Takrar - 18th August 2012 - Mufti Abdul Qavi vs Maulana Tahir Ashrafi - "Chaand Nazr Aya Ya Nahi Aya?"

[Sher]

[Believer12]

اسلامی یکجھتی کا مظاہرہ ابھی صرف دو علما بات کر رھے ھیں،،،اگر تین ملین علما مل گئے تو کسقدر یکجھتی کا مظاھرھ ھوگا سبحان اللہ،،،،قوم کوی پرواھ نھیں جب گورنمنٹ اعلان کرے وھ عید منا لیتے ھیں پر علما کیوں اس بات پر جذباتی ھو جاتے ھیں سمجھ سے باھر ھے

[Sohraab]

اسلامی یکجھتی کا مظاہرہ ابھی صرف دو علما بات کر رھے ھیں،،،اگر تین ملین علما مل گئے تو کسقدر یکجھتی کا مظاھرھ ھوگا سبحان اللہ،،،،قوم کوی پرواھ نھیں جب گورنمنٹ اعلان کرے وھ عید منا لیتے ھیں پر علما کیوں اس بات پر جذباتی ھو جاتے ھیں سمجھ سے باھر ھے

aap ne agar yeh Show dekha hai to phir itna bhi bata dain ke koon sa aalim tha in teenon main jis ne dosre ki baat bhi kaati aur dosra jub bol raha tha to woh NON stop bolta raha .. Batao bhai koon tha ???? ... In teenon main se sirf aik aalim ne yeh kaam kia hai

[hawkeyeblue]

No worries More the Merrier, just think this way do we pray at the same time, on so there is no compulsion to have one Eid. We have more important things to be united on.

[Jshah]

Muneeb should be immediately removed from this position to avoid further disgusting.
Muneeb is so arrogant and denying the practices of Quran and Sunnat.

[_pakistan]

abhi tou kuch ulma hakumati ohdon per hain,tou ye haal hey inka. ager ye khalafat laey aaye ,jo key namumkin hey tou ye mulik ka kia hashar karain gey?

bus ye sirf inqilaab ka naara hi lagatey rahain. aur qoum ko bewqoof banatey rahain.

Wesey chand dekhney main ulma ka kia kaam hey?kia ye mahre falkiaat hain?

[Jshah]

What else can you expect from these paid Mullas???

[Just_one]

The argument is right.

- If the determination of moon is to be made by scientific experts, then abolish "Rohit-e-Hilaal" committee and stop wasting taxpayer money on it.

- And if the traditional method of sighting is to be adopted, that is, a person who qualifies on a certain standard gives his testimony - then that should be accepted, whether it is from KPK, Baluchistan, PUnjab, Sindh or other parts of Pakistan.

[Believer12]

aap ne agar yeh Show dekha hai to phir itna bhi bata dain ke koon sa aalim tha in teenon main jis ne dosre ki baat bhi kaati aur dosra jub bol raha tha to woh NON stop bolta raha .. Batao bhai koon tha ???? ... In teenon main se sirf aik aalim ne yeh kaam kia hai

main nay yeh baat note nahi ki aap hi bata do mugh trust hai.

[devilzzzprey]

Happy Eid Mubarik from my side

[Sohraab]

main nay yeh baat note nahi ki aap hi bata do mugh trust hai.

Main bata deta hoon .. aap dobara show dekh lena agar aap ke liye possible ho to phir mujhe bata dena ke main theek keh raha hoon yah ghalat

Mufti abdulqavi ne sab se pehle baat kaati aur non stop tab bolta raha jub dosre ki baari thi

[Believer12]

Main bata deta hoon .. aap dobara show dekh lena agar aap ke liye possible ho to phir mujhe bata dena ke main theek keh raha hoon yah ghalat

Mufti abdulqavi ne sab se pehle baat kaati aur non stop tab bolta raha jub dosre ki baari thi

yes you are correct.

[GHULAM NABI]

Muneeb should be immediately removed from this position to avoid further disgusting.
Muneeb is so arrogant and denying the practices of Quran and Sunnat.

Calculations, moon sighting and taking advice for sighting from scientists by Natonal Royat-e-Halal Committe are surety (haqqul-yaqeen), while claims of sighting by Leaders of Masjid Qasim Bagh may be suspicion (zann) or mistake. In the present era of scientific and technological advancement, four decades after man landed on the moon, why some of our Muslim brothers of Masjid Qasim Bagh are still avoiding to accept scientific knowledge, decesion of Natonal Royat-e-Halal Committe and advice on moon sighting?

[Sohraab]

yes you are correct.

Woh agar sacha hota to yeh harkat kabhi na karta

us ke dosre Saathi Mufti Muneeb ne aaj 3 channels par phone line kaati aur bhaag gaya

[Sohraab]

Calculations, moon sighting and taking advice for sighting from scientists by Natonal Royat-e-Halal Committe are surety (haqqul-yaqeen), while claims of sighting by Leaders of Masjid Qasim Bagh may be suspicion (zann) or mistake. In the present era of scientific and technological advancement, four decades after man landed on the moon, why some of our Muslim brothers of Masjid Qasim Bagh are still avoiding to accept scientific knowledge, decesion of Natonal Royat-e-Halal Committe and advice on moon sighting?

Tum ko kis Bewaqoof ne kaha hai ke Masjid Qsim khan ke kisi Leader ne chand dekha hai ??????????????

Woh to masjid main baithay rehte hain aur un ke Pass gawah khud aate hain

[Believer12]

Woh agar sacha hota to yeh harkat kabhi na karta

us ke dosre Saathi Mufti Muneeb ne aaj 3 channels par phone line kaati aur bhaag gaya

iss commette k ilawa bhi to Eid manai ja sakti hai maloom nahi kiun millions ka budget in per lagatey hain?

[awais8804]

Yar Ye Mufti Doebandi Ha Ye Kabhi Mufti Moneeb Ki Bat Nhi mane Ga Or Ye Jo Anchor Ha Ye Anti PakisTani Ha Aese D-ogs Ki Wajah Se Pakistani Qom Taqseem Hoti Ha.

[GHULAM NABI]

Calculations, moon sighting and taking advice for sighting from scientists by Natonal Royat-e-Halal Committe are surety (haqqul-yaqeen), while claims of sighting by Leaders of Masjid Qasim Bagh may be suspicion (zann) or mistake. In the present era of scientific and technological advancement, four decades after man landed on the moon, why some of our Muslim brothers of Masjid Qasim Bagh are still avoiding to accept scientific knowledge, decesion of Natonal Royat-e-Halal Committe and advice on moon sighting?

[GHULAM NABI]

Tum ko kis Bewaqoof ne kaha hai ke Masjid Qsim khan ke kisi Leader ne chand dekha hai ??????????????

Woh to masjid main baithay rehte hain aur un ke Pass gawah khud aate hain

Evidence is accepted only if what is testified for is possible physically, logically and legally. If we assume that calculation indicates with certainty the impossibility of sighting, then a testimony of sighting must be rejected because it testifies to what is impossible. Islamic law does not make impossible requirements.

[Sohraab]

iss commette k ilawa bhi to Eid manai ja sakti hai maloom nahi kiun millions ka budget in per lagatey hain?

mujhe kisi ne kaha hai mufti muneeb ki per moth Sallery 4 lack 50 thousand hai .. Allah behtar jane yeh sach hai yah Jhoot