq achay hain


ye baat humare beshtar ulmaae deen ke ser se guzar jaatee he... doosre ulmaa ki terha engineer mirza bhi badtehzeeb aur badikhlaq hai..

jis terha shia , sunni , deobandi aur ahlehadith din raat ek doosre per laan taan kerte rehte hen .. isi terha engineer mirza bhi apni zaban per qabu nahin rakh sakta.

ilm ke saath saath amal ka hona bhi zarooree he werna aap ki baat interesting zaroor ho sakti he lekin pur asar nahin.

kya faida aise fans ka jo in logon ko defend kerne ke liye ek dusre ki tawazuh hee galion se kerte hon.

agar ders dena hai to pehle ikhlaqiat , sabar aur lehje mein haleemi ka ders den.
 

Pakistani1947

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
ہاہاہا..ارے واه جی واه ! آپ تو بڑے استاد نکلے؟
یعنی در پردہ آپ نے ایک اچھی خاصی دلچسپ جگت
کر بھی دی اور کسی کا نام بھی نہیں لیا؟ یہ فن تو کوئی
آپ سے سیکھے؟.....@Pakistani1947
OK, very short this time a Sufi Scholar, Tahir ul Qadri's picture which equals 1000 words. And two hadeeths without my comments. How about that?




Sunnan e Abu Dawood - 2140
میں حیرہ آیا، تو دیکھا کہ لوگ اپنے سردار کو سجدہ کر رہے ہیں تو میں نے کہا: رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم اس کے زیادہ حقدار ہیں کہ انہیں سجدہ کیا جائے، میں جب آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کی خدمت میں حاضر ہوا تو میں نے آپ سے کہا کہ میں حیرہ شہر آیا تو میں نے وہاں لوگوں کو اپنے سردار کے لیے سجدہ کرتے ہوئے دیکھا تو اللہ کے رسول! آپ اس بات کے زیادہ مستحق ہیں کہ ہم آپ کو سجدہ کریں، آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا: بتاؤ کیا اگر تم میری قبر کے پاس سے گزرو گے، تو اسے بھی سجدہ کرو گے؟ وہ کہتے ہیں: میں نے کہا: نہیں، آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا: تم ایسا نہ کرنا، اگر میں کسی کو کسی کے لیے سجدہ کرنے کا حکم دیتا تو عورتوں کو حکم دیتا کہ وہ اپنے شوہروں کو سجدہ کریں اس وجہ سے کہ شوہروں کا حق اللہ تعالیٰ نے مقرر کیا ہے ۔
Source: Islam360

The Messenger of Allaah, sallAllaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, said: “Whoever loves that the people appear before him standing (up for him), then let him find his seat in the Hellfire.” Reported by Al-Bukhaaree in Al-Adab-ul-Mufrad (977) and others
Source: Fataawaa of Shaikh Al-Albaanee [Al-Asaalah, Issue #20]

Urdu Translation of above Hadeeth:
جو شخص یہ پسند کرتا ہے کہ لوگ اس کے سامنے کھڑے ہوکر حاضر ہو جائیں ، پھر اسے جہنم میں اپنی جگہ تلاش کرنے دو۔" الحدیث


 
Last edited:

Pakistani1947

Chief Minister (5k+ posts)
Tum mein se behtereen wo hai jiss ke ikhlaq achay hain


ye baat humare beshtar ulmaae deen ke ser se guzar jaatee he... doosre ulmaa ki terha engineer mirza bhi badtehzeeb aur badikhlaq hai..

jis terha shia , sunni , deobandi aur ahlehadith din raat ek doosre per laan taan kerte rehte hen .. isi terha engineer mirza bhi apni zaban per qabu nahin rakh sakta.

ilm ke saath saath amal ka hona bhi zarooree he werna aap ki baat interesting zaroor ho sakti he lekin pur asar nahin.

kya faida aise fans ka jo in logon ko defend kerne ke liye ek dusre ki tawazuh hee galion se kerte hon.

agar ders dena hai to pehle ikhlaqiat , sabar aur lehje mein haleemi ka ders den.

What do you expect from a devoted Muslim who see his fellow Muslims are following the Babas whose Books have following Gustakhana statements:

For example:
"Chishti Rasool Allah" - khawaja Moin uddin Chishti
"Ashraf Rasool Allah" - Ashraf Ali Thanwi
There is none else worthy of worship. Come and worship me.
(Mullah Jalaluddin Rumi, Mathnawi 4:52)

This morning Allah wrestled with me. He floored me because I am 2 years younger than He is. (Abul Hassan Kharqani, Fawaid Faridiya Pg 78)

Sahih Muslim - 2005
عبد الوہاب بن عبد المجید ( ثقفی ) نے جعفر ( صادق ) بن محمد ( باقر ) سے روایت کی انھوں نے اپنے والد سے اور انھوں نے حضرت جابر بن عبد اللہ رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ سے روایت کی انھوں نے کہا : رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم جب خطبہ دیتے تو آپ کی آنکھیں سرخ ہو جا تیں ، آواز بلند ہو جا تی اور جلال کی کیفیت طاری ہو جا تی تھی حتیٰ کہ ایسا لگتا جیسے آپ کسی لشکر سے ڈرا رہے ہیں فر ما رہے ہیں کہ وہ ( لشکر ) صبح یا شام ( تک ) تمھیں آلے گا اور فر ما تے میں اور قیامت اس طرح بھیجے گئے ہیں اور آپ اپنی انگشت شہادت اور درمیانی انگلی کو ملا کر دکھا تے اور فر ما تے ۔ ( حمدو صلاۃ ) کے بعد بلا شبہ بہترین حدیث ( کلام ) اللہ کی کتاب ہے اور زندگی کا بہترین طریقہ محمد صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کا طریقہ زندگی ہے اور ( دین میں ) بد ترین کام وہ ہیں جو خود نکا لے گئے ہوں اور ہر نیا نکا لا ہوا کا م گمراہی ہے پھر فر ما تے : میں ہر مو من کے ساتھ خود اس کی نسبت زیادہ محبت اور شفقت رکھنے والا ہوں۔ جو کو ئی ( مومن اپنے بعد ) مال چھوڑ گیا تو وہ اس کے اہل و عیال ( وارثوں ) کا ہے اور جو مومن قرض یا بے سہارا اہل و عیال چھوڑ گیا تو ( اس قرض کو ) میری طرف لو ٹا یا جا ئے ( اور اس کے کنبے کی پرورش ) میرے ذمے ہے ۔
 

Citizen X

President (40k+ posts)
Tum mein se behtereen wo hai jiss ke ikhlaq achay hain


ye baat humare beshtar ulmaae deen ke ser se guzar jaatee he... doosre ulmaa ki terha engineer mirza bhi badtehzeeb aur badikhlaq hai..

jis terha shia , sunni , deobandi aur ahlehadith din raat ek doosre per laan taan kerte rehte hen .. isi terha engineer mirza bhi apni zaban per qabu nahin rakh sakta.

ilm ke saath saath amal ka hona bhi zarooree he werna aap ki baat interesting zaroor ho sakti he lekin pur asar nahin.

kya faida aise fans ka jo in logon ko defend kerne ke liye ek dusre ki tawazuh hee galion se kerte hon.

agar ders dena hai to pehle ikhlaqiat , sabar aur lehje mein haleemi ka ders den.
What good is all the "ikhlaq" and "thezeeb" of such Ulema and Moulvis when they teach and preach such shirk and idolatry?
 

Saboo

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
OK, very short this time a Sufi Scholar, Tahir ul Qadri's picture which equals 1000 words. And two hadeeths without my comments. How about that?




میں حیرہ آیا، تو دیکھا کہ لوگ اپنے سردار کو سجدہ کر رہے ہیں تو میں نے کہا: رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم اس کے زیادہ حقدار ہیں کہ انہیں سجدہ کیا جائے، میں جب آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کی خدمت میں حاضر ہوا تو میں نے آپ سے کہا کہ میں حیرہ شہر آیا تو میں نے وہاں لوگوں کو اپنے سردار کے لیے سجدہ کرتے ہوئے دیکھا تو اللہ کے رسول! آپ اس بات کے زیادہ مستحق ہیں کہ ہم آپ کو سجدہ کریں، آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا: بتاؤ کیا اگر تم میری قبر کے پاس سے گزرو گے، تو اسے بھی سجدہ کرو گے؟ وہ کہتے ہیں: میں نے کہا: نہیں، آپ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم نے فرمایا: تم ایسا نہ کرنا، اگر میں کسی کو کسی کے لیے سجدہ کرنے کا حکم دیتا تو عورتوں کو حکم دیتا کہ وہ اپنے شوہروں کو سجدہ کریں اس وجہ سے کہ شوہروں کا حق اللہ تعالیٰ نے مقرر کیا ہے ۔

The Messenger of Allaah, sallAllaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, said: “Whoever loves that the people appear before him standing (up for him), then let him find his seat in the Hellfire.” Reported by Al-Bukhaaree in Al-Adab-ul-Mufrad (977) and others
Source: Fataawaa of Shaikh Al-Albaanee [Al-Asaalah, Issue #20]

Urdu Translation of above Hadeeth:
جو شخص یہ پسند کرتا ہے کہ لوگ اس کے سامنے کھڑے ہوکر حاضر ہو جائیں ، پھر اسے جہنم میں اپنی جگہ تلاش کرنے دو۔" الحدیث


Ok very short....Jo koi bhi ghalat karay ga wohi bharay ga bhi..Na mein na tum!
 

Saboo

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Ok very short...lame very lame, according to you then all dawah should also stop.
That is non sense? I never said that...I only said only those people will be held accountable who do some thing wrong. To do dawah is not wrong? Actually muslims were asked to do that (in Quran)...meaning....Among you there should be people who go out asking people to stop doing bad deeds and advise them to do good. Now how could that be bad?
 

Citizen X

President (40k+ posts)
I only said only those people will be held accountable who do some thing wrong.
Kuffar and Mushriks are also doing something wrong and will be held accountable.

To do dawah is not wrong? Actually muslims were asked to do that (in Quran)...meaning
And doing islah for Muslim who hold mushrik and kuffar beliefs is also dawah.

Among you there should be people who go out asking people to stop doing bad deeds and advise them to do good.
That's exactly what's being done here too.

Now how could that be bad?
Yes how could it be bad?
 

Saboo

Prime Minister (20k+ posts)
Kuffar and Mushriks are also doing something wrong and will be held accountable.


And doing islah for Muslim who hold mushrik and kuffar beliefs is also dawah.


That's exactly what's being done here too.


Yes how could it be bad?
Oh man? I don't know what you are trying to say?...Anyways we should leave it like that.
 

Citizen X

President (40k+ posts)
Oh man? I don't know what you are trying to say?...Anyways we should leave it like that.
Why? Have you forgotten to read English all of a sudden or what, that you don't know what I'm trying to say? I'm just saying what you said. Who even is doing wrong leave him alone, so leave everyone alone. That would also include dawah.